Preview

ghxf

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1659 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
ghxf
Analysis

The story of the Grand Inquisitor strongly resembles a biblical parable, the kind of story that Christ tells in the New Testament to illustrate a philosophical point. Both Ivan’s story and Christ’s stories use a fictional narrative to address a deep philosophical concern and are open to various interpretations. The similarity between Ivan’s story and Christ’s stories illustrates the uneasy relationship between Ivan and religion. At the same time that Ivan rejects religion’s ability to effectively guide human life, he relies on many of its principles in forming his own philosophical system. Like Christ, Ivan is deeply concerned with understanding the way we define what is right and what is wrong, and with understanding how morality guides human actions. However, Ivan ultimately rejects both Christ’s and God’s existence, as he cannot accept a supreme being with absolute power who would nonetheless allow the suffering that occurs on Earth.

The story also implicitly brings up a new point with regard to Ivan’s argument about expanding the power of ecclesiastical courts. By setting his story in sixteenth-century Spain, where ecclesiastical courts were at the height of their power to try and punish criminals, Ivan asks what verdict such a court would have reached in judging Christ’s life. Since Christian religions teach that Christ lived a sinless life, presumably an ecclesiastical court would have been unable to find Christ guilty of any sin. However, the fact that Ivan’s court finds Christ guilty of sins against mankind illustrates the difference between Ivan’s religious beliefs and his beliefs in the efficacy of ecclesiastical courts. He sees the courts as an effective way to guide human action, but not necessarily as a way to induce men to believe more strongly in God or religion.

The conflict between free will and security further illustrates the reasons for Ivan’s dissent from Christianity. The fundamental difference between Christ’s point of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Gordon provides a detailed account of da Costa’s life before and during the trials in his investigation, “Confessing Sodomy…Luiz da Costa.” Gordon not only elaborates on his analysis of the trials and da Costa’s life, but includes the actual, translated transcripts of the trials of Luiz da Costa. Gordon, who is an accomplished author, historian, and journalist, is very-well versed in Latin American studies, and begins the account by providing a detailed account of who da Costa was, and what he might have encountered during the trials. Gordon’s commentary and analysis is an excellent way to provide background information for the next segment of the chapter, the transcript of the trials. The transcripts are the materials that were taken directly from the time period of the Inquisition, and translated into English, defining them as a primary source. We can come to the understanding that a primary source is any piece of material that comes directly from the time period of the material of interest. Some may argue that since the material was translated, it is therefore not authentic by definition. However, many prominent sources, including the University of Maryland Libraries, agree that it still maintains its status as a primary source since it is an original material deriving from the time period at…

    • 1518 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1983, being a Christian in Communist Russia was dangerous and risky. In his essay, "Men Have Forgotten God," Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn argues that this situation is the result of men forgetting God and abandoning the Biblical standards that the people of Russia used to live by. Solzhenitsyn wrote his essay in order to inform people about the persecution of Christians occurring in Russia and offer a solution to return the love of God to the people of Russia. Basing his information off of experience and knowledge, Solzhenitsyn writes an essay that is both compelling and informative to the reader.…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lost Letters Pergamum

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Believers today do not face the challenge of imperial religion, but there is much in Western culture that tends to force Christ from His rightful place in believers’ lives. Antipas’s example challenges readers to follow Christ wholeheartedly despite the consequences. If the church today had followed this throughout the years, we would probably be in a better place. Although there were faults and the early church needed help due to persecution, morally, they were better off than we are today. As Christians we can learn so much through this novel and try to remember our roots as…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Wars of Religion in the 17th and 18th centuries were some of the bloodiest conflicts of all of European history before the World Wars. They spanned the entire continent, involved nearly every member of society, and resulted in the deaths of millions. Reactions to these wars varied– some were in favour, some were opposed. However, despite the fact that people’s reactions deviated wildly, the evidence shows that many rulers had a similar attitude towards the Wars of Religion, and manipulated them for the benefit of themselves or their country.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Paganism was a mental mindset of the Eastern Slavs living in a world where a majority of the European countries surrounding them had already converted to a monastic religion. Vladimir I, a great prince of Kiev, reigned from 980 till 1015 and succeeded in the mass conversion of the Eastern Slavs.1 Throughout his reign Vladimir’s agenda had always been to strengthen his empire, in order to be considered valuable among the dominate nations of the European family.2 The traditional view of Vladimir’s motivation for the conversion is that only after considering all monastic faiths, did he finally reach the decision of Eastern Christianity, based on the beauty and wonder of Constantinople.3 The conversion of Kievan Rus not only led to a change in religion but also a variety of other benefits, which suggests Vladimir was motivated not only by aesthetic reasons, but also political and economic reasons too. The choice of Eastern Christianity had a profound and lasting effect of the Eastern Slav’s all over Kievan Rus. The gateway opened by Vladimir and Eastern Christianity allowed the country and its people to expand in various areas of art, architecture and education. These areas of culture effected and shaped the events in the history of Russia that followed.…

    • 1742 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Phil 101

    • 1660 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In many ways Ivan’s story feels like it is preaching or a type of parable. Ivan is putting forth his own principles and beliefs and the only reason that it is not a one-sided argument is because Alyosha is present for the conversation and occasionally interjects. What Ivan presents…

    • 1660 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Variables religious practices are only images of piety, halfway between religion and superstition. If piety is not based on a moral requirement (what Socrates called his famous daimon, voice of the higher consciousness), then it is at best an expression of social conformity, useful to the city, but because unjustifiable based on relative values. At worst, godliness refers only fear or ignorance. The final ascent that demands the dialectic does not seek an intellectual intuition of truth but rather an overview, block. It requires the examination of a final report that of all the scientific truths…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ivan does not accept God's ethical system of "allowing" evil to occur, because he believes that God is omnipotent and has the power to stop it. On the other, Swinburne might comment by mentioning how Ivan uses the fallacy of ad populum by involving God when God has nothing to do with the choices people make; since God, like a good father delegating responsibility, gave us free will to use it for good, but humans are the cause for evil since they use free will to harm rather than help. I would rebuttal as to ask Ivan if he truly believes God allows evil in the world then he must also agree that there is no such thing as free will. With a divine being, being the cause of everything evil in the world, then us, humans, have no power or responsibility over the choices we make. Therefore, there is no purpose in rejecting God's ethical system since you are determined to obey his ethical system and you would have no control over your own actions just as everyone else. Lastly, Swinburne and I might conclude to say that Ivan has a biased argument due to his specific view on the suffering of children, as mentioned in the chapter Rebellion, and not the overall aspect of…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s novel The Brothers Karamazov, the Grand Inquisitor is told by Ivan to Alyosha. The setting of the story is in the 16th century in Spain. According to the story, Christ came back once again, briefly, and appeared quietly in the midst of the people, healing those who came to him. People begin to recognize him though, and the guards came and took him away and put him into prison. The “Grand Inquisitor” visits Christ in jail and begins to question why Christ has made a reappearance. He begins to state that Christ has already had his say, and that he set the world in motion and that he already had his turn on earth. He also says that everything is running according to his plans, and he doesn’t belong here anymore. The grand inquisitor says that he has made things better and fixed the mess he left them. He tells Christ that he has given people free will and it was not a wise thing to do. He says that people will always make bad choices and that people are not capable of using free will. I personally disagree with the Grand Inquisitor when he states this. Christ was definitely not wrong in giving people free will, and people do not just use it for bad reasons.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Martin Luther Influence

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Born in Eisleben, Germany, back in 1483, Martin Luther went ahead to become one of the most prominent figures in the entire Western history. Luther spent the early years of his life in relative anonymity serving as a monk and a scholar. However, in 1517, he was able to pan a document that was attacking the Catholic Church for practicing corrupt practices that involved selling “indulgences” to absolve sin. Through his “95 Theses,” he was able to pronounce two central beliefs that sparked the Protestant Reformation; hence leading to the thesis that Martin’s writing created unending divisions in the Catholic Church ever while his ideas shaped the Protestantism that emerged later. The paper analyzes the issues that Luther presented for the debate…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Religious notions of evil and moral notions of evil are not mutually exclusive. This paper defines religion, morality and evil, and explains how religion and morality are compatible and have similar characteristics. Despite the compatibility, they also have their differences but this does not make them mutually exclusive in my opinion. This paper also makes use of ‘Love and Law’ by Alison Gopnik to explain the commensurability between religious and moral notions of evil. Gopnik explains the mind of a child and how children are innately empathetic. She shows how morality is grounded by empathy and creative examples and scenarios.…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Philosophy 8

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Chapter III focuses on the problem of evil. The table of contents shows it contains discussions on God and evil, evil with regard to varieties of atheism, and free will with evil. The titles and descriptions of this chapter show how it relates to things this class has already discussed; God’s goodness with respect to evil, and free will. These topics are therefore a continuation of that which we have already learned and are familiar with.…

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    These can take the form of allusions to the holy books of one of the world’s religions, or the central figures of the religion, or to the religion’s teachings. In Crime and Punishment Dostoevsky has several of his characters, especially the female characters Dunya and Sonia make allusions to Christianity, and specifically to Christ’s suffering on the cross. In some forms of Christianity, it is taught that the great suffering the Christ endured while on the cross purified him of his sins; in other words, since Christ was part man, he was tainted by the same original sin that all humans are. It was through his suffering on the cross that Christ was purified of the original sin within himself. However, this suffering also redeems all of humanity. Because Christ suffered on the cross, all of humanity has the chance to be forgiven of the original sin, and then let into heaven. This is what Christians mean when they say Christ suffered and died for your sins. Both Sonia and Dunya take Christianity very seriously, and believe in its teachings. This is why they urge Raskolnikov to turn himself in and accept his punishment (the other word in the novel’s title) because only by suffering from his punishment does Raskolnikov have any chance of being saved. At first, Raskolnikov holds out, and says “they say it is necessary for me to suffer! What’s the object of these senseless sufferings”…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ghfh

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I feel Harley-Davidsons approach was very effective, well-structured and thorough. They stuck to the major phases of the ERP Life Cycle (LRP - Verville and Bernadas 2007 - ERP Acquisition Planning) throughout the process; the different phases in this model are planning, information search, (pre) selection, evaluation, choice and negotiation.…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gksf

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Grand Kerala Shopping Festival, often abbreviated as GKSF is an annual shopping event in Kerala. The festival is conducted by Tourism Department in co-ordination with the Industries and Commerce Department, Finance Department and Local Self-Government Department. Through this shopping festival, the Kerala government aims to transform the State into a hub for international shopping experience and thereby launch “Shopping Tourism” in the State.…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics