Preview

Edward I Koch Death Penalty Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1598 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Edward I Koch Death Penalty Analysis
The death penalty has been a continuous argument that has been debated throughout history. This topic can be seen and heard in novels, articles, journals, essays, and speeches. There seem to be two primary sides on the death penalty. One side argues the idea that the death penalty should be practiced, which can be seen in Edward I. Koch in his essay, Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life. The opposing side believes that people should not permit killing other people as a form of punishment; this is illustrated in The Death Penalty by David Bruck. After analyzing the two essays, I came to the conclusion that David Bruck's essay proves his claim in a more effective and efficient manner than Edward I. Koch. Both sides of the …show more content…
In the essay, Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life, Koch’s main goal is to make the readers feel that they need to act on this issue. He does this by making a connection between the reader and the neighbors who did nothing when a woman was being raped and murdered. This connection is a little extreme, but it is effective. It makes the reader feel responsible in a sense like they have a duty to protect people (Koch 487). Koch also displays the criminals in the worst possible light. When he displays Luis Vera as showing no guilt about killing someone, it makes the reader feel no sympathy towards him. Therefore the reader feels a sense that he should be killed (Koch 484). Pathos can be seen in Bruck’s essay as well. Bruck makes the reader feel guilty when he points out that if one supports the death penalty, they are in a sense celebrating and encouraging a death of another human being (Bruck 490). He states that Alvin Ford during the year on death-row lost his mind (Bruck 491). The example of Ford makes the reader feel bad or depressed for Ford and his state of mind during the years he had to spend knowing he would be put to death. The two essays tugs on the reader's emotions in an effective

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The tittle “The Death Penalty: Justice for None” the author provokes a feeling to the readers of compassion and empathy making it seem like the death penalty is completely ignorant and wrong no matter what the consequence of the criminal is. The authors opinion about the death penalty is that the death penalty in the united states shouldn’t even be considered an option because it is cruel and unjust.…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I can both agree and dissagree with Edward Koch 's opinions in his essay called Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life. Some of the arguments that he has presented seemed valid, however, he didn 't supply enough facts to back up what he was saying for many of his examples. It seemed to me that most of what Edward Koch was saying had more to do with his own opinion on capital punishment than on any type of reasearch he has done on the topic.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    He shows his opinion towards a statement made by an individual against capital punishment. Koch believes the death penalty will help the innocent people be safer. By executing the murderer, there will be no chance of him or her being released and committing another crime. Koch’s argument is effective because precautions should be taken when the lives of innocent citizens are in danger. In New Jersey, Richard Biegenwald served eighteen years in prison. After serving the years in prison for murder, Beigenwald was freed. He has been convicted of committing four murders since his release (485). Another example Koch uses to support his argument is that New York has no death penalty statue. In one year, New York arrested eighty-five people for homicide. All of these people had been arrested for murder previously in their lives (486). Using these examples to support his argument was very effective because it shows the reader what could eventually happen without capital…

    • 439 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The death penalty is a very controversial topic that some may oppose while others assent. I have read two interesting essays about the death penalty. One is entitled “The Penalty of Death” by H.L Mencken and the other “Execution” by Anna Quindlen. Both authors presented their arguments and used great points to support their opinions. H.L Mencken is for the death penalty while Anna Quindlen is against it. After reading these two authors work I was able to form my own opinion on this punishment. I condone the death penalty despite how cruel it may be.…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arguments on capital punishment have been around for centuries, and will continue to be so. Providing adequate punishment to those that take a human life must be approached very carefully. David Bruck wrote a response to Mayor Edward Koch's essay entitled, "Death and Justice: How Capital Punishment Affirms Life," in which he goes on to explain through examples why the death penalty should be forgotten. In Bruck's response, "No Death Penalty," he provides many examples, but few arguments to support why the death penalty should be abolished.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Capital Punishment is regarded as one of the United States' hottest topics. Those for and against it constantly debate over the various issues that capital punishment brings forth. This essay explains just a few of these topics and my view on the death penalty.…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Where there is society there have always been criminals, ones that would cause grief among others for the benefit of themselves. Accurately accessing the integrity of a nation includes how it deals with its criminals. In American circumstances, it is to kill them. “What Will Doom the Death Penalty” which was published in 2014, is an article by the New York Times enlightening left-wing ideas on capital punishment. The author of the article is Daniel LaChance, who is currently a history professor at Emory University.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article “Death Penalty” by Robert Kiener gives the public a summary of what the people think about the death penalty and why is should or should not be allowed. This article starts by saying how the Boston Marathon bomber started up the debate about the death penalty being or not being allowed again and how less of the people who used to support the death penalty now no longer support it any more. Then, Robert writes that Nebraska is thinking about stopping the death penalty and how it would be interesting to see the result this will have on the people. Afterword’s Robert talks about how much the death penalty cost and the money that could be saved if stopped, there is also the fact of innocent people being accused of crimes they have not commented in the past. Next, it states how death sentences have been going down anyways and put on hold because of…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The article “To Kill or Not to Kill” by Scott Turrow was written to examine the fairness and effectiveness of the capital punishment system. The author believes that it is important to address this issue because the current system is very flawed and cannot be trusted with consistent results, the author looked closely for the arguments of for and against the death penalty . In one of the first arguments that ambivalence in the death penalty is something that people have struggled through throughout the years, he uses statistics and percentages as well as emotional appeal to point people who are both for and against the death penalty in the same direction, As Turrow’s said “Many Americans question the system's over-all fairness and its ability…

    • 145 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Koch’s has a long history in the political arena. He served as: mayor, district leader, lawyer, congressman and councilman. His years of public service offered his audience a sense of trust and credibility toward his views. He begins by assuring those opposed to the death penalty, that he has studied, listened and considered their views completely, but he still believes in the death penalty as a means to the practice of social justice. His values and beliefs, nonetheless, are for protecting the precious lives of the innocent and upholding justice in our society. Overall his essay is a keen definition of social and humanitarian justice.…

    • 1282 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The death penalty has been an ongoing debate on whether it should be allowed or whether it violates our constitutional right. While most developed Western nations have stopped executing the United States continues to execute offenders (Zimring 2004). From 1977 through 2008 1,136 people have been executed, which consisted of people who committed murder (Procon 2010). Those who are in favor of the death penalty believe it is an important tool to help deter crime and it cost less than life imprisonment (Procon 2010). They believe retribution helps console the grieving family and it also ensures that the offender will never be able to commit another heinous crime (Procon 2010). According to Grant (2004) some people believe that some offenders should face the death penalty because of vengeance and retribution for violent crimes. During the…

    • 1847 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The issue that I chose to write about in my paper is the Death Penalty. The Death Penalty has been a serious issue that has recurrently caused so much conflict in our world today. My argument is that the death penalty is very important to bring justice pertaining to murderers. This issue with the death penalty is one of the highest arguments in the United States. The death penalty is something that countless individuals do not have an unclouded opinion on. The death penalty dates all the way back to 1622.…

    • 2428 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The death penalty is an extremely controversial topic in America, and people usually shy away from it, but speaking about controversial topics can help us come close to actually find solutions. This exercise was conducted in my survey of law class in which, we had gone over several homicide cases in which the criminal received the death penalty. In the end of the lesson, our teacher asked a simple question “raise your hand if you believe in the death penalty”. I was appalled to see that more than half believed it was worth it. In my mind it was clear that even though that person could have murdered another human being, we have no jurisdiction to kill them, and we would be no better as civilized being if we killed him.…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The death penalty is a major topic for debate Shannon Rafferty defends in her portfolio published by Penn State entitled “Death Penalty Persuasive Essay.” She believes the penalty should be allowed because it functions as a deterrent, it provides society retribution and it is morally just. Olivia H. disagrees with use of the death penalty in her essay “Capital Punishment Is Dead wrong.” She tells about the risk of punishing the innocent, and how the states are doing irreversible acts of crime. As the authors disagree about whether the death penalty should be allowed, they have some common ground when it comes to admitting the potential for human error and in both disagreeing to the use of barbaric punishments by the government.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Shame

    • 545 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I agree with the writer, "Death and Justice", it is very effective at proving how the death penalty ensures to protect the lives of innocent people and justifying the actions made by murderers. In Koch's essay, he describes how the American population does not support capital punishment. There are many people who do not believe that the death penalty is a consequence beneficial for the justice of murders. Many believe that capital punishment makes a human's life seem cheaper than it is. While others say that the methods of the death penalty are barbaric. And there are some that argue the United States is the only democracy that uses the death penalty as a consequence for murder. There are a few murderers that are prime examples for why the death penalty should be the only result for murder. Edward Koch's essay was a very good argument on the death…

    • 545 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays