Preview

On the Power of Man: Position Paper on Synthetic Biology

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
813 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
On the Power of Man: Position Paper on Synthetic Biology
On the power of man: A position paper on synthetic biology

BBC Horizon’s documentary “Playing God” has given its viewers a glimpse on the technological advances of the field Synthetic Biology, a field that dwells on the so-called artificial life. Like what almost all the field of science has been brought about, synthetic biology’s aim is to be of benefit to the human kind—to serve our dominant race for scientific and economic prosperity. In itself, however, ethical issues are bugging this field in its the inclination on the proliferation of synthetic life. The major questions that bug this issue is that, is this a celebration of the human potential, thus acceptable?

Whether life is an abstract term or not, we, as part of its circle, are all concerned on this whole idea that we live—we have life. We claim that we are in a journey full of the mystery of our being, full of queries on our existence, brought about by our interaction with the people around us and the environment we live in. However obscure our philosophical claims are, life is more or less a mere socially constructed term, that in itself, it is merely describing an existence of a moving, breathing, reproducing, and in our case, thinking entity. Life is a precious gift for most of us that to kill another human being is a sin to the human race, or more so, to God among theists. But to kill a cow for food seeks no justice since this is the so-called norms among us, humans. This is the same as to bear a child, which is considered as a gift in a pro-life perspective and, for argument’s sake, a must for survival. But what about the idea of creating another living creature in vitro?

The human potential has been tested for several decades. For centuries, our kind dwelled on seeking answers to our questions which has brought forth myriad of discoveries and inventions that improved the living of every individual on earth. The process for the good of mankind, however, has ceased the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    According to Laurie Garrett, author of “Biology’s Brave New World,” biology and politics are more related than you may think. Garrett’s article, originally published in Foreign Affairs, explores the world of synthetic genomics, a branch of bioengineering in which biologists code DNA sequences to create organisms born from computer code, instead of from earth’s natural evolutionary processes. This groundbreaking research marks the beginning of a new era in which biologists can tinker with living organisms in order to achieve desired effects. Though this opens the door for creating better immunizations and bacterial colonies that can glow in the presence of poison, this also opens the door for sophisticated bioweapons, targeted bioterrorism pathogens, and artificial superbugs capable of destroying the population. Called the “dual-use research of concern,” Garrett explains that synthetic genomics research has both beneficial and devastating implications. However, she asserts that the negative implications should not justify terminating this kind of research. Instead, Garrett advocates for…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The view that life begins at conception plays a huge part in the moral debate that surrounds the use of embryonic cells for research. Researchers often obtain spare embryos that have been donated by couples having fertility treatment. The fertilized egg (viewed as a living or potential person) is incubated for a short period of time. The stem cells are then extracted and the embryo is disregarded (viewed as ending the life or potential life).…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Humans are on a constant quest in the search for perfection and advancement in all areas of life through progressive scientific knowledge. From such a stance, the future of humans appears boundless with all the potential possibilities biotechnology provides, but such developments will cause ethical, social and biological implications.…

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    David Baltimore’s written work of Limiting Science: A Biologist’s Perspective discusses the controversy of research in molecular biology and its limitless freedom, disputing there should be freedom in which direction science heads, but the public should decide the pace at which it goes. Baltimore first begins his argument with the discussion of how molecular biology began. It was born from individual sciences where attempts at trying to solve the mysteries in these fields led to the realization that the answers lied in genetics. Advances in the field are what really are at the heart of this discussion though. The most critical one is the development of recombinant DNA where DNA can be multiplied for an indefinite period, but the potential of this process has scared some scientists, even Baltimore himself, about unforeseen events. This led to even more unsettling questions that inevitably hurt the field of genetics, which Baltimore goes on to explain that the dangers have been blown out of proportion. The most common subject that comes to discussion through these fears is genetic engineering. Baltimore delves into the two techniques for altering imperfect genes, and then raises two questions that normally pop up. Who gets to decide what genes get altered and how will they decide it will be done? For Baltimore this presents a dilemma of both ethics and morals and thus presents the real problem at heart. To clarify the argument against recombinant DNA research Baltimore presents to the reader similar arguments. After he gives us the danger of actively researching genetic engineering, Baltimore flips the coin and argues the danger of restricting it. His theory is that the criterion used to decide how science should be handled reflects a dominant principle of governing. This should not be allowed to control scientific advances nor should science be the servant to this ideology, mainly because of the repercussions on society it could…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gibbs, W.W. (2004). Synthetic Life:Biologists are crafting libraries of interchangeable DNA parts and assembling them inside microbes to create programmable, living machines, [internet]. Scientific American, http://online.sfsu.edu/%7Erone/GEessays/SyntheticLife.htm…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With the development of genetic modification scientists have created a chicken that has a dinosaur leg in a reverse evolution experiment, a goat that produces spider silk, featherless chicken, glow in the dark cats, sheep and monkeys and recently in February 2016 British scientists were granted permission to genetically modify human embryos. Just as Etienne Geoffroy St. Hilaire and his son Isidore Geoffroy St. Hilaire created malformations in chicken embryos, scientists in the 21st century are creating malformations in animals in the name of science – for “the good” of human beings. Wherever a person situates themselves in time, whether it is in the 18th century or 21st century, people need to understand that there will always be consequences for what we choose to do with the knowledge we gain. Knowledge can create and knowledge can destroy- both in the physical realm and in the moral realm. Morally speaking, knowledge can change how individuals (and collectively human beings) view themselves in the world and how individuals view other animals and material things in the…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    At the heart of the political debate about whether the federal government should sponsor and pay for the research of embryonic stem cell is the cultural and political idea of when human life begins. This question is the most important one in the process of either banning or allowing and funding the research. It is clear that murder is against both the moral/ethical and legal code in this country and in most others. The question of whether life begins at conception; a point of view taken by pro-life activists, or whether life begins later on in the process when the egg forms a sense of…

    • 2512 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    What right does man have to accuse another of such a dastardly feat? It is nearly an undoubtable fact that one day man and technology will form a unity and biotechnology will become integrated into everyday life. Man has no right to play God, but man also has no right to attack every technological breakthrough with controversy and radical accusations. “Playing God” is a cliché that has become all too common in the present day. Man has every natural right to alter and improve itself as a race through biomedical augmentations. It is inevitable that technological breakthroughs will have widespread effects on the fields of biology and physiology. Biotechnological developments will also lead to grave changes in global commerce and consumerism within a span as short as the next 20 years. Theological and ethical arguments against replacing the natural human form do not possess the factual backing, nor the rationale, to effectively make the accusation that man is “playing God” with its inevitable biotechnologies and procedures. The human body has near-unlimited capabilities as a biotechnological receptor, and the possibility that this will become a reality is up to society. If humanity can accept the technologic lifestyle it is destined toward, then ethical debates and moral rationales will finally stop getting in the way of scientific…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The argument between whether genetic engineering is wrong or right rages on every day, and will continue to be an issue until everybody can come to an agreement on what can and can’t be done. Mary Shelley, the author of Frankenstein, writes about how she feels and questions the progression of modern science and how far we can go until it is just morally and ethically wrong. Through the mind of a young scientist, Mary pictures the possibility of what could happen if we venture too far into the unknown and how could it harm everyone. Knowing the line between continuing and finding things that can help society and knowing when to stop is essential to stop something from happening just like in the novel Frankenstein. Not only that, but many people argue over the fact that modifying the human body is wrong and go against the will of many different…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pro Life Vs Pro Choice

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Lee and George expand on the idea that “the human embryo, from conception onward, is fully programmed actively to develop himself or herself to the mature stage of a human being, and, unless prevented by disease or violence, will actually do so” (2). The moment the sperm and egg combine is when a living creature begins to form. Every single individual began as a human the size of a pinkie-everyone still grows and evolves into a more mature individual, just as any age person grows more everyday. It is human nature to finish whatever you start; you can’t just kill a flower right before it begins to bloom. A beating heart and developing brain begin to form as soon as four weeks after conception. In “Why I Am Pro-Life”, Thomas Friedman recalls the importance of having a presence on this Earth and that “respect for life has to include respect for how that life is lived, enhanced and protected — not only at the moment of conception but afterward” (4). Life is a gift should be treasured, not something where you can just get rid just because you made a mistake. When a woman gets an abortion, she is depriving the child of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. So how exactly do you define life? Life is any creature that is growing and has a niche in a certain environment; this includes the “clump of cells” that will evolve and flourish into a…

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Synthetic Biology?

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The environmental movement, addressed in "Rewilding North America" by Caroline Fraser, focuses on the negative outcomes of human activities in the environment. It is a movement that restores the environment that humans have damaged. Scientists have addressed the idea, in "A life of its own" by Michael Specter, of using synthetic biology to mend environmental issues. Synthetic biology combines the "elements of engineering, chemistry, computer science, and molecular biology…to assemble the biological tools necessary to redesign the living world" (Specter 364). There are both positive and negative impacts of a synthetic world on the environment movement. The environmental issues consist pollution, depletion of natural resources, extinction of endangered species, population, protection of natural areas, etc. Synthetic biology can aid some of these issues, but further deteriorate others as well. A way that synthetic biology could potentially enhance the environment is through the creation of "cheap drugs, clean fuels, and new organisms to siphon carbon dioxide from the atmosphere," but only "if the tools of synthetic biology succeeds" (Specter 265). However, some of the processes that the environmental movements undergo contradict with the ideals of synthetic biology. Therefore, moving towards a synthetic world will hinder some of the environmental movements on several issues such as, the usage of money, habitat and animals, nature, animal cruelty, but the anticipated benefits are without a doubt worth the cost.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Stem Cell Research Cons

    • 1977 Words
    • 8 Pages

    embryo is alive. The central question remains, is it a life? Or is it a mere piece of…

    • 1977 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    920 921 964 0146 965 966 0147 0173 0202 0204 1006 0238 21 1086 0240 22 23 1048 104 1087 1088 108 0241 24 0242 25 26 27 0479 0382 0383 227 228 229 348 0445 0444 311 310 349 312 0528 388 351 389 390 467 468 430 469 392 432 472 471 433 0609 510 0684 509 473 511 589 590 0770 628 629 632 0805 669 670 671 593 672 434 0610 474 514 068 554 594 0775 633 673 634 0 674 714 0077 713 0875 752 753 754 0003 751 0899 712 0002 750 749 711 0075 0872 0073 710 0074 748 709 0001 0898 592 0773 631 630 394 0841 708 0870 747 0644 591 0771 0071 707 513 0686 0687 0772 588 668 0645 549 550 551 552 553 Type II RM 0737 0738 0739 CCTTC 0736 0741 0735 0740 0742 0040 667 512 0685 0804 0039…

    • 54836 Words
    • 220 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The world that human is living today is fulfilled with technology. The scope of such technological applications is not limited in one specific field. To be more specific,, technology can be used in the teaching area, agricultural development, aerospace engineering, medical science and service industry etc, which brings a substantial number of benefits. However, technology itself is a double-edged sword. When engaged in medical treatment and personal benefits, some people are skeptical about the practicability and feasibility of using technology to improve one’s mental or physical abilities. Some opponents might claim that people are born with given characteristics and it is morally unacceptable to change the intrinsic properties.…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Computers in 2020

    • 2846 Words
    • 12 Pages

    We are supposed to lead our generation in looking for new and life enhancing technologies to make man 's life easier and more enjoyable.…

    • 2846 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays