Preview

What a Star-What a Jerk: Harvard Business Review Case

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
716 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What a Star-What a Jerk: Harvard Business Review Case
As a team leader, Jane has already touched based with her group and recognized everybody’s role: Tom is “the joker,” Jack is “the intellectual,” Caroline is “the mom” and Andy is “the top performer and troublemaker.” She understands that all of them are high-paid employees and have been working as a group for a while, at least much longer than she has. As far as the performance, Jane believes that they are high performers and make up a very interesting and strong group; although there is no evidence of it since the company has been trying to keep the top 80% of employees, so all the members but Andy could be still working because the management like them and also be considered as average performers or even lower-level. What is true and seems to be temporary: Caroline, the oldest member, is currently having a questionable efficiency because some personal issues. Moreover, Jane has made up her mind with the idea that Andy has not only the best performance but also a nasty and irreversible behavior, so the team is pretty much split in two sides: Andy and the rest. Based on her first impressions about the company’s too-nicey-nice atmosphere, should she also think about that as Andy and the company? There is no way to know this. But what it seems to be obvious, is that the latter leader couldn’t fix this whole situation up either.

Andy’s behavior is always affecting the group with his frequently signals of nastiness. Since Jane’s start, he’s been stepping all over each member: Jack and the too-long-to-explain-flawed idea, Caroline and the “big mistake” with Andy’s 8-month important prospect, Tom and some kind of hot discussion. Even over Jane’s assistants, Maureen and Danielle, because of some “routine” mistakes (scheduling and customer’s information request, respectively). Hitting almost one month of e-mailing with Rick (an outside adviser, who acknowledged her as “softie” with routine mistakes), she’s still taking her time to explore the group and trying to figure
Continue Reading
View Writing Issues

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Compensation At Trader Joe's Case Study
    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Compensation At Trader Joe's Case Study

    3. For Hazel to establish herself as a successful team leader, she first and foremost needs to learn from the employers in which she would be leading. Personally, I think a new leader in the company should be hired externally because it’s important to let your employers train you. Knowing how your employers work and what their job routine or habits are will make Hazel more successful in leading them. Finally, she must also…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    LeadingTeamsatWestCoastTransit
    • 1074 Words
    • 3 Pages

    LeadingTeamsatWestCoastTransit

    Selecting a team from the member profile to collaborate on a West Coast Transit marketing project took deep thought and consideration. Everyone brings strengths and weaknesses to the company. First, I choose Natalie. Natalie works well on a team, is positive and ambitious. She works well in tense situation which is needed for this high stress project. Natalie has strong written communication skills as well, which is an added bonus. The next person I choose was Elizabeth. She enjoys collaboration, has a positive attitude is diplomatic and open minded. She is a detailed oriented, has a good work ethic and is good at meeting deadlines. Natalie and Elizabeth both will work well together with a team. I choose Katelyn as well because she is very driven and seeks a promotion. This will be her chance to prove herself to management. Katelyn likes to lead projects and will be proactive on the team. Next on the team is Susan. She is well respected, and others seek her out for guidance. She is creative and a go getter. This project will require new ideas to drive up sales. Susan also works well with others. I also choose William to be on the team. William is an easy going team player who also doesn’t mind leading a project. He and Katelyn can co-lead the project together. William is a veteran in his area of expertise and motivated by challenging work. Working as the leader with Katelyn will be a good fit for this project. Last but not least I will choose Ian. Ian is quick and efficient. He is also smart and tech savvy. This will be needed to develop a new sales approach for the company. Ian can bring in new ideas the company has never tried before. He is a key component to this project. I believe that all of the team members chosen will work well on this project together. Everyone may not work well on a team, but there are people that…

    • 1074 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Qcf5 Unit 510 Lead and Manage a Team
    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Qcf5 Unit 510 Lead and Manage a Team

    | “The top 10 features of an effective team are: * clear purpose; * open communication; * constructive conflict; * effective problem-solving and decision making; * defined roles, responsibilities and accountability; * strong relationships; * systems and procedures; * experimentation and creativity; * measurement and self-assessment; * shared leadership.” For a team to be effective, they need to have clear boundaries on what their job role is and any responsibilities relating to their job, and clear goals to give the team direction. Policies and Procedures are put into place and adhered to. Monthly supervisions, annual appraisals, daily diaries and communication books are used to ensure all staff are made aware of changes and continuity is maintained for the service users. “Positive leadership” also plays an important role, where managers are able to identify strengths and weaknesses within a staff team and utilise strengths while providing training and support for weaknesses. Training is also a key feature as it instils confidence within staff and helps staff to bond, improving relationships within the staff team. Conflicts are resolved with “healthy, professional confrontation” enabling staff to air their views and respond to others with issues. “Effective leaders are a bit like cheerleaders for the team, they encourage and support members who are committed and actively with their teams and engage those members who aren’t participating.”…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Ldr/531 Professional Development Plan Paper
    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Ldr/531 Professional Development Plan Paper

    Because the majority of the team members have a cautious behavioral style, it is to my advantage to have these individuals break down each assignment and project from the beginning to the end. They are also task-oriented which will bode well for each project. Their strengths are attention to detail and follow through. Lauren has the dominance behavioral style and likes to be in charge that will help to keep the group on track. Those with the cautious behavioral style tend to work at a slow pace and are extremely over analytical. As the leader of the team, my plan is to encourage my team members and recognize them for their achievements. Laura, who is supportive, will provide the encouragement the team needs to complete each task. She will also be strong on follow through and following up with each team member to ensure they are on track to complete each assignment. She is the most people-oriented of the group, so I will rely on her to maintain stability and balance in the group. Each team member will lead a project or assignment each week because each person will share some of the four behavioral styles depending on the nature of the assignments. Each team member will explore the behavioral styles of her fellow team members to understand each person fully on how they think, act, and interact with one another. This will enable each person to…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    LDR/531: Professional Development Plan
    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages

    LDR/531: Professional Development Plan

    My team seems to be pretty realistic in what is expected of them, as far as getting training that will father help them move forward. The ultimate goal will require more research to learn about how the team will be able to work together. The recommendation after reviewing all this information is that the team seems to be well rounded, dominate, yet focused, critical thinkers, and socially compatible members. We also came up with professional development plan for team members to reach their goals and still be happy in the work place. Before starting this assignment we all thought it would be difficult to keep every individual happy within the workplace. It would be in the team’s best interest to play to the members strengths and develop the weaknesses. Allowing the cautious member to lead the projects that were extremely detailed oriented and can be completed without much group interaction. The dominate member should be allowed to help with the structure and delegation of the tasks. They have strength in getting deadlines completed on time and are charismatic enough to lead. Anything that needs to be bid on or presented would be perfect for the interactive member. Using this type of formula allows everyone the opportunity to play to their strengths and in addition creates a strong potential for…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Better Essays

    SOC110 r6 W2 Effective Teamwork week 2
    • 1232 Words
    • 4 Pages

    SOC110 r6 W2 Effective Teamwork week 2

    Effective team are important, and their functions crucial to their success. I have found that clear goals, relaxed environment, open communication, and freedom to express ideas and feelings are great ways to ensure success. In the video “Helping Annie”, the dynamics of the team were lost due to lack of information, who was right and who could be trustworthy. When team members meet, they should feel as though they blend in with the group. They should feel a commitment to the goals and achievements to the group. What I know about groups are, that having valued diversity, defined roles, balanced participation, and cooperative relationships help with moving the group to a positive outcome. As a participative leader, as it is said in our eBook Working In Groups, “there is a balance of primary roles and when team members know their roles, work to their strengths, and actively manage weaknesses.” (Engleberg, 2013, p. 55).…

    • 1232 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Tears Of A Tiger Comparative Essay
    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Tears Of A Tiger Comparative Essay

    His personality changes and He begins to rebel against his parents and teachers, often disobeying his or her orders and acting out against them. Andy begins to become mischievous in school, setting of fireworks in his math class, not completing his assignments for English Class, and despite the encouragement from his teachers and the orders from his psychologist and parents, his behavior does not change, resulting in his grades to slip. Another reason why Andy is qualified for the Hall of Shame is because of his deception of his teachers, parents and his psychologist. He is successful in tricking most of the people who he is a associated with into thinking that he is no longer depressed and regretting his actions that caused the accident. The only person who he truly shows his emotions to is his girlfriend, Keisha, where he regularly has mood swings in her presence. Since he is not confronted about his mood swings because he is able to deceive most of the people in his life, He is never able to recover from the accident which eventually results in him committing…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Fred Mairino
    • 5283 Words
    • 14 Pages

    Fred Mairino

    Reading through the Fred Maiorino’s case, it is very much clear that the main key issue for this case was lack of motivation. The way Fred’s new boss Jim Reed motivated Fred to get going on his job wasn’t a very good way. Reed failed to understand that motivating an old employee is completely different than motivating a new energized employee. From motivating followers Dr. Yammarino points out that the individualized leadership should be evaluated with respect to three practical considerations; first human motivations are complex and are not always nice; second, leaders must cope with difficult people and a competitive, somewhat Darwinian world; third, leaders must make decisions that often result in someone losing and someone winning (Yammarino, 2000). Every human being and/or employee is different in nature and reacts differently given a variety of situations. Being a leader of a group of people is a complex job where the leader has to understand each employee. Some humans are easy to understand and make understand certain things while some people are so much difficult that they can never be understood in our whole life, just like our professor Dr. Humphreys mentioned in class about one person in his career whom he didn’t find out a way to motivate. Not just a single or couple, but there will be many people in every leader’s career whom they cannot find a way to motivate in a proper way. Thus, for these kinds of situations a leader should always be prepared with a bag of solutions. It’s a leader’s job to make sure that the workplace is competitive, rewarding and appraising so that someone is winning and someone is losing.…

    • 5283 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Ldr/531 Professional Development Research Paper
    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ldr/531 Professional Development Research Paper

    The four of us have some great qualities, as well as some not so great tendencies when it comes to doing work with others or getting what we want. As a team leader, it is vital for me to understand how each person thinks and acts so that I can plan accordingly and have a successful outcome on any type of project. Seeing as how three of us, including myself, have a more Interactive Style and one of us is a Cautious Style, I need to remain aware of what motivates each person to get the job…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    Learning Team Analysis
    • 2145 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Learning Team Analysis

    Beth’s leadership style reflects the Theory Y portion of the Theory X and Y theory of leadership. Her high scores on the learning team building assessment, in the concern for people and task sections, shows her ability to care for others and still accomplish the task. Beth’s conflict-handling style shows high scores for collaborating, accommodating, and compromise, three very significant factors for effective teamwork. The fact that her preferred forms of power…

    • 2145 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Reflection: My Role As A Directive Leader
    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Reflection: My Role As A Directive Leader

    I do my best to maintain a good rapport with my team members. I would say that they are comfortable approaching me if they need assistance. I encourage them to learn and accept new tasks assigned to them. I don’t stop to make everyone an in-group member in our unit. However, based from my observation, I will find few team members who are not motivated to excel themselves not because the leader isolates them from the in group members but because they prefer to be in the out-group situation. They choose to do less because they don’t want additional responsibilities. Nevertheless, I am a persistent charge nurse, I assign them new tasks to accomplish so they can benefit from the learning experience. To add to their confidence, I assured them with my presence and my willingness to help. It can be tough sometimes on my part because sometimes I end up spending a lot of coaching and monitoring them closely so they can be successful in completing their tasks. I am getting good job results from team members but inconsistently. The outcome of my leader-member relationship may not be of high-quality yet due to my being task-focused. But it is my hope that through this subject course I will be able to adopt or apply the different styles of leadership regardless what type of situation I will undergo at…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Powerful Essays

    The Features of Productive Working Relationships
    • 2593 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The Features of Productive Working Relationships

    The term ‘team’ is imbued with a meaning derived, from games. However, a more appropriate use of the term would be to use it in the working world and in the business industry where the term appears to be used far more loosely. ‘Team’, (in this instance), can be applied to individuals engaged in a common understanding where their separate roles are non existent. Managers in many work places will talk in an avuncular fashion, (positive) about their team. When a team is formed, (a process that will be discussed later in this report), roles must be assigned to each individual. Now, some individuals may fall into their roles because they have to right aptitude/skills to do so. Others may not have such clear abilities and would need a role assigned to them. Either way Belbin’s ‘Team Role Theory’ is relevant here, as it states that there are nine specific roles that any individual can have within a team;…

    • 2593 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    Team Leadership Essay Examples
    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Team Leadership Essay Examples

    “Team development is the cohesiveness of the team and the ability of group members to satisfy their own needs while working effectively with other team members (Nadler, 1998). This is in contrast to a work group who may not necessarily work well together, and may only care about their own self-interests. These are the ones who show up to the meeting table, give standard answers, little input, constructive criticism or feedback, and leave. As Northouse (2012) insists, “effective groups have a clear, engaging direction; an enabling performance situation that contains structure, support, and coaching; and adequate resources” (p. 299). Additionally, Northouse (2012) points out “Larson and LaFasto (1989) studied real-life successful teams and found that, regardless of the type of team, eight characteristics were consistently associated with team excellence”; which include; clear and elevating goals, results-driven structure, competent team members, unified commitment, collaborative work environment, high standards, support, recognition, and ethical leadership (p. 299). While the possession of all of these qualities and characteristics of a leader and its team may seem idealistic; they are elements which can guide the leader and its members towards…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Case Study 4.2 Finding the Emotional Intelligence to Be a Real Leader.
    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Case Study 4.2 Finding the Emotional Intelligence to Be a Real Leader.

    2. I think that out of five key elements of an effective real leader, Kathy showed her motivation and self-awareness. In her previous projects Kathy has shown that she is a talented project manager and the Asian project was a chance to demonstrate her true potential in front of upper level managers. Throughout the project Kathy showed that she is really motivated to succeed and wanted the project to be successful. In the first paragraph of the case study it is written that she is well organized. As for me, being organized is close to being self aware of you’re your own weaknesses and strengths. Overall, Kathy is a good project manager, but due to lack of social skills and empathy she couldn’t succeed and get approval from top managers of the…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
    Read More
  • Good Essays

    1.1 Explain the Features of Effective Team Performance
    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages

    1.1 Explain the Features of Effective Team Performance

    The features of effective team performance is set up through positive leadership, this is something which is developed and nurtured. An effective team will work together, be focused and all the time supporting each other along the way to achieve and reach goals. For a team to be effective, each team member needs to be clear on their roles and responsibilities relating to their job. Team performance will be more effective if there is respect for the leader/manager and an understanding towards their job role and responsibility. The leader/manager should also be aware of the skills or weakness within the team and be able to provide support were necessary and also utilise their strengths. Training and support will enable staff to improve performance, develop confidence and lift spirit within the team. A leader should encourage any conflicts to be resolved through healthy, professional confrontation and willingly and openly negotiate necessary changes. Effective leaders are a bit like cheerleaders for the team, they encourage and support members who are committed and actively with their teams and engage those members who aren’t participating.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
    Read More

Related Topics