Preview

The Government's Attempt At Erasing The Identity Of Native Americans

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
877 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Government's Attempt At Erasing The Identity Of Native Americans
Boarding schools were the government’s attempt at erasing the identity of Native Americans. They tried three different ways of schooling to assimilate the natives. The first two did not have the successes the government was looking for because the children still had their Indian Culture. The Native students did receive a few benefits from going to school, but the cost of the negative experiences was not worth the few benefits attained.
Schooling provided by the government or a denomination was intended to assimilate the Indians. The least successful schools were the boarding and day schools that were on the reservation because the children could go back to their families to take part in traditional ways of life. The children were taught
…show more content…
Hans informs, “Even those Native communities that had originally supported education for their children felt that residential schools were culturally oppressive and, most importantly, their children were subjected to physical, spiritual, and sexual abuse”. The children were not allowed to practice the spiritual beliefs of their tribes and they often received harsh punishments for breaking the rules. Even the Native children were close to home suffered abuse at school. Indian children were instead forced into Christianity by their teachers. Specifically talking about the missionaries’ day schools Hans commented, “Teachers hoped that they would carry what they had learned to their parents and communities.” The hopes of the denomination schools were that the children would take what they learned about Christianity and teach it to their parents and the other tribe members. Although the intention of spreading Christianity was there it was difficult to do so because the tribal ties were still strong if the school was on the reservation. The off-reservation schools had more success at assimilating the children but the students and parents met the schooling with resistance. According to Surface-Evans, “The most common and subtle forms of resistance utilized by students, such as refusing to eat or ingesting toxic substances, or continuing to speak native languages…Arson was also a way to strike back at the institution and materially corrode its power”. The Indian children were persistent and did not go done without a fight. In addition to maltreatment disease spread rampantly. Milwaukee explains, “Many of the Indian deaths during the great influenza pandemic of 1918…took place in boarding schools… In the early twentieth century trachoma, a contagious and painful eye disease, afflicted nearly half of the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Without being able to practice their religion or speak their native language, Pratt ensured that the students lost the most important parts of their culture. Through the view of Pratt and the others, forbidding these practices must have been a way to remove the “savage” from the children. The video mentioned several students that had died of plagues and various sicknesses, but I think it is important to note the cases of children dying of home-sickness. In these cases, it was impossible for the child to leave behind their previous way of life--an interesting application of the "nature vs. nurture" debate. The "white man's way" was forced upon these children and they were encouraged to abandon their past.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lucy’s and Indian Boarding schools affected the students dramatically, with facing a great deal of…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Looking at the effects of Canada’s colonial past, the chapter of Monchalin’s textbook The Impact of Assimilation discusses the history of residential schools and the impact that they have had on Canada’s Indigenous community. The purpose of these horrendous and unethical establishments was to eradicate the culture, traditions, and language of Indigenous peoples. This was done by removing Indigenous children from their homes, denying them communication with their families while forcing them to adopt the beliefs of Christianity. Beginning in 1920, it became compulsory that all Indigenous children from the age of seven to fifteen must attend school however; this did not necessarily mean that they were required to attend a residential school. Though…

    • 212 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Assimilation through Education” an intriguing essay by Carolyn Marr it goes into great detail explaining the idea of boarding schools. As Marr states that the overall goal of boarding schools was to “ease the assimilation of Indian people into the…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the years of its operation, students suffered from physical, sexual, and emotional abuse at the hands of their teachers. Over the course of its history, many investigations by the Department of Indian Affairs and several other government organizations failed to successfully bring forth any change in the school. Even the death of two male students (in separate incidences) brought forth no change. The deaths of the boys were blamed on the “wild nature” (page 112) of the First Nations, and that they “hate confinement” (page 112). The book ends with blaming the church and government’s inability to effectively stop the mistreatment at residential schooling systems, which has ultimately lead to much suffering and long-lasting trauma in First Nation’s people and their…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Trafzer, C. E., Keller, J. A., & Sisquoc, L. (2006). Boarding School Blues: Revisiting American Indian Educational Experiences. U of Nebraska Press.…

    • 2180 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the Ethnic Dimension in American History on page 192, it mentions the Carlisle School used non reservational schools that were designed to remove Native children from their reservations and tribal environments. While this was primarily the flagship program that began the process of taking away educational responsibilities from various tribes. The program was mostly incorporating in places like Pennsylvania but spread across many reservations. The psychological damage that this likely caused would be detrimental to the cultural identity of these Native Americans for both the children and parents.…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Métis Residential Schools

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Many missionaries determined that the success of their lessons was reliant on how long these children remained in the Missionary Schools and away from the influence of their traditions and families. While many Métis did go to school, the missionaries were still powerless to sway the Francophone Métis communities. Missionaries eventually forcibly removed these French-speaking Métis children from their homes and put them in a setting where punishment, conformity, Christianity and European Values replaced Métis and First Nations traditions and culture. This was an entirely new and alien approach for the Métis, who had always had taught their children by example and…

    • 2013 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Best Essays

    Today’s education has markedly different goals than it did in the mid 1700’s in that its religious connotation is virtually eliminated and the methods of teaching are less Draconian. However, despite the vastly dissimilar goals of early 18th century and 21st century education, one must consider the implications of the former and its role in shaping the latter. Public schools were only formed to deal with the large increase in the immigrant population that occurred in the mid 1800s; these schools were poorly funded, and were meant more for supervised congregation than actual learning. During this time period, native U.S. citizens still largely attended private schools but public schools with larger numbers of native citizens enjoyed the benefits of better teachers, resources, and funding. This began the long trend of racial and ethnic discrimination in U.S. education. This notion of inherent inequality is important as it created the environment in which parent involvement and SES became integral to student success. Richer, more involved parents sought to improve their children’s education by either placing them in private school or a more prestigious public school, and the immigrant population recognized the importance of involvement in their children’s education…

    • 3045 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    European Christian missionaries traveled to spread their beliefs and established religious schools for the Native Americans. This was done, in part, because the government was trying to assimilate them to White ways. Some of the Indians however, did convert to Christianity, went to school, cut their hair, and dressed like the regular White man. The beliefs held by the Native Americans where closely tied to their ancestors, desire to appease the spirits and their love of the Earth. The Native Americans taught the Whites how to love the Earth and treat it with respect.…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The start was when the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) found the first Indian boarding school in Washington on the Yakima Indian Reservation. The plan was made by eastern reformers Herbert Welsh and Henry Pancoast, who had an original good-intentioned goal for Native Americans to “assimilate” (which means to understand fully) the “American way of life.” In the schools the Native Americans would be taught the importance of private property, material wealth and monogamous nuclear families. As well as that the reformers wanted to ‘civilize’ Native Americans and adjust to the white man’s cultures and beliefs. They believed…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The harsh reality of the events occurring to native children gone missing from residential schools has been brought to light. Records concur that over 150,000 children have been taken from their parents, sent to residential schools and many never returned. The leading cause of these tragic deaths was disease, mainly tuberculosis and the Spanish flu epidemic. The children faced these diseases every day in residential schools. Furthermore, there were many deaths that were influenced directly by the schools themselves. Students would sometimes be fed rotten food, or be unquestionably malnourished. The students could even be used in experiments…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Americanization attempts directly oppressed Native culture and identity through government Indian boarding schools. Rules, such as, cutting children’s hair, changing names, altering diets, modifying clothing, and reshaping identity were ordered. Teachers demanded Native American children to speak English and practice Christianity (Marr). They instilled these Western ideas in young Native Americans in order to conquer their natural liveliness and standards which were too different than those of an American youth. These guidelines at…

    • 1329 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cherokee Motherhood

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The western idea of motherhood was one of a virtuous and affectionate bond between mother and child with the father being the main disciplinarian (Smith 2010:416). However, Cherokee women were tasked with the job of giving out punishments, which were usually comprised of scoldings and lectures (Smith 2010:419). When their role as disciplinarian was questioned or if a mother became unhappy with the methods of the missionary schools they would quickly pull their children out of the school's care (Smith 2010:423). Mothers often did pull their children out of school either for family visits or important communities events such as the Green Corn festival. These breaks were instrumental to the mother's mission of keeping their children firmly connected to their heritage and culture while still benefiting from what the missionary school could offer (Smith 2010:418). Missionaries were set up for classes with this practice when they would allow the fathers of children to enroll and pull children out from these schools without the express permission of the mother. This stemmed from the missionaries lack of understanding about the standing of a Cherokee mother in their culture. The father taking such a step in undermining the mother's authority in…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This assimilation forcing the Natives to convert to Christianity, learn to speak and read English, and adopt European ways of living, such as the economical practices of individual ownership of land and other property, ripped them from their own culture. Children were kidnapped and forced into boarding schools, to “cleanse” their mind of their ethnic impurities. Their native names were replaced with European names such as Susan or Thomas, or even in some cases, replaced with numbers. Their hair, a symbol of their identity to their tribes and cultures, were shaved identically to one another. Their clothes, replaced with uniforms. Children were not allowed to speak in their native tongue, and were punished severely if they did. The whitewashing of the children’s mind, whom were often vessels for the passing of generational knowledge and the life line of the indigenous people’s culture, made sure to rid the Native’s of their identities, in hopes that they would then conform to the European…

    • 1548 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays