Preview

The Nice Trap

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
677 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Nice Trap
Case Incident 1 The Nice Trap?

In these pages we’ve already noted that one downside of agreeableness is that agreeable people tend to have lower levels of career success. Though agreeableness doesn’t appear to be related to job performance, agreeable people do earn less money. Though we’re not sure why this is so, it may be that agreeable individuals are less aggressive in negotiating starting salaries and pay raises for themselves.

Yet there is clear evidence that agreeableness is something employers value. Several recent books argue in favor of the “power of nice” (Thaler & Koval, 2006) and “the kindness revolution” (Horrell, 2006). Other articles in the business press have argued that the sensitive, agreeable CEO—as manifested in CEOs such as GE’s Jeffrey Immelt and Boeing’s James McNerney—signals a shift in business culture (Brady, 2007). In many circles, individuals desiring success in their careers are exhorted to be “complimentary,” “kind,” and “good” (for example, Schillinger, 2007).

Take the example of 500-employee Lindblad Expeditions. It emphasizes agreeableness in its hiring decisions. The VP of HR commented, “You can teach people any technical skill, but you can’t teach them how to be a kindhearted, generous-minded person with an open spirit.”

So, while employers want agreeable employees, agreeable employees are not better job performers, and they are less successful in their careers. One might explain this apparent contradiction by noting that employers value agreeable employees for other reasons: They are more pleasant to be around, and they may help others in ways that aren’t reflected in their job performance. While the former point seems fair enough—agreeable people are better liked—it’s not clear that agreeable individuals actually help people more. A review of the “organizational citizenship” literature revealed a pretty weak correlation between an employee’s agreeableness and how much he or she helped others.

Moreover, a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    As employees we have all felt the differences between respect amongst our co-workers. This can be real or imagined but nearly all of us, at some time, have felt this emotion. This mostly occurs when management puts forth an heir of self-importance or simply treats its employees indifferently(Pierce & Newstrom, 2011, p. 118). This benign treatment of employees lowers morale, causes poor work performance, and can cause internal strife within a business(Pierce & Newstrom, 2011, p. 118). It should be avoided at all costs as to better the company.…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    2 - Understand how to behave in a way that supports positive working with others…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to our textbook; “The most popular and productive people in any work environment are usually those with the best attitudes”. (Sharon Lund O’Neil and Elwood N. Chapman pg.6)…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Trap Island: A Short Story

    • 1778 Words
    • 8 Pages

    I had never slept in a beter bed, thought Sanger Rainsford. Bang! Thunder like a gun fired in the sky and woke Rainsford up from a deep comfortable sleep. Rainsford , unable to go back to sleep, went to the window. The sky was night black with clouds. Lightning for a moment, lite up the beach And rainsford saw six dead black dog lying on the Scarlet sand, their necks snapped or split wide open.A pair of bloody footprints lead to the building gate .…

    • 1778 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bus 520 Research Paper

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages

    I can credit that same attitude or way of thinking to the way that I behave in the workforce. In reviewing my career path as and I coordinator I must be an effective communicator. It is crucial that I always have my attitude in check. I assume everyone I come in contact with is intelligent, stay motivated and have a genuine passion for what I do. I always take the iniative, listen to my customers and respond accordingly. Not only am I great with the customers but the employees and upper management as well. I am very responsible; I see projects thru to completion in a timely manner. I am a perfectionist at heart. I not only do my job because I have to but because I want to. I am honest and operate with integrity. I tell the truth even when I need to deliver bad news whether is to a customer or employer. A good employee such as me must keep commitments and special exceptions. Whether it be returning a follow up phone calls or reporting for a special project In handling my everyday task of dealing with customers. It is important that I show empathy or sympathy depending on the situation, seeming I deal with a variance of issues. Simply taking the time out to acknowledge someone else’s well-being shows that you care. However being or using all the attributes I mentioned above may not be easy to do all the time, it is beneficial to my employer or any employer for that part. It has allowed me to have high appraisals, afforded me work opportunities and the ability to be networked or marketable across many verticals in my career choice, which will later lead to job…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even if a person does not enjoy being around other people, everyone deserves a basic degree of respect from others. People should strive to be amiable and courteous towards other people, even towards individuals with whom they do not get along. A person can choose not to have certain people in his or her life, but if a person chose to frown and ignore everyone else, that person will almost definitely find him or herself in an undesirable position. A person who comes off as closed and unfriendly will most likely antagonize acquaintances, which can prove detrimental to a person’s personal and professional life. People perceived as negative or rude will have a harder time getting a job after an interview or getting promoted in the job they already have. For example, Dwight Schrute from NBC’s The Office, was interviewed by a panel of his colleagues for the job of branch manager. He was a dedicated, well-qualified hard worker. However, his authoritative, paranoid, self-centered personality drove his coworkers to instead choose Robert California to replace Michael Scott as Dunder Mifflin’s regional manager. If he had had a more open, friendlier disposition, his coworkers might have felt honored to make him their boss.…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Personality and job performances in the workplace are related. Have you heard of the big five factors? The big five factors are supposed to represent the beginning structure when it comes to all personality traits. The big five factors are mostly related with cooperating with other individuals amongst the workplace and about appreciating the workplace environment. The big five factors are: 1) Emotional stability, 2) Extraversion, 3) Openness, 4) Agreeableness, and 5) Conscientiousness. And of these five factors extraversion and conscientiousness are the two factors that determines and are responsible for positive job performances. But the one issue with the big five factor is that the results are based on jobs that are solely based on social interaction, jobs with not as much interaction with the individuals the big five factor has less impact of determining job performances. This is where cognitive abilities steps in because cognitive ability is brain based skills that each individual need to complete any task from the simplest to the most complex. A person with cognitive abilities perform just as good as or maybe even better than individuals who have favorable personality when it comes to working in a larger company where there is not too much interaction or socializing amongst the employees…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Nordstrom case study

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Now a days good service have become the most important value that a company no matter the industry need to have, therefore the need of employees who really enact it in their daily work is really important and it is in this value where personality plays and enormous part; personality is that thing that define who you are and how you understand the world, they way you act in an specific situation will completely depend on your personality which is constantly shaping depending on the experiences you have during your life time.…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    For instance, it is important to understand that we as people do what we want to do because we decide to. Not because we’ve been ordered to do. We must work as a group to achieve our ending goals. When we look at our occupations and how we do our job this is a concern. If someone’s orders are to follow orders from someone else then their job wouldn’t be very interesting. Not very fulfilling. But when you let others have a real say in the way things are done, they are most likely to accept the challenge. This is what I’ve learned doing my service learning project and watching how these staff interact with the clients. We need to give everyone the life they deserve to have a chance at…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    |that overlap are High Expectations Respect for the Diversity of Others Fairness Professional Conduct Reflection Curiosity Honesty Compassion |…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    8th Habits

    • 5018 Words
    • 21 Pages

    “How timely! How needed it is for one of the finest human beings, industrial leaders, and philanthropists on the planet to compellingly drill down on timeless, universal values for business and life. This book edifies, inspires, and motivates all of us to model these common sensical lessons for our organizations, all our relationships, and especially our posterity—for what is common sense is obviously not common practice. Primary greatness is character and contribution. Secondary greatness is how most people define success—wealth, fame, position, etc. Few have both. Jon’s one of them.”…

    • 5018 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Unless these types have strong Humanistic-Encouraging (1 o 'clock position) or Affiliative (2 o 'clock position) scores, they can be almost constant critics, relentlessly questioning and shooting down staff ideas (LSI, 2014). With this in mind, I recognize the multitude of opportunities I have to lessen and reduce this phenomena by engaging my staff in more proactive and inclusive ways. My ranking on the LSI reflects my current position on the management that I have received in recent employment, which is not accurate of my personal views on management. I do believe employees should have strong leadership and expectations, but I also believe employees need to be much more proficient in their technical and customer service skills. Managers who are dominant in being Self-Empowered need to ensure there is sufficient collaboration between the Accommodation style to meet organizational goals. I am committed to using the great merits of prestige to encourage my employees to strive for perfection; even though it may be seen as a way to measure worth. I do believe professional and technical work needs to be process-oriented, limiting the errors and improving productivity and opportunity for all to…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Encouraging the Heart

    • 10274 Words
    • 42 Pages

    Reflects upon one of the most elusive aspects of leadership - caring - and offers a deeper understanding of how and why it works. Premise is employees perform best when their contributions are genuinely appreciated. However, Kouzes and Posner assert most executives have not mastered the decidedly soft-management skill of "encouragement" that fosters such behavior. They advocate mutual respect and recognition of accomplishments to motivate and encourage others to be their very best. More importantly, they extend a set of principles, practices, and examples that show how to energize people to excel and then reach for even greater heights. Kouzes and Posner maintain that people will aspire…

    • 10274 Words
    • 42 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Organizations need managers that can take the diversity that is present, the good and the bad, and make it work to their advantage by providing positive influence to obtain desired results. This essay will give solutions to those leading individuals by offering a plan for positive influence. It will incorporate ways to increase motivation, satisfaction, and performance in the workplace. It will also address the differences in attitudes, emotions, personalities, and values, as well as how these components influence behavior.…

    • 1859 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Can Managers Be Too Nice

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages

    According to Dictionary.com, nice is an adjective and is defined as pleasing, agreeable, delightful, amiably, or pleasant. Now for a person to be too nice they have to go beyond what the definition states or due too much of what the definition states. One of my all-time favorite quotes is by Leo Durocher that, “Nice guys finish last.” and I’m still waiting for the day to prove that quote wrong. Well we can use that in business and say nice managers finish last. According to a study conducted by the University of Denver over a 20 year period, managers can finish last, not be promoted, or be taken as an ineffective leader for being too nice (“Nice Managers Finish Last”).…

    • 1470 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays