Preview

The Crucible: Theocracy Is a Dangerous Form of Government

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
457 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Crucible: Theocracy Is a Dangerous Form of Government
To all intents and purposes, the power of theocracy in Massachusetts was broken." (146). The wrong-doings of "religious officials", however one defines them, caused this unjust government to collapse. What is the point of trial when one could not be proven innocent? Each trial lead down the same path, a witch that confessed was punished, and an accused witch who did not confess was also punished. So under a theocratic government, there were no winners nor losers, only those unfairly put to excruciating and horrifying deaths. A theocracy is a very dangerous form of government because it is unjust, has no real structure, and ironically put the innocent to death and let the guilty live. Imagine being put on trial knowing the word innocent would not be used that particular day. Nothing could help considering that this government was based on religion, and G-d was obviously not showing up in person. The prosecutor has no scientific proof at all, only words flowing out of mindless people that are trying to save themselves before they think about what harm they are causing to their community. Abigail shows this by committing acts of witchcraft, and then turns around and points her finger at the innocent. An unstructured government is just about the same as having no government at all. What is a government without leadership? A theocratic government was in a league all its own. With its only form of reference being the bible, laws were not needed and not useful. In Salem, Massachusetts, the Puritan community based everything they had on their religion. This is why it is no surprise that their government was another daily reminder of how strongly God and the bible affected them.
A looming sense of danger filled the air when John Proctor told his wife that Giles Corey had been executed. He was the first of many to come. And that same sense of danger filled each household as the news spread around Salem about who was being accused and who were the accusers of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Arthur Miller uses Mass hysteria through Abigail mainly throughout the story. Abigail uses her emotions to pretend seeing spirits and lies about what others do. She does this strategically so that whenever she is the topic of discussion she can start to blame someone else of witchery instead of herself. This happens plenty of times, For example, when Mary Warren was being accused of witchery, the attention turned towards her so she turned it back to Mary by pretending there was a bird speaking to her in “Mary's Spirit” trying to hurt Abigail. This was a complete lie so that Mary was the one being accused of witchery instead of her. Another…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Evidence was limited to an initial accusation (after all, if you weren’t, why won’t someone say you were?) and some testimonies that rang of gossip more than sworn word. But the similarity to be focused upon here is not the trail (not quite yet) but of the escalation of the indictments. Abigail started the cry of dark magic after seeing that she was being threatened of her person. To protect herself, Abigail accused the black slave (a foreigner for comparability to the McCarthy trials) of the occult and the accused says whatever she needs to feeling that would free her. One name leads to four others which then lead to hundreds accused. With any defense for the defendant easily written off as “That is what a witch (or commie) would say,” like the victims of the blame in Salem, most people had to confess to suffer only the lesser…

    • 613 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She had condemned many people to jail and the court believed all of it. John Proctor was in the courtroom when her just snapped and grabbed Abigail threw her on the court table yelling and shouting. Proctor says, Your raising up a whore.” (Miller). John was so mad he just gave up and shouted the unspeakable. Proctor said “God is Dead.” (Miller). Proctor could not believe that they were going along with Abigail’s lies. It seemed like she was getting away with everything, like there was no way out of her lies.…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    John Winthrop, the man who set this goal for the Puritans, used God as a way to form a close-knit society. Winthrop felt that closeness in a community was very important in order to work closely together. (Doc A) Since God was so influential in this situation, then it must have been important for Him to be a bigger part of their society: their government. This led to the development of a theocracy. The “closeness” that Winthrop spoke of was very true in the theocratic government, because ministers were protected, and the church members worked closely with each other. Together, they placed harsh requirements upon the people of Puritan New England. They had to attend church services, pay taxes to support the church, and were therefore bound to the church not just through religion, but also through the government. Their loyalty was also expected by the church. The people could in no form offend the church, they promised to study the gospels, spread their knowledge of Him to their children, and most importantly, acknowledged His power: “…and all this not by any strength of our own, but by the Lord Christ” (Doc C). Because it was assumed that any material success by the people…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abigail is a peculiar individual as she is one of the main charachters in the play, with her convicting so many innocent civilians, it can only be assured…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    of these people was a man named John Proctor. Mr. Proctor had been accused of…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ladies and gentleman of the jury, you have been hearing for days that my client is the sole cause of the death of these innocent people. I acknowledge the fact that my client had an explicit role in these horrific events, and nothing can bring their innocent souls back. What you have been hearing from the opposing attorney is that Abigail is both a witch and maliciously planned the accusations of other people of witchcraft; however that is not true. Abigail Williams should not shoulder all of the blame for this string of tragedies. In fact, Abigail should be exonerated and found innocent, As a result of Abigail’s tragic childhood and manipulative relationship with John Proctor, her mind was corrupted into such an altered state that she…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Abigail would tell people that someone was a witch just because she didn't like them or she wanted them to get in trouble. If they were accused they would lose their land and they would have to deal with legal issues or they could be killed. Abigail just wanted to get everyone in trouble. They were scared of…

    • 184 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    If she was bewitched, why would it be happening in court? The accused obviously would not want to prove her guilt in front of a judge with an edgy finger for signing death certificates. Also, Abigail lied to get some backing on her accusations by accusing two of the worst ladies in town of witches, as well as a black slave from Barbados. This was very believable, as these women held no social rank among the town. This has been a common way throughout history to get support for individuals and groups. The Nazi party in Germany accused Jews of all their economic woes. It gained backing among the party as they looked for blame, and Nazis gained from it power. Abigail is a skillful liar and a quality enemy. Abigail purposely hurt herself for evidence in court. "I have been hurt…I have seen my blood runnin' out! I have been near to murdered everyday because I done my duty pointing out the Devil's people." (Abigail 108) She was very good about pinning guilt on others and the fact that she was the victim. She had a way with convincing both the judge and…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a theocracy, governing persons are overly empowered because they are supposedly ordained of God. This makes it hard for truth to stand because there is no tolerance for second notions. In a theocratic state, authority is especially distrusted because there is no way of proving direction from a higher power. Arthur Miller illustrates this concept in The Crucible when Salem's citizens are suspicious of new authority figures such as Parris and Judge Danforth.…

    • 511 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The court perceives their town leader, the head of the church, Reverend Parris, as undoubtedly innocent because of his position as a man of God. In essence, through the implied promise of strict adherence to the word of God, he is absolved of the possibility of reasonable doubt in the face of crime. The court perceives Abigail’s innocence through her premise of purifying the town, that her actions are all in the interest of a greater good, and so by using her experiences and actions and distorting them to achieve martyrdom, she becomes so holy to the town of Salem, they refuse to believe she would be at fault. John Proctor calls attention to this hypocrisy by reminding the court essentially that is always true that all humans can and do sin, and that neither Parris nor Abigail are exempt from that truth, and so, refusing to hold an unbiased trial for those accused of witchcraft, they are handing to much power to the unbalanced biases a court of justice is expected to…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Abigail is guilty for starting everything she’s still a young girl and had terrible role models. Then she had seen her parents get killed and he only cared about his image in the people’s eye’s . However , she didn’t need to follow her uncle’s footsteps and could have prevented their family’s reputation from going bad. To dispute she could also have said the truth and be a mature 16 year old. Despite all the things she’s been through it didn’t mean she could start chaos in the…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Today we grieve the sad death of a man that is known throughout this village of Salem. He was a farmer, a husband, a father of two, and to me, a good friend: John Proctor. He was hanged next to my sweet Rebecca, and after speaking about my dear wife, I knew it must only be right if I share some words about John.…

    • 827 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    God In The Crucible

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages

    God symbolizes the truth, forgiveness, goodwill, and many other aspects. These values are what many of villagers of Salem try to live by every day. When in fact, the same people went against these values when witchcraft emerged. Everyone frantically accused one another of being a witch and justified their claims with God’s Name. In the play, Abigail explains, “God gave me strength to call them liars, and God made men to listen to me, and by God I will scrub the world clean for the love of Him!” (141). In this quote Abigail ironically declares she was given power by God to kill anyone for His love and believes she is doing God’s work even though she is prosecuting innocent lives. The same irony is shown many times in the court as well. It was said multiple times the court’s goal was to find the truth and to bring justice. Furthermore, the court of Salem is also representative of God’s laws and values, but its members are not. Their interests lie in only retaining authority through the court. Judge Danforth states the following after being questioned about an uprising, “I speak God’’s law... If retaliation is your fear, know this - I should hang ten thousand that dared to rise against the law, and an ocean of salt tears could not melt the resolution of the statutes,” (119). Again this quote shows the irony in his actions and his use of God’s name, but it also…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Abigail Williams Quotes

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This quote could summarize this story pretty well. Abigail told one lie. Her first lie. After that, they just became a habit that she would do when she felt threatened. She would fake seeing things, and accuse people of witch craft. The more she did it the better she got at it, the more believable the lies became. Abigail told so many lies, and wanted so many people to believe them that there was no point in trying to argue with her. She would always say who she "saw"'with the devil. She would always get the girls to follow her, in anything she did. No matter how much people argued with her,told her to stop, or told the truth. People believed her. In the movie we watched her tell lies constantly, just to get John proctor. In the end, her lies are actually what killed…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays