Preview

Phil 235 Paternalism Essay

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2256 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Phil 235 Paternalism Essay
Paternalism in the Medical Profession
Philosophy 235 EC: Biomedical Ethics

“The only appropriate and realistic model of the Dr.‐patient relationship is paternalism. Doctors are the medical experts; most patients have little, if any, reliable medical knowledge; implicit trust in one’s physician is essential to the healing process; and doctors have the responsibility for our health and therefore have the duty to make all the important medical decisions.” Critically assess that claim.

The issue of doctor patient relationships has become more and more prevalent in our world today. It is hard to draw a clear line in deciding what the appropriate roles are of both the patient and the medical professional. The claim that the paternalistic model is the appropriate and most realistic model will be argued in this paper. This model states that the doctor is the one in complete control, making all decisions on behalf of the patient, and the patient grants the doctor this responsibility, obeying any orders. In this model, patients act as children, who are ignorant and unknowledgeable, and doctors act as parents, not only guiding the child in the right direction, but also, actually telling them what to do. Should doctors really hold complete responsibility for our health? Should they be the ones to make all the important medical decisions without patients having any say? This model will be argued in this paper in order to critically assess whether it should be dominant in our present society.

“The traditional view held by physicians themselves was that the physician is the captain of the ship, and that the patient has to follow orders.” This view has only been strongly believed since the 19th and 20th century, when medical professionals were granted almost complete control over all decision making by their patients. Before that time, going to see a doctor was perceived as a last resort, and many would ignore their doctor’s advice altogether. Over time, this view has

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    An analysis of Robert Schwartz “Autonomy, Futility, and the Limits of Medicine” reveals that physicians are not required to give patients treatment that has been proven to be effective, and they are not morally obligated to provide treatment that is not in-line with practice of medicine. Schwartz explains although our autonomy is respected, there are limitations on our request.…

    • 818 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If we seem doubtful of the assumption that one is morally upright simply because he or she has a career in medicine, we are struck with a seemingly viable counterargument: all doctors must take the Hippocratic Oath in which they “solemnly” swear to “uphold a number of professional ethical standards” (www.nlm.nih.gov). If we still remain unconvinced as to the universal rectitude of all clinicians, we are belittled and then told that doctors do have our best intentions in mind, as they spent years and countless amounts of money thoroughly studying every aspect of the human body. For why would anyone spend 12 years and half a million dollars for any other reason than to carefully heal and nurture the body of his fellow man? Most of the time, our reliance on “authority heuristics” is rewarded as it is noted that the “majority of physicians” take the words of Hippocrates to heart and refrain from “abus[ing] their patients” (Pesta 4).…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Doctor’s have influence on the patients as they have to help people by treating patient’s illness, providing advice and support, and seeing the effects of both ill health and good health from the patient's point of view. They have to examine the symptoms presented by a patient, and consider a range of possible diagnoses. If they are unable to do this it will affect the patients and the company as the patients will lose their trust in the doctors, and as a result it will affect the company’s reputation.…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The purpose of Freidson’s article was to analyze the social organization of the medical profession and its members. In his study, he explored how the medical profession has gained a monopoly in its field, which grants it complete jurisdiction over determining what illness is therefore how people must act in order to be treated as ill (Freidson 1970:205). Because medicine has the ability to label one person’s grievance an illness and another one not, Freidson believes that medicine creates the social role of illness. Illness is thought of as a deviance from a set of norms that represent normal or healthy behavior. “Human, and therefore social evaluation of what is normal, proper, or…

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Susan Goold, M. L. (1999 ). The Doctor–Patient Relationship: Challenges, Opportunities, and Strategies. Retrieved from Society of General Internal Medicine: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1496871/…

    • 4506 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Homeless Paternalism Essay

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The concept of paternalism is heavily evident in most organizations, especially in areas concerning homeless people. While America prides itself as the most giving nation in the world, the idea behind different charities often juxtaposes this ideology. This idea of paternalism has been the practice for most food organizations in order to help the greater community. The notion that an organization should have the authority to disregard homeless people the right of their liberty for the sake of their protection has perpetuated and contributed to the practice of paternalism.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Patients oftentimes seek out their doctor's opinion on any number of health and societal issues. How educated the physician is on the subject matter and how they respond to these inquiries can have a direct and significant impact on how the patient proceeds, and their long-term health. A study by Stein et al. (2004) illustrated this point by showing that how the patient's physician responded to advice given by public health officials impacted adherence to the advice. The study involved a public health suggestion to a group of postal workers and Capitol Hill employees to take a 60 day regimen of antibiotics to combat potential anthrax exposure. Of the group, 37 people got specific advice from their personal physician about taking the medicine. When the physician suggested they take the medicine, 14 of 15 did. When the physician wasn't certain or did not recommend the medicine, only 4 of the 22 actually used it. Though this study is relatively small, it shows that a physician merely supporting public health recommendations has a synergistic effect on patient compliance, and hopefully, overall public health. If one-on-one personal recommendations from a doctor can have such an impact, how else might the physician support public health in their community or even the…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Contrary to what many physicians have thought in the past, a number of studies have demonstrated that patients do want their physicians to tell them the truth about diagnosis, prognosis, and therapy. For instance, 90% of patients surveyed said they would want to be told of a diagnosis of cancer or Alzheimer's disease. Similarly, a number of studies of physician attitudes reveal support for truthful disclosure. For example, whereas in 1961 only 10% of physicians surveyed believed it was correct to tell a patient of a fatal cancer diagnosis, by 1979 97% felt that such disclosure was correct. A specific culture should not change the situation in any medical view. Patients no matter what their background deserve the truth in knowing and understanding their physical health. Most patients rely on physicians to provide medical health information, especially when they know that something is not…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is an endless multitude of ethical issues/dilemmas in the medical profession which has span throughout history to our present time. In this essay I will address the first two dilemmas/issues I ponder about the most and how these certain dilemmas have reshaped medical ethical principles over time.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Individuals naturally assume that medical providers know what is best for patients because they hold the knowledge, authority, and control. Therefore, without knowing that they also have the right to voice their opinions regarding their health, patients often leave the decision making up to the professionals. Although medical professionals may know more, patients know more…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    When people are injured or they are sick they go to the doctors because that is what you are supposed to do, and you have trust in the doctors. But now a day’s doctors just prescribe their patients to medications even when they don’t need it. Doctors need to be more cautious about what drugs they are…

    • 2051 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    1st Do No Harm

    • 1773 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The article titled “First Do No Harm” written by Michael Kidd AM is an inspirational article for the students like us who are going to practice in the field of medicine. First Do No Harm reframes the traditional doctors’ rule, demonstrating that it should apply not only to patients, but also to doctors themselves. With the extensive medical, professional and academic experience, Michael Kidd have created a legacy to be shared with medical students, junior doctors and experienced medical practitioners across all medical specialties. This article has provided a newmeaning of creed, as it is not only about protecting our patients, it is also about protecting the wellbeing of our colleagues, our families, our environment and ourselves. It’s our privilege to write a reflection paper on this article.…

    • 1773 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Health care - we do not have the same medical knowledge as the doctor. We rely on the doctor’s…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lens Of Care Experience

    • 1639 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Foucault argues that physicians have authority and maintain great power within the clinic as a result of their medical knowledge. Their expert understanding of the pathological processes of the human body can penetrate illusions of outdated theories and unveil the ‘truth’ about the disease that a patient is experiencing (Foucault, 1963). Louisa’s answer, when asked about her autonomy in hospital, illustrates this point:…

    • 1639 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Previously, health care and education is based on paternalism, patients had insufficient access to information. Patients had limited partnership in decision making. Health care providers decided what information was to be given to the patients. The quantity…

    • 915 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays