Preview

Invisible Saviour Siblings

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1865 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Invisible Saviour Siblings
The philosopher Immanuel Kant said “Treat others as an end and not as means to an end.” People need to value others for themselves rather than for what they can achieve by the means of them. The idea of selecting an embryo, conceived by IVF, which will become a child that can donate for an older sibling suffering from a genetic disease, has created a difficult moral dilemma. Concerns over the creation of what are called “savoir siblings” are specifically created to help an existing child. In the novel “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodi Picoult there is a girl named Anna who was brought in to this world for the purpose to save her sister Kate. Anna suggests that while her method of coming into the world is not conventional, since most babies born are unwanted; she at least was a wanted child. But she is wanted as a product, as a medical treatment, as a donor. Anna came to a decision that she wanted to stop donating to her sister, so she starts a lawsuit for medical emancipation; the right to control her own body. The child is used as something instrumental and has a welcome that is far from being unconditional. Even the label "savoir” is a misnomer. When we speak of a savoir we refer to someone who has made an active choice to donate. The child never has a choice. When a donation occurs it will have lifelong effects on the body. The possible psychological problem the child will have from being a savior sibling. The parents do not think about the saviour child in the terms of an individual. The parents need to realize that there is a line that separates the value of preserving life and the costs of the quality of life.
When a child is born it is up to the parents to make the decisions for them, but what if the parents are not focus on that child? It is their zeal to make things better for their sick child, but the parents have forgotten that their donor child is a person with feelings, not a something just to pick at when needed. In the case of babies who are



Cited: Picoult, Jodi. My Sister 's Keeper: a Novel. New York, N.Y.: Washington Square, 2004. Print.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    My Sister’s Keeper is a movie that introduces the world to the Fitzgerald family with its countless imperfections. The family carries some guilt when it comes to their youngest daughter Anna; who was genetically created to donate things such as blood and bone marrow to her older sister Kate, who has cancer. With tears and laughs, the film, My Sister’s Keeper, captured thousands of hearts across America with its incredible acting, capturing introduction, flash-back imagery and shady realness.…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the novel, My Sister's Keeper was made into a movie different characters are the focus and the ending and its plot twist is changed. Jodi Picoult wrote this novel in a special format. All her chapters were divided by each character in the novel and they would narrate their feelings upon central problem which was Kate’s Sickness. Jodi Picoult worked at several of different jobs throughout her life. One of her major goals was becoming a writer. For Picoult, My Sister's Keeper was a big accomplishment. Jodi Picoult made Kate’s sickness and Anna's lawsuit a central issue which allowed the main character's to share their stories and feelings about it.She also received an honorary Doctor of Letters degree from Dartmouth College in 2010 and another…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The mother in the book “My Sister’s Keeper”, Jodi Picoult, said “Goldfish get big enough only for…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Had this had been me in this predicament I would choose to see the pregnancy through, however I would choose to give the child up for adoption because I don’t think it is the child’s fault that they are born with this disability so I would give them the opportunity to live for I too see life as being sacred. As a result one might say that the theory I relate too is the moral agency one. I chose to handle the decision based on my morality and I thought that it was not right to choose to terminate the pregnancy. Due to me judging the situation and deciding what was right and what was wrong, my decision was heavily influenced by the moral agency…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wiesemann Natality

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “The Moral Challenge of Natality: Towards a Post-Traditional Concept of Family and Privacy in Repro-genetics” is an article from Gottingen University, written by C. Wiesemann. Wiesemann discusses how “repro-genetic is going to change the way we conceive children, and will have a substantial influence on the family” (61). He evaluates the two family models, the traditional model and the care model. They are part of an “ethical debate” of which model is better for a family. Instead of choosing between the two he suggests a third model, the kinship model as a “moral agent” for the debate (61). He thinks of the kinship model as being better suited for the family model. Wiesemann persuades his view by appealing to the audience’s emotions for the most part. Although he does well to prove his point, his arguments are ineffective due to hasty generalizations, ad populum, and ad misericordiam.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The topic of abortion is a highly controversial issue in today's society, and various views are held concerning the morality of the procedure. Some people feel that abortion is simply cold-blooded murder, because it is their opinion that a 'foetus' is a human being from the moment of conception. However, others would argue that a foetus is merely insubstantial matter, dependant entirely on its mother's body for survival, with no real life of its own. It is for this reason that pro-abortionists support the woman's choice to undergo abortion. After all, why should something so small and insignificant, which is not yet human, be entitled to the same rights and privileges a real human has"…

    • 1652 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A child is dying and the parents want to harvest the child’s eggs for the opportunity to conceive another child or treat any potential genetic anomalies. The parents believe this is a viable option to ensure a healthy child. Which physician is right in this situation? Is this consistent with scope of practice? Should the physician intervene?…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “It is not always in the best interest of the child to be born” (Jacob, 2006). A great example comes from the book Abortion under Attack. It features a story from a girl whose father never wanted her. She “suffered emotional abuse of hearing on a regular basis that she was unwanted and unwelcomed.” (Jacob, 2006) A lot of children are sadly born into this type of unloving environment when a mother is too poor to afford an abortion and doesn’t have the support to take care of the child or when they are born into a strained relationship. When a child is born to parents who don’t want them, would it not have been in their best interest to have been aborted? Rather than be subject to emotional or physical abuse or loveless lives in group homes, they could have never had to experience any of the pain; they never would have known. The fetus is not a conscious being, so when it is aborted it feels no pain; it is as if it never existed.…

    • 1785 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Due to boldily autonomy and the clear distinction between a fetus and a rational, self-aware person, abortion is morally permissible practically whenever the mother chooses it, given it is done humanely. Most people would agree that in cases where the woman did not choose pregnancy, like rape, abortion should be morally permissible due to bodily autonomy and the immorality of asking someone to undergo psychological and physical trauma due to something beyond their control. This is supported by the Famous Violinist argument which explains that women, especially those who are pregnant due to rape, are not morally obligated to endure this immense sacrifice, even if it would be nice to do so (Singer, 1975, p.113-114). Whilst Thomson’s argument has fallen under criticism based on utilitarianism, these arguments are countered by Singer’s deconstruction of the Conservative Argument and its flawed perception that human life is inherently special, which demonstrates the moral permissibility of most abortions. The Conservative Argument’s premise that a fetus is an innocent human can mean two things: either the fetus is a person that has self-awareness and rational thought or a fetus is a member of the human species (Singer, 1975, p.117).…

    • 1642 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are always cases of women who just don’t want their baby, or can’t care for them. If someone doesn’t want their baby or cant care for their child, there is always adoption. There are families out there that can’t have children, so the logical thing to do would be to give their baby to someone who wants them. However, there are some cases that involve rape and or harm to the baby, the mother, or both. In some cases, they should still consider adoption. I would rather say, “I gave my baby away to have a better life” than say, “I killed my baby for selfish reasons”. Abortion is not legal or illegal because of the Roe vs. Wade case, but that still doesn’t make it right. – (historical allusion)…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethics Essay

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The topic which I have investigated is Saviour Siblings. The term ‘Saviour Siblings’ is given to process of someone having another child of the same genetic material to save another existing child’s life. The topic of Saviour Siblings is very conversational as it raises many ethical dilemmas and disagreements between different religious principles and viewpoints. In this essay I will explore wheather or not different religious/ moral principles are a hindrance to medical ethics.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Secondly, it also should be permitted when mother discovers, at an early phase, that an embryo has defective genes. Therefore, a child could suffer from serious disease in the future. I believe that abortion would be better solution than let live such baby and feel great pain that you cannot help him.…

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main thesis of the Chapter is the ethical, moral, and political concerns regarding experimentation on human embryos. In the chapter, Philosopher Bonnie Steinbeck argues that embryos have a moral value, but do not possess a moral status. In her argument, moral value is when good reasons can be used to justify a being’s existence rather than objectifying it, and moral status is a being’s ability to have its own interests. For example, the ability for a being to feel pain. One would assume that a being would chose to not endure undue pain and seek to avoid it. Since embryos are not yet sentient, they cannot feel pain. In the late 1900’s Congress refused to authorize legislation for embryonic experimentation, even when the Ethics Advisory Board…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the case of the child being taken away from her foster parents, it would seem as though there is no way to make a decision without someone getting hurt in the end. On one end, the birth parents made the horrible decision to do drugs and were unable to care for their daughter. While they did become rehabilitated, it took them a very long time to do so. On the other end, the foster parents were only temporarily legal guardians of the girl. So the question I think everyone would ask themselves is “would the child benefit more from being returned to the people who gave her life or would she benefit more from being with the people who have raised her and loved her as their own?” In my opinion, I believe it would have been best if the foster…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This would be a specific type of deontology, in which morality of an action is based only on the compliance of the action itself, not on the action’s consequences. Overall, nobody should merely be used to obtain a goal. According to Kant’s second formulation, a person is obligated to account for the dignity and value they possess in oneself and in others. It is the argumentation and their position as rational and noble beings. In Sue’s case she decided she was not ready to have a baby, but was too afraid to let someone adopt it. Once the infant is born, it can no longer pose any threat to the woman’s life or health since she is given the opportunity to put it up for adoption. For some women, having the baby be raised by someone other than themselves may sound scary, so they take the abortion route. Yes, a lot of women may suffer from the idea that their child is being thrown into the adoption system, and the mother will be worried about the child’s happiness, education or health, but in the end the mother should have been more responsible to discuss these things with her family or husband in order to avoid late-term abortion. Surely, there are better ways of dealing with these problems than permitting late-term abortion in such cases. For any killing where the victim did have a valuable future like ours, having that future by itself is sufficient to create the strong presumption that the killing is seriously wrong (Marquis, 4). According to Marquis, killing a fetus is just as wrong as killing a human being after birth. The loss of the future of any human being by killing or by abortion is unjustified. In essence, a seven-month old fetus is not that much different in appearance from a newborn, and has measurable brain activity.…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays