Preview

Should America and Canada Have a Common Economy?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
944 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Should America and Canada Have a Common Economy?
Position Paper on

Should Canada and the United States have a common economic system with little government involvement?

By
Siddhartha Goutam
Student of Grade 9
Crescent Heights High School
Calgary

Abstract

This paper, contains the outcome of our research on the following question: “Should Canada and the United States have a common economic system with little government involvement?” After elaborate consideration of all aspects, this paper concludes that such an integration would be disastrous to both the countries and their people. The Economy of these countries (Canada and the U.S) is so powerful, that such a change could, not only harm the people of North America but also the economies of the whole world. So this paper strongly recommends that such a step should never be taken.

Should Canada and America share the same economies?

People have always wondered what it would be like to step in the shoes of others - people that are completely different from them and see the differences and similarities in their lives. These days even countries are thinking of the same question. For example, what if, Canada started sharing its economy with the US? Canada and the United States have different economic systems even though the countries are geographically close to each other. In the economic continuum of planned, mixed and market economies, Canada has a mixed economy, and U.S has a market economy. Generally speaking, Canadians and Americans are very different people. Creating a single economy could have disastrous effects on the lives of the people and should not be done. First off, with less government involvement Canada would no longer have the things that Canadians celebrate. Secondly, the switch would go down hard on the homeless people of Canada who would now not have the government help that they desperately need and in a colder climate like that of Canada, it would be very hard for them to survive with the new economy not helping them



Bibliography: OECD Health data 2007 Preventing homelessness in America. (n.d.). Retrieved from http://www.solutionsforamerica.org/thrivingneigh/homelessness.html Canada and the north american free trade agreement. (2009, October 22). Retrieved from http://www.international.gc.ca/trade-agreements-accords-commerciaux/agr-acc/nafta-alena/index.aspx http://www.naftanow.org/

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Canada better than The United States by on many stands. Canada is better because it has a better geographic location and it is a safer country than The United States. Canada has less people per square mile or kilometer. Canada wins at being the best. It is a better location than the states.…

    • 262 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the early twentieth century Canada’s economy was strongly tied to farming and natural resources such as wheat, fish, minerals and pulp and paper. Most of these goods were exported to other countries, and as long as the world demand was high, Canada prospered. As the future would show, however, the economy’s dependence on such a narrow range of goods was very risky.…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    This paper looks at whether or not Canada may be properly considered as being far too close an ally of the United States – at least from a military and economic point of view. Although it is tempting to view Canada as being in a dangerously dependent position relative to the United States of America, the simple reality is that Canada needs those close ties with America. For one thing, although Canada is obviously a junior partner in NORAD and NATO, and although Canada appears to often engage in joint military exercises with US forces, the simple reality is that such military integration and alignment is necessary: at this paper is being written, Russia is making a move towards seizing arctic territories that Canada has a legitimate claim to; at the same time, Russia has recently engaged in “fly-bys” whereby Russian fighter jets ventured uncomfortably near Canadian airspace. Since Canada has under-spent on its military for decades, this nation is poorly-prepared to deal with a hostile assault from a well-armed and ambitious foreign nation; without US support, Canada would be very vulnerable, indeed. At the same time, although economic nationalists are frustrated at the degree of integration that has unfolded between Canada and the United States, the simple reality is that being part of a North American free trade zone has allowed Canada easy access to the richest market on earth; at the same time, the voracious American demand for Canadian natural resources has meant plenty of well-paying jobs in Canada (as well as other benefits that will be touched upon in due course). In general, it is fair to argue that Canada is too dependent militarily and economically upon the United States – but that close relationship also shelters Canada and gives this nation opportunities that other countries do not possess.…

    • 4379 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The purpose of capitalism is to make money, on the other hand we believe that the free market has not failed, it is not morally bad, and in fact serves deep human values. In this paper we are discussing the implementation of the Buy American Act and its consequences. This Act may seem contradictory to a free market system, where there is free competition of suppliers and buyers, but in the end, this Act would protect domestic products and build manufacturing stronger in the U.S, and of course create more jobs for the economy to thrive. The Buy American Act wants Americans working in the manufacturing plants, and to have those plants located in the United States, which is totally against the capitalistic ethic, but I believe is all American. This Act also provides more benefits to the country besides the economic benefits, but builds more independence and solidarity of our global economy and economic dominance all over the world. In fact financially the U.S. would be the one to provide services to other countries, creating revenue for our country instead of another. The main purpose is to be a stronger and more globally competitive player in the world market. This law would protect our production systems, since there is no foreign participation in the production processes. In turn Remote Control Unlimited and VectorCal would be ensured participation in these contracts, and this would provide competition and creation of more jobs, adding more weight to our domestic firms and to national…

    • 2794 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    More new products being built expands businesses and creates new jobs, which means more money for the country and citizens. Prosperity is the goal. To obtain that goal, countries and leaders have to think of new ways to reach it. When Canada wanted to create a better economy, Lester B. Pearson decided to get American Car dealerships into Canada, creating the Automotive Agreement (Auto Pact). “The agreement helped secure the foundations for Canadian manufacturing and industry.”6 Creating a strong foundation for the economy of Canada improved many things. It protected the country if anything bad were to happen and made it easier to repair the country back to normal. A countries look, or reputation also depends on its economy. When a country has prosperity, people from other countries will want to visit, earning more money from foreigners as well. “The Auto Pact helped strengthen the relationship between Canada and the US.”7 At the time, Canada and the US were not very close because of Cold War tensions between the two. The Auto Pact helped settled those tensions and made Canada and the US a lot closer, which strengthened their countries as well. Canada could now rely on the US, and the US could do them same with them. Lester B. Pearson’s action in creating the Auto Pact helped to build prosperity in Canada, which created a stronger, more wealthy…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    7. One national government would eliminate the problem of double majority, where Canada West and Canada East often disagreed on proposed legislation and would create political deadlock in the legislature.…

    • 460 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another important impact was if any municipal, federal or provincial Government favored national or provincial firms over other foreign firms then the Government of Canada is liable to be attacked by other Governments of those countries who belong to NAFTA or WTO. Additions such as these to the Canadian legal order have had a direct effect on legislative consequences. This brought an end to a long generation of industrial development. Canadian governments could no longer provide subsidies’ to domestic firm in order to increase their competitive performances and also boost the economy’s exports. The external constitution has impacted Canada by weakening Government autonomy in the trade sector and allowed for external forces to interfere with domestic trade affairs. Governments had had to changes their laws and regulations because of various clauses presented in these trade agreements which are…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The source presented talks about the Canadian government’s upcoming actions as it deals with the country’s economic affairs. It can be inferred that the author feels that economic prosperity is the most important sign of progress and a good quality of life for Canadians, as jobs and economic growth can lead to “long-term prosperity” that will benefit every citizen of the country. An example of this envisioned economic prosperity is the Harper government’s economic action plan, which seeks to supply more jobs in order to prolong and strengthen Canada’s performance economically. By saying that costs must be reduced or eliminated in international affairs, it can be assumed that the author favours nationalism over internationalism. The speaker’s stance can then be assumed that he or she would most prefer to have their country reap the most benefits through the improvement of economic budgeting, over being a world citizen who cares more for the welfare of the world as a whole, and can be inferred that their position supports unilateralism, wherein a country’s decisions are made by themselves, without international influence. An example of favouring nationalism over internationalism is the recent backing out of Canada from its military participation in Afghanistan, due to its expensive costs. This example shows the challenge between balancing both nationalism and internationalism, as Canada’s purpose of providing military aid to Afghanistan shows that the country seeks to be of help during international crises, but then its withdrawal shows that as much as Canada seeks to aid Afghanistan, it has to prioritize its own welfare first in order to keep giving help. The speaker’s sentiment in the last sentence shows exactly that the programs and benefits must be beneficial to Canadians, not in international affairs where they feel that giving our resources only hinders Canada’s path to economic prosperity. Some would agree with the source, as Canada’s…

    • 1081 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Quebec is the main reason of Canada being a bi-lingual country. After they separate there would not be as many French speaking Canadians and potentially lead to Canada becoming an English speaking country only in which case Canada would lose all of our individuality and a huge reason that makes Canada a unique country. Canada is known for it diversity and multicultural traditions and unfortunately the separation could make people think that Canada is falling apart. Without Quebec, Canada would not have an identity of its own; when tourists think of Canada they also think about maple syrup, poutine as well as Hockey, all of which originated in Quebec. With the loss of such elements of Canadian culture, it could be ( ADDD SOMETHINGHRRE). Moreover, the Quebec separatism would lead to Canada losing a huge part of its identity.…

    • 851 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Moments In Canada

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Canada is a one of the wealthiest countries in the world but Canada didn’t just become wealthy overnight. Canada has many accomplishments and failures but the most defining moments in Canadian history were both the failures and accomplishments in the economy or economy related. The three most defining moments in Canadian history were; the stock market crash, which led to the “Great Depression”, the baby boom on the other hand led to increases in jobs during the 1960’s, and finally GST replaced “Manufacture Sales Tax” (MST) in 1990.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It's one of the, if not the fairest way to govern a country. Democracy means that they'll try to get everyone’s opinions and ideas. Each province will vote who will govern it and who shall represent them in the parliament. More provinces in the Confederation equals better laws because more voices are heard. If a province or territory leaves the Confederation, it will make things chaotic. To make things worse, the separated province or territory won't be able to get as many different opinions and ideas because it is small compared to the rest of Canada. Some provinces such as Quebec complain about being left out, but from 1957-2011, they've received an extra 120 billion dollars from equalization payments. Those extra money can be used to preserve their heritage and culture. Atlantic provinces weren’t doing so well, so the Canadian government helped them by giving them money payments. Now, Newfoundland has found oil and it gives money back to the government in return for it’s help. In Canada, citizens can form their own party and if it receives enough support, it could win the federal election. The Western provinces felt alienation because they thought the government didn't care about them. That gave rise to the reform party which eventually became the Conservative party of Canada. The Conservative party is also the governing party of Canada. As you can see, Canadian politics are fair and…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Homelessness In Canada

    • 3071 Words
    • 13 Pages

    On the one hand, it is a prosperous nation of over 30 million people with over 80% of the population living in urban areas. The Organization for Economic Development and Co-operation (OECD) sites Canada for its strong, economic performance including having recorded national budget surpluses for the past 11 years (OECD, 2008). Yet, despite this, Canada’s government is not meeting the needs of the homeless population as we can see from this paper. The lack of reliable data may limit Canada’s ability to address homelessness and has been a focus for international criticism. During a visit to Canada in October 2007, for example, the then-UN Special Rapporteur on adequate housing, Miloon Kothari, reported that he “was disappointed that the Government could not provide reliable statistics on the number of homeless” (Kothari, 2007). The UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights has voiced similar concerns (OHCHR,…

    • 3071 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    the people, it is the government who should intervene. When I look at what the…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    America currently obtains more than 500,000 people living on the streets. Homelessness is a rising issue that is continuing at full speed. Everyday more people are forced to the streets with no other options. The main cause of homelessness is loss of income, divorce or breakups in a home, and traumatic incidents in a person’s life, these factors can push people out onto the streets and damage their mental and physical health.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ECONOMIC INTEGRATION

    • 7596 Words
    • 26 Pages

    By integrating the economies of more than one country, the short-term benefits from the use of tariffs and other trade barriers is diminished. At the same time, the more integrated the economies become, the less power the governments of the member nations have to make adjustments that would benefit themselves. In periods of economic growth, being integrated can lead to greater long-term economic benefits; however, in periods of poor growth being integrated can actually make things worse.…

    • 7596 Words
    • 26 Pages
    Powerful Essays