This essay will attempt to identify, analyze and discuss the strategic issues in Geely Holding Group using industry structure and dynamics. There are five competitive forces that shape the strategy of a company, threat of new entrants, bargaining power of supplier, bargaining power of buyers, threat of substitute and rivalry among current competitors. However, as covering all five forces will be beyond the scoop of this essay, it will be focusing on threat of new entrants and rivalry. Even though Geely Holding Group exports cars on top of selling in its local market, its main market is the China’s automobile industry1. With China’s automobile market growing rapidly in the last few years, it has become one of the biggest automobile markets in the world, this mean that the existing firms in the industry will have to be aware of new entrants into the industry. Gerenally, barriers are high in an automobile industry, and there are several main factors contributing to this. One of the factors is supply‐side economics of scale. When firms have high output, it allows them to cut cost in production by buying in bulk and because they have huge buying power, supplier will not want to lose them as customers and give them better deals. They will also be able to spread cost over more units for their marketing, research, services and distribution. This means that new entrant will have a much higher cost of production unless they are able to come in on a large scale. With 1.2 million Geely cars on the road globally2, this is certainly an advantage that Geely has over smaller new entrants. Established firms also enjoy demand‐side benefits of scale. When more people use the product, it will assure people that the product is trustable, causing even more people to be willing to pay for the product. With products like automobiles, quality is important. Incumbents have the advantage of having experience, acquiring technology and building customer loyalty over the years thus, unlike entrants, they do not have to spend as much on marketing and advertising to prove that they are trustable. In 2010, Geely’s sales surpassed target by 15,000 units3. It sales will be a testimony of its reliability to new customers who would be more willing to buy from a company that is doing well than to take a risk with a newcomer. All these will discourage entry, as entrants will have to keep their prices much lower to compete for customers. To enter the automobile industry, there is a high capital requirement. The high level of investment sometimes will keep entrants out because it means that risk is high. Entrants will need not only to invest in fixed facilities, they will need to invest in advertising and research, which are mostly unrecoverable cost, if they
1 Geely Automobile Holdings Limited Annual Report 2009 [ONLINE]. Available 2 Geely Holding Group [ONLINE]. Avilable from:
from: http://hmdatalink.com/PDF/C00530/e00175(116).pdf http://www.geely.com/english/1‐6.html
3 Geely Auto sales surpass 2010 target. (January, 2011) [ONLINE]. Avaliable
from: http://autonews.gasgoo.com/china‐news/geely‐auto‐sales‐surpass‐2010‐ target‐110112.shtml
want to get to where the incumbents are, without the guarantee that they will be successful. For established firms like Geely, one of the best strategy will just be to keep the entrants out to defend their market share. They posses enough resources to fight back, they have technology, borrowing power and facilities at their disposal. As they are large firms who enjoy economics of scale and their production cost is usually low, they also have the ability to cut prices in order to retain their market share without making a loss. High rivalry among competitors limits the profitability of an industry.4 The rivalry in the automobile industry in China is intense. One of the factors the attributes to this is that there are numerous competitors. Even though Geely is an established and relatively large firm, there are many other local and foreign automobile firms that are just as powerful, if not more powerful, and could mirror its cars’ quality and price promotions. Due to high investment nature of the automobile business, exit barriers in the industry are high. This mean that even if they firms were not making much profit or sometimes even making a loss, they will stick around in the business and try to cut prices to retain their market share, this will affect the whole industry as it is a price competitive industry. The market that Geely is focusing on is mainly middle class sedans and these cars, unlike luxury cars, are price sensitive. Thus when one firm cuts its prices below the normal market price, its competitors will start to do the same to stay competitive. The low switching cost of cars for customers from one brand to another is another factor that adds to the rivalry. When switching cost is low, customers are more price sensitive and are more likely switch to the product that is cheaper as there will be no barriers stopping them. Moreover, most of the middle‐class sedans are nearly identical with hardly much difference in the features of the car except for the design of the cars. This characteristic of the industry means that firms often cut cost to win customers starting price wars. The essence of strategy is choosing to perform activities differently than rivals do(Porter 1996). To have a sustainable strategy, Geely should try to take a different approach from it’s rivals rather than do what every other firm selling affordable cars are doing. It has been reported that Geely has tried to collaborate with China Unicom to develop the new generation of 3G "intelligent vehicles"5. This could be something different that it is doing to stand out. Allowing its product to differentiate from other products is essential in a highly competitive
4 Porter, M. E. (2008). The Five Competitive Forces That Shape Strategy. Harvard
Business Review. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.mktgsensei.com/AMAE/Strategy/HBR%20on%20Strategy.pdf#pag e=25 5 China Knowledge. (2010). China Unicom, Geely join hands on 3G intelligent vehicles. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.chinaknowledge.com/Newswires/News_Detail.aspx?type=1&cat=R ND&NewsID=%2039715
market. The only way a company can do better than its rivals is if it can find a sustainable difference that could appeal to customers. References: China Knowledge. (2010). China Unicom, Geely join hands on 3G intelligent vehicles. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.chinaknowledge.com/Newswires/News_Detail.aspx?type=1&cat=R ND&NewsID=%2039715 Geely Automobile Holdings Limited Annual Report 2009 [ONLINE]. Available from: http://hmdatalink.com/PDF/C00530/e00175(116).pdf Geely Auto sales surpass 2010 target. (January, 2011) [ONLINE]. Avaliable from: http://autonews.gasgoo.com/china‐news/geely‐auto‐sales‐surpass‐2010‐target‐ 110112.shtml Geely Holding Group [ONLINE]. Avilable from: http://www.geely.com/english/1‐6.html Porter, M. E. (2008). The Five Competitive Forces That Shape Strategy. Harvard Business Review. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.mktgsensei.com/AMAE/Strategy/HBR%20on%20Strategy.pdf#pag e=25 Poter, M. E. (1996). What is Strategy?. Harvard Business Review. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.ipocongress.ru/download/guide/article/what_is_strategy.pdf
Marketing This essay will attempt to analyze Geely Automobile’s marketing by using segmentation and comparing it to its competitor, BMW China. Market Segmentation is the process of dividing a total market into groups, or segments, consisting of people or organizations with relatively similar product needs.6 The automobile industry in China has all the five conditions that are needed for segmentation to succeed. The market is heterogeneous because different people look for different things in a car. While some are content as long as their car is efficient, some look to their car as a status symbol. Due to the heterogeneous natural of the market, most automobile firms tend to focus on a certain segment. This allows the firms to meet the needs of its target customer more precisely. Two of the very distinct market segments for the China automobile industry will be those that want low‐cost cars and those that want luxury cars. These can be further broken down into more segments however, most of the automobile firms will end up in one or the other, taking on a concentrated targeting strategy, with a few firms taking on the differentiated targeting strategy and taking on both the segments. Geely Automobile strives to produce cars that are high quality yet low cost. Its affordable vehicles are mostly targeted at middle‐class buyers. Geely went with demographic variables. It looked at income and social class and recognized that there is a huge emerging middle‐class consumers in China’s less‐developed hinterland whose annual income is climbing above 50.000 yuan, which is the threshold for car ownership in China as believed by executives.7 These group of people forms its market segment. BMW China, on the other hand, pride themselves on producing stylish, elegant and luxurious cars that are associated with class and money. Its market segment is the upper and upper‐middle‐class segment of China’s population, people who mostly live in the cities and have became very wealthy since China opened its doors. Both employ the concentrated targeting strategy and specialized in providing for its target market segment, allowing it to be focus on satisfying that group’s needs. However, before Geely and BMW had arrived at their market segment, they went through the process of selection the specific target markets that are the most suitable for them. When deciding which segment to participate, long‐term profit opportunities must be considered by looking at sales estimates, competitors and cost estimate. Sales were good in both market segments in China for the past few years. However, when it came to competitors, Geely was a new company and it was not ready to compete with firms in the luxury segment such as Mercedes‐ Benz and it would be better to be competing with other local manufacturers and perhaps the Japanese and the Korean manufactures in the low cost cars segment.
6 Pride, W. A. and Ferrell, O. C. (2008). Marketing Concepts and Strategies.
Expanded 2008 Edition. United States of America: Houghton Mifflin Company [ONLINE]. Available at: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB100014240527487046109045760312930467 66076.html
7Shirouzu, N. (2010). In China, Making Cars on a Budget.. The Wall Street Journal.
Its competitor, BMW, however, had been around for a long time is able to go face to face with other luxury car brands and match them in technology and style. Cost wise, BMW was already an established car manufacturer thus the cost of entering the luxury market would not have been that high as it’s brand image and trust worthiness had already been established. Geely, however, was a new entrant into the industry just a few years ago and it would cost a lot for it to be able to build its reputation to that to BMW in a very short time, thus it was be better for it to go into the low cost cars market where it can compete with other relatively new car manufacturers as well. BMW also had the financial resources, managerial skills, employee expertise, and the facilities to enter China’s luxury cars market as it was already an established car manufacturer. Geely, however, did not have the fortune of having all of those strong enough to compete in the luxury market as it was just starting to venture into the industry when it entered the market. For BMW, luxury car market segment was appropriate and we see how that it is blooming in the market with sales of BMW coming to a record of 90536 units in 20098. Geely’s marketing approach of selling affordable efficient cars have also so far been working in its favor, in 2010, its sales surpass target9 and Geely annual report shows that its profit from the year from 2005 to 2009 has increased steadily.10 BMW has managed to position itself in the China automobile as a high‐end luxurious car brand that people have came to associate with a symbol of status. It does this by consistently delivering high performance cars that are reliable yet stylist and luxurious. Geely Automobile, on the other hand, has to position itself in the China automobile as a trust worthy car that is low cost and efficient. Geely have invested a lot of money into its Geely Automobile research institute11 and have won awards for being innovative and reliable. However, it kept its marketing strategy and still keep the prices of its cars affordable and had made a name for itself in the Chinese automobile market in just a few years. As Geely automobile become one of the biggest automobile firms in the China market, it might eventually try differentiated targeting strategy and develop a market mix for both the luxury segment and low‐cost segment. Its acquisition of Volvo is a step in the direction of luxury cars. Now that Geely has established itself in the market, it could reposition its image, however, there are high risks in
8 Andrew, C. (2010). BMW sales in China came to a record of 90536 in 2009.
4WheelsNews. [ONLINE]. Available from: http://www.4wheelsnews.com/bmw‐ sales‐in‐china‐came‐to‐a‐record‐90536‐units‐in‐2009/ 9 Geely Auto sales surpass 2010 target. (January, 2011) [ONLINE]. Avaliable from: http://autonews.gasgoo.com/china‐news/geely‐auto‐sales‐surpass‐2010‐ target‐110112.shtml 10 Geely Automobile Holdings Limited Annual Report 2009 [ONLINE]. Available from: http://hmdatalink.com/PDF/C00530/e00175(116).pdf 11 Geely Holding Group [ONLINE]. Avilable from: http://www.geely.com/english/1‐6.html
doing so. Even though it is doing so well now, it might just be due to the fact that it is in the right market segment and if it try to reposition itself and to change its target markets, it might end up not doing as well as now. References: Andrew, C. (2010). BMW sales in China came to a record of 90536 in 2009. 4WheelsNews. [ONLINE]. Available from: http://www.4wheelsnews.com/bmw‐ sales‐in‐china‐came‐to‐a‐record‐90536‐units‐in‐2009/ Geely Automobile Holdings Limited Annual Report 2009 [ONLINE]. Available from: http://hmdatalink.com/PDF/C00530/e00175(116).pdf Geely Auto sales surpass 2010 target. (January, 2011) [ONLINE]. Avaliable from: http://autonews.gasgoo.com/china‐news/geely‐auto‐sales‐surpass‐2010‐target‐ 110112.shtml Geely Holding Group [ONLINE]. Avilable from: http://www.geely.com/english/1‐6.html Pride, W. A. and Ferrell, O. C. (2008). Marketing Concepts and Strategies. Expanded 2008 Edition. United States of America: Houghton Mifflin Company Shirouzu, N. (2010). In China, Making Cars on a Budget.. The Wall Street Journal. [ONLINE]. Available at: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB100014240527487046109045760312930467 66076.html Steven, P. S. (1991). Marketing Strategy, A Customer‐Driven Approach. United States of America: The Free Press
References: (2010). (January, 2011) (2008). (2010).
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Since the beginning of the last century, automobile companies have fought for control of a quickly expanding market in the newly created automobile industry. Hundreds of companies attempted to secure their place in market but ultimately, only three companies remain today (Wright, 2012). The decisions, mergers, and products those three companies made is ultimately what kept them going. Starting a business and ensuring its success are two different things entirely. A successful business will recognize the need to adapt to the various pressures exerted on it from other forces.…
- 1892 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
With more and more countries taking part in the international trade, the world’s market is expanding in a rapid pace. How to make use of the enlarging market and remain competitive become urgent for those participants. Market diversification is a good way to take full advantage of the resource and improve the efficiency by enlarging the business scope. In addition, it can also ease the pressure of competition and reduce the cost. The report mainly discuss that Australian Holden may enter Chinese market and chooses Shanghai as the target market. The report firstly analyzes the Australian and Chinese market and briefly introduces Shanghai. Then it presents the market-entry strategies and focuses on comparison on the advantages and disadvantages of Export-based entry and manufacturing-based entry. Through the comparison, the export-based entry is recommended to Holden. Finally, the report analyzes the 4p in marketing, which are price, place, products and promotion. In short, Shanghai is a bid developed country with the encouragement from the government to promote the development of automobile industry.…
- 3458 Words
- 14 Pages
Better Essays -
IntroductionGeneral Motors Corporation is the largest automobile manufactures in the world. The corporation, which is located in Detroit, employs more than 260 millions people and sells cars and trucks in about 35 countries. The corporation has a dominant influence in automobile market in the United States and other developed market such as the United Kingdom, Canada and so on. The corporation also enjoys a large market share in the rapid growing market of developing countries such as China and Brazil. However, the corporation is in face of changing internal and external environment.…
- 3827 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
| • Manufacturing capability is low. Will become a weakness if the company attempts to sell less expensive, more popular cars.• No significant market share in any of the popular categories (Family, Economy). Most units are sold in the popular Family category, in which firm C has only 13% of the market (4th).• High dependency on the high income consumer segment, and low market share in the Singles and Enterprises segments which are the fastest growing segments (5% and 7% respectively).• Highest margins and number of units sold are in the Family category, where firm C is least competitive (and is more likely to struggle). In the Minivan category, where the company is the only player, margins are very low.…
- 433 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
x. They reconcile conflicting performance goalsThey combine low cost, high quality(because of checks and 125 points system), etc.…
- 995 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The automotive industry is a tremendous contributor to the comprehensive level of economic growth experienced throughout the twentieth century. With the peak of industrialization finally realized, there existed opportunity for development and modernization of societies around the world. With this in mind, opportunity was present for the production of automobiles for use around the world as well. This substantial demand created the economic opportunity for companies such as General Motors to begin building their empires. As one of the first companies to become a strong contributor in the industry, General Motors quickly placed itself…
- 298 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The main strength of the Geely Automotive Holdings, Ltd. is their focused research and development initiatives. They invest roughly “10% of their annual sales revenue (which is significant when compared to Toyota’s 5% investment)” in research and development and focus much of their company’s efforts on their Geely Automobile Research School and the Geely Engine Research School (Dess, Lumpkin, and Eisner, 2010). These schools allow them to make improvements pertaining to gas efficiency (a huge competitive advantage in the U.S. and European markets), the meeting of EPA standards, design innovation, as well as feature innovations. These are all important things to consider for any company in the automotive industry, but due to their founder’s (Shufu Li) visionary belief that “by mastering technology, Geely would be able to maintain its competitive advantage when facing foreign rivals,” Geely has taken the necessary actions to increase their total sales revenue as well as total profits from 1997 (the year they started their research and development for automobiles) to present day (Dess, Lumpkin, and Eisner, 2010). Geely has built upon this strength by showcasing their technological innovations in the heavily marketed and world renowned Detroit Auto Show. They also tied for first prize in the 2009 State Science and Technology Award for its innovation and received an award that has, for the past 5 years, has been received by only 12 out of the more than 5 million candidate companies (Min, 2005). Awards like this as well as Geely’s industry celebrated technology advantages (such as the Blow-Out Monitoring and Brake System, Electronic Equal Balance System, and overall safety improvements that allow Geely to meet the international F1 technical car racing safety standards) are part of what helps will help in generating more customer trust in the quality of their product and will in allow Geely obtain a larger scope of economy (Zhao, 2009).…
- 2367 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Geely was a privately owned firm, which was involved in producing non-luxury cars for its local market of China. For the acquisition of Volvo, Li obtained financing from state-owned banks and governments in China and this acquisition made Geely able to enter in the new market of luxury cars by following a “related diversification” strategy.…
- 2774 Words
- 12 Pages
Good Essays -
Geely Firm is an excellent auto manufacturer of China and also among the country’s top 500 firms. In the past ten years, Geely has grown fastest in all of the companies in the Chinese automotive industry. As an outstanding auto manufacturer, Geely has its unique organization culture as well as the business strategy, which deserves to be researched. According to some classical analysis, such as PESTEL analysis, 5-Forces analysis and SWOT analysis, this report finds out the status of its external business environment it faces and then based on which to evaluate its business strategy. The report tries to find out the appropriate strategy that the firm should to follow.…
- 3421 Words
- 14 Pages
Best Essays -
Hyundai set altogether different mindset such to focus on the customer first and the needs of the business thereafter. So Hyundai makes their competitor as their own researching to more advance their production than other competitor at the market. A condition which enables a company to operate in a more efficient or otherwise higher-quality manner than the companies it competes with, and which results in benefits accruing to that company. The close competitors for Hyundai are Toyota, Honda, Mercedes and more that produce the same product like Hyundai. , Hyundai can increase they profit in upgrade their strategy in attract their customer like adding more quality than their competitors. Hyundai also can create a design that different from their competitor too. Technological feature of the automobile industry gave some advantage to Catching-up firms like Hyundai Motors in Korea. Hyundai's development of its own engines, fuel Injection system and other parts were basically the engine of its own initiatives, without help from the government which basically provided only domestic market protection.…
- 464 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
When globalization becomes a circumstance, many companies try to open oversea market. Here, we’d like to take a look at a Chinese private-own automobile company Geely. As china’s top car maker, Geely abstracted the world’s eyes recently. In 2004, Geely plans to export 5,000 vehicles to the Middle East, South America and North Africa after shipping 1,000 cars to Syria in the fourth quarter of 2003 at US$4,000-$6,000 each. This year, Geely wants to open US market. But with many strong competiters in car manufactory in US, with weak reputation around chinese product, How does Geely find an appropriate approach to develop its business? This paper will try to find the answer.…
- 2590 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
High barriers to entry is one of the determinants of whether a firm can enter into the industry or not, the higher the barriers the more likely entry is discouraged. It’s not possible to enter into the global car market as a major player since barriers to entry are much too high, unless the potential entrant has the capital requirements to match of those such as GM, Ford, Honda, Toyota and Nissan to develop a market presence. Investment in equipment, factories and plants, raw materials, R&D, advertising, access to distribution channels and technology are all major costly elements to consider when entering this industry. Any new entrant moving into this industry is likely to face the high level of responsiveness from global competitors. Looking at the experience curve (1960: Boston Consultancy Group) a new entrant must have the investment needed to achieve cost parity with existing firms in the industry so it can achieve the economies of scale needed to compete on cost advantages along side the competition.…
- 2408 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
India represents several opportunities for the two Malaysian Auto manufacturers. The two companies should enter India given the huge domestic demand and a well-established infrastructure. Even though, It is difficult to frame an exit strategy for companies in India, the advantages of going in outweighs the risks. The study found that the threat of New entrants, and bargaining power of suppliers were low, while bargaining power of customers was rated as medium and is rising. On the other hand, the threat of substitutes and rivalry between existing firms was found to be quite high. The two companies, if they decide to enter India, have to take into account, the inherent difficulties and uncertainties of operating in the Indian market while designing a marketing strategy. They should enter India through a joint venture with a partner primarily to benefit from the distribution network and local knowledge of the Indian market conditions. Regarding place of entry, Tamil Nadu was found the most attractive. Ultimately, Proton and…
- 419 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Starting at the center of the model is the current industry, which includes General Motors and their typical competitors, such as, Ford, DaimlerChrystler, and the Japanese [Laudon & Laudon, 2005]. All of these traditional competitors are able to produce cars at a much cheaper cost than General Motors.…
- 2635 Words
- 11 Pages
Better Essays -
|global business where product development is responsible to earn profit and brand building acts as strength of automobile |…
- 1518 Words
- 7 Pages
Best Essays