Preview

Discuss Two or More Explanations for the Success and/or Failure of Dieting (9+16 Marks)

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
674 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Discuss Two or More Explanations for the Success and/or Failure of Dieting (9+16 Marks)
Discuss two or more explanations for the success and/or failure of dieting (9+16 marks)
Dieting is increasingly popular as people try to fit into the thin western ideal of beauty. Theories for the failure of dieting include the restraint theory, while it has been suggested that the key to success is the amount of attention we give to the detail of our food.
The restraint theory (Herman and Mack) suggests that restraining our food intake actually increases the risk of overeating, which is why many diets fail and some people even end up putting more weight on. Herman and Polivy (1984) developed the boundary model to explain this. According to this model, dieters have a larger range between their hunger and satiety levels, so it takes them longer to feel hungry and they need to eat more food to be satisfied. Dieters also have a self imposed desirable level of food intake. When they perceive themselves to have gone beyond this level, they experience the disinhibition effect and continue to eat until satisfied. They are more likely to perceive themselves as going over this level if it is something ‘forbidden’ (e.g. cake).
This theory is supported by a study by Herman and Mack (1975). They had restrained and non-restrained women of normal weight eat zero, one or two milkshakes. The participants were then allowed to eat as much ice cream as they wanted. For non-restrained eaters, the results were as expected; those more ate more milkshake, ate less ice cream, as they were closer to their satiety level. For restrained eaters however, those who ate more milkshake ate more ice cream; this is the disinhibition effect. This shows that a food preload (e.g. milkshake) often results in overeating for those restraining their food intake. However, this study is gender biased as it only involves women. The results can therefore not be generalised to both genders. This study also ignores individual differences (e.g. some women may just enjoy ice cream more than others) so the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    A dietician is a health professional who gives advice about nutrition and swallowing or feeding…

    • 99 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Dieting makes everything worse, for the chances are high that fat people will fail. They will be saddened and frustrated by their failures” (Schwartz 180). She gives us her view of a fat society. This society is one, which in fact only fat people reside. No no more vindication on people with larger size.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this essay I am going to be looking into and assessing possible influences on an individual’s diet, how this affects their health and then making recommendations to minimise the negative influences. I’m going to be looking at 4 separate case studies to do this with.…

    • 1926 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Food is essential for life but what we eat is subject to a wide range of influences. Recognising these and taking account of them when planning menus and preparing food can make the difference between and individual eating sufficiently for their needs or not”.…

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the major causes for obesity is overeating. The stability between calorie ingestion and energy outflow determines a person's weight. If a person is ingesting more…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Chapter 1 of Mindless Eating by Brian Wansink, PH.D., the statement "We overeat because there are signals and cues around us that tell us to eat." is discussed. Wansinks main focus is on how cues influence each of the multitude of food decisions that we make each day. Cheeseburger, fries, and Coke, or grilled chicken, rice and veggies? Strawberries and yogurt, or pie and ice cream for desert? Munch on a snack while lounging in front of the television, or sip a bottle of water? As stated in the title "Mindless" Eating the cues that influence and direct these decisions are unconscious.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lawmakers should impose restraints on the amount of sugar each person ingests. In the text Sugar Lobby to Aggressively Oppose World Health Organization's Diet Report the author states “Most people don't calculate numbers when drinking soft drinks or eating baked foods, such as cookies and cakes, which are laden with added sugars. She also warns that many low-fat foods are also high in sugar.” This can show us that if we do not have restraints on sugar know one will pay attention to how much they consume. An average person doesn’t know how much sugar is in each food or drink they have, which makes it hard for us to cut back on are own. In the article it says “Eating too much of these foods is storing up health problems for their future.” This shows that lawmakers should put a restraint on sugar because kids are a part of the problem and it is progressively affecting people who eat foods that contain a lot of sugar. Sugar can affect you when you are older or right away. This makes it hard for people to know if they are injected with too much sugar. If lawmakers make restraints then it is harder for people to get more then there body should get. Sugars can lead to 7 different concerning areas; cancer, cholesterol, diabetes, diet, hyper activity, obesity, and tooth decay. Therefore, since there is not one outcome to the effects of sugar it is harder to stop it without restraints. For example, if your hose has a leak you put a piece of duck tape on it and then it’s ok because it has no other things wrong with it. What if you had the same hose but with 5 holes instead of one? what if you only had that one…

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    f. Dietary Restraint – People are Constantly thinking about Food While Dieting, so Overindulge More.…

    • 1166 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    The following is a paper about the psychological, biological and cultural factors that combine to influence the overweight and the obese. The reader will learn of the many different mental affects that an individual has to deal with when facing food consumption issues. Biological influences pertain to genetics and brain activity that control an individual’s hunger. Culturally, an individual’s society through media and peers also play a role in how someone manages their appetite. These factors combine to create a vicious cycle that a person must deal with on a daily basis when facing overweight and obesity issues.…

    • 2581 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Obesity Unit 2 Essay

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Obesity is known to be one of the most public health disorder concerned globally. Some of the factors that impact obesity socially is greater exposure to fast-food advertisements, limited access to physical activity opportunities, and poor individual choices/ lifestyle choices. Furthermore according to the article, sociodemographic (age, race, ethnicity, and language) plays a huge role in obesity. For instance, low-income families are likely to face more challenges and become obese due to not being able to eat healthy. These factors of social impact and individual choices also impact biological reasons. For example, due to an individual’s choice of living and…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Metabolic Diet Essay

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages

    One of the challenges with most diets that are based on decreasing the total number of calories being consumed is sustaining a high metabolism. Our metabolism is responsible for burning through calories, but when the caloric content of our food is reduced, our bodies shift gears and decrease their calorie consumption. This results in that feeling of sluggishness and tiredness that is common among most dieters, meaning we become less efficient at burning calories. What a metabolic diet does is raise the metabolism to speed up the burning of calories, which equates to a faster weight loss rate. This method of dieting is much more effective than what essentially amounts to starving yourself. But if you are dieting to lose weight, how can you avoid…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Why Sugar Is Bad

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The balance between healthy and unhealthy foods are prone in your body and once you make changes, behavior starts to change also. For example, a quote says, “I had never felt so stressed, tired, and worn down.” This is caused by post pregnancy and having to change the diet that was being eaten. I think that having a constant and persistent eating schedule, with the same nutrients everyday, your body will adapt that and if taking out sugars or other unhealthy foods, will cause behavior…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What, When and How to Eat

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Yes, I believe my personal experiences support these concepts discussed in 12.3 of the reading material. The Learned Taste Preference and Aversion section describes that nutrition has little direct effect on our feelings of hunger. Many of us prefer to eat food that are culturally specific to us. This is something I agree with. For example I am half Mexican I enjoy spicy foods but my boyfriend and his children are not use to this type of food, while I think it’s good they do not like the taste because they have had different foods based on their culture. This does influence what we eat. Now on to when we eat, I do believe when we eat has to do with “cultural norms, work schedules, family routines, personal preferences, wealth, and a variety of other factors.” ( Biopsychology, John P.J. Pinel) The chapter also states on how we have certain feelings or attacks of malaise, as the reading calls it, when we miss a regularly scheduled meal. This happens to me, I feel nausea. Last factors that influence how much we eat. The reading material states that when we stop eating a meal before the food is gone is called satiety. “Satiety mechanism plays a major role in determining how much we eat.” (Biopsychology, John P.J.Pinel)This section also states that the way we feel about food and our personal experiences with food also influences how much we eat (not just our physical need for food but our physiological need for food affects how much we eat.) Also our social settings has an effect on how much we eat. I know this to be true because I am about 20lbs overweight and in social setting I eat less. I do not want others to think I eat too much. This…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lifetime of student debt

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When it comes to the topic of nutrition, most of us agree that in order to live a long healthy life one must eat right and choose nutritious alternatives to preserved and fast food products. The incredibly complicated and confusing question of what we humans should eat in order to be maximally healthy is a huge problem that lingers in our every day lives. In recent discussions of nutrition, a controversial issue has been whether obesity is determined by the food industry or the way we eat. Some are convinced that trusting yourself and your body will lead to better choices, others argue that eating food in moderation and more fruits and vegetables is the path to choose. In this day and age, there are many different debates on what one can do to eat healthier and make better decisions in regard to diet. Many people have proposed their own theories and advice on beginning a healthier lifestyle, such as Mary Maxfield and Michael Pollan.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Diet Analysis

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Analyzing a diet can be very complicated. There are many programs and sources on the internet to give the information needed on the correct amount of food groups and vitamins we need for our bodies. By using the program My Diet Analysis, you are able to gather data containing information from My Plate, macronutrient information, micronutrient information and your actual intake vs your recommended intake on certain food groups. I am also on the fertility diet which is higher in protein, low in carbohydrates, only whole grain and no dairy products. By inputting my information in the MyDiet analysis program I gathered a lot of data that I found intriguing.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics