Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

A Critical Thinking Approach to Public Education Reform

Powerful Essays
1459 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Critical Thinking Approach to Public Education Reform
A Critical Thinking Approach to Public Education Reform
There is no doubting the fact that this country’s educational system is in desperate need of reform. Low rates of graduation, poor student performance, fiscal instability, shortages of classes, gross disparity between the rich and poorer districts, and an over-abundance bureaucratic red-tape are a sad testament to the inadequacy of our schooling system. The reason for this is simple: macroeconomics. Without competition or the risk of failure, there is virtually no incentive to find more effective ways of satisfying customers. If the techniques of critical thinking are applied to the issue of education reform, one would find that the best course would be to privatize the bulk of our public institutions, permit individuals the freedom to choose where they want go to school, and implement a student voucher program for those with limited income.
Many people shudder at the thought of no free education but this is just a reactionary response.
Society as a whole would be better served if the educational complex was restructured in a way that optimizes free-market conditions.

Evidence of the failure of public education is all around us, from the glaring negligence seen in underprivileged districts throughout the nation to the crippling budget problems of local
California schools. The subpar quality of education that the majority of students receive is alarming. According to a recent study by the non-profit testing organization, ACT, “only 22 percent of U.S. students exiting high school met ‘college ready’ standards in all of their core subjects.” (Crotty 1). It has also been found that, despite the fact that the United States spends more per capita on K-12 education than many first-world countries, “U.S. students remain poorly prepared to compete with global peers, [ranking] fourteenth in reading, twenty-fifth in math, and seventeenth in science compared to students in other developed countries. Our idea of
"advanced" is clearly below international standards. There appears to be a consistent weakness in our teaching performance in the sciences that it may even be seen as widespread academic failure in this department. (…) Under 25% of Americans obtain a bachelor’s degree.” (Crotty 1).
The history of the educational establishment in this country gives many clues as to the explanation of why this is.

The decline of the educational system can be linked directly to its increased centralization and the strengthening of its ties to the federal government over the years. “[Public education] over time has become more defective as it has become more centralized. Power has moved from the local community to the school district to the state, and to the federal government, as evidenced by the drop in the number of school districts from 55,000 in 1955 to 15,000 in 1992.
About 90 percent of our kids now go to so-called public schools, which are really not public at all but simply private fiefs primarily of the administrators and the union officials.” (Friedman 1).
The unintended consequences of this are dismal: financial troubles across the board, often in the form of billion-dollar deficits; and a sharp contrast between the relatively good educational opportunities offered in wealthy communities and the disadvantaged, inner-city schools where
“high drop-out rates, increasing violence, lower performance and demoralized students and teachers” are commonplace.

It is a wonder why people refuse to abandon a system that yields such abysmal results.
There seems to be a prevailing belief in the fallacy that public education is ideal because it takes into account the plight of poor children. Though, in reality, such a system serves only to exacerbate the situation of the disadvantaged and education is not even really “free” because everyone pays for it through taxes. Via the modern educational structure, artificial circumstances have caused the demand curve for education to become inelastic, meaning that no matter how the quality and price of education may change for the worse, the demand for it remains unaffected. Taxpayer money goes straight to public schools, guaranteeing them revenue regardless of whether they merit it or not- and students often have no other choice to attend whichever school is in their locality. The only means that families have of selecting their children’s school is by moving to richer areas with better school districts. This phenomenon leads to the creation of ghettos, particularly in the inner cities, because low income families cannot afford to do the same. The schools in these areas are notorious for being of substandard quality, which results in an “achievement gap” between the economic classes. (Garrett 1). The unfairness inherent in our schooling structure is something that should not be tolerated.

When faced with a botched system, the only rational thing to do is to demand sweeping reform. If public education is to improve, the consolidated power of the schooling establishhment has to be broken. The laws of macroeconomics must also be taken into account, for, after all, education is an industry, and it is affected by these laws the same as any other.
Schools must be made to compete with each other- to improve classroom conditions, teaching techniques, and student accomplishment so that they keep and expand their clientele. This can be achieved through the means of a universal voucher program to aid low income students as well as ease the transitioning of public schools into profit-driven enterprises. Such a program would cut out the bureaucrat middleman and be much less expensive than what the government now spends per pupil. The vouchers must go directly to the students and have no conditions attached, allowing families the freedom to send their children to a school of their choosing. This would create a market for high-quality private schools that would attract entrepreneurs into the industry and facilitate the steady privatization of a substantial portion of public schools.
According to the laws of macroeconomics, the competitive nature of the market would plunge costs down and drive educational standards up, as firms try to make them-selves as appealing as possible in order to gain more profit. Soon, a first-rate education, once only accessible to the privileged few, will become available to the vast majority. “The innovations in the ‘luxury’ product will always spread to the basic product when there is completion for profit. If this vision is realized, everybody, except a small group of those with vested interests, will win: parents, students, dedicated teachers, taxpayers- for whom the cost of the educational system will decline- and especially the residents of central cities, who will have a real alternative to the wretched schools so many of their children are now forced to attend.” (Orozco 1).

The benefits of the shift from public to private education would be immeasurable. Not only would a dramatic rise in student performance and lower tuition costs be seen, but new methods of teaching and technological progress in these areas would also be likely to surface.
Worthy teachers would obtain higher salaries as schools compete to engage the best ones, especially now that funds would cease going to the pensions of bureaucrats. Taxpayers would no longer be burdened with paying for bloated government administration in schools. Class stratification would be greatly reduced by the advent of vouchers and the widespread availability of inexpensive, high-quality educational prospects. In fact, such reforms might go a long way in expanding the upward mobility of the disadvantaged and lessening the rigidity of the present social order.

When the academic system in the United Sates is analyzed from a critical thinking perspective, it becomes obvious that the major problem is that it’s structured in a way that stifles the market forces. This is the underlying cause of most of its issues with incompetence and mismanagement. A far-reaching voucher plan coupled with the privatization of a considerable number of public schools would introduce competition to the industry, paving the way for a free- enterprise system of education that would be much more innovative and cost-effective than its public-sector counterpart. If this ground plan was to be put into practice, more people would have access to a better quality education than ever thought possible.

Sources:
Garrett, Rose. “Factoring in the Achievement Gap.” Education.com. Web. 6 July 2012.

Orozco, Graciala L. “Understanding the Culture of Low-Income Parents: Key to Involvement.” School Community Journal 18.1 (2008): 21-37. ERIC. Web. 6 July 2012.

Friedman, Milton. “Public Schools: Make Them Private.” June 23, 1995. The Hoover Institute. WEB. Cato.org.

Crotty, James Marshall. “7 Signs that U.S. Educational Decline is Jeopardizing its National Security.” March 26, 2012. Forbes publications. WEB. Forbes.com.

Devins, Neal. “Centralization in Education: Why Johnny Can’t Spell Bureaucracy.” 1987. Facutly Publications. WEB. Law.wm.edu.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Despite The U.S education is prestigiously considered one of the best one worldwide, it now has issues shocking us with more illiterate students seen all over. As Micheal Moore, an Author, Filmmaker and Winning Oscar director, bring to light this phenomenon in his article" Idiot Nation" he labels the education system as "subservience" and " go out of its way to remain ignorant and stupid." The author argues the money has been continuously steered off for education resulting in deterioration of school buildings, not sufficient libraries and low qualities of teachers, that are plaguing the education today. In order to fully analyze and understand Micheal Moore' article, I will focus on presenting different approaches on the impact of insufficiently funding the flawed education.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Have you ever felt like you or your child is not getting a proper education? Are you a student who has below average grades and yet still manages to pass your class? Have you ever wondered why the U.S has gone from 18th in math to 31st? The answer to these questions, and many more that people have been posing is quite simple. Our education has just simply gotten worse. Many people today in society believe our education has gotten worse, though some believe that it is up to standards. I believe that our education has actually gotten worse, because the quality of our education has been going down, our performance has been going down, and our standardized tests are a mess.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Schooling is seen as a necessary part of life in America for generations, needed to transform the children of the nation into happy and productive individuals. Unfortunately, there seems to be a problem with overall performance. According to the Program for International Student Assessment survey administered by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development in 2012, the United States ranks 27th in math, 17th in reading, and 20th in science. According to the OECD the US spends more on education than most countries with an average of $115,000 per student (PISA, 1). Unfortunately, that level of spending has not equaled an improvement in education. We have tried to improve our schools with more money, better teachers, and legislation such as No Child Left Behind Act of 2001. What if the true problem with schooling is not the components of the system, but the system itself? In the article “Against School” John Taylor Gatto present several causes for the failing of the American public school system. One of the main causes he puts forth is the institution of compulsory schooling in a system designed to repress the working class, keeping the classes…

    • 1400 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The government needs to support more funding for the public school system, so the next generation of children who born in lower class family can better advance themselves and achieve a bigger piece of the American dream. According to Bob Herbert from Hiding From Reality, “For all the talk about the need to improve the public schools and get rid of incompetent teachers, school systems around the country are being hammered with dreadful cutbacks and teachers are being let go in droves,…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The United States is an economic leader in part because of its leadership in education during the 20th century. We were the first country in the world to provide free K-12 public education and for many decades our citizens where the most educated and well prepared to drive national economic growth. In the past few decades, other countries have greatly expanded and improved their education systems, and now we’ve and we’ve lost our leading edge.…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nation At Risk

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Our nation is at risk: this is how the legendary “A Nation at Risk” opened its scathing assessment of American public schools in 1983. The paper gave five recommendations to fix the problems of the U.S. education system: strengthened requirements, measurable standards, higher pay for teachers, increased time in the classroom, and accountability. Today, the country still faces many of the same problems, such as teacher shortages, low test scores, and poor teacher training programs. In the past forty years, the United States has doubled the expenditures it spends for every child to get an education, with no concrete improvements in student achievement (Guggenheim & Chilcott, 2010). According to the Program for International Student…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are many issues plaguing the educational system that need to be assessed immoderately. The American government needs to increase the number of students pursuing a higher education without diminishing the quality of learning. Through subsidies and government assistance the general public may have greater chances of earning a degree. Equally important work experience and military service time should count towards a college degree to allow the working class equal opportunity. Thirdly through lobbying and promoting public interests we may approach the issues congesting the school system and give birth to a brighter tomorrow.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Wake up at 0600! March to the cold brick walls and get ready to be stripped if you individuality. It doesn't matter if you don't understand, there is only one answer and only one way to get it!” Doesn't that sound like fun? Well, that's every day for most students. Not students in prison or students in the military, students in a normal public school. Every day children are forced to wake up at ungodly hours, put into classes with a curriculum made way too long ago to be useful, and told there is only one answer and one way to get it. The American school system need reform. Students are unhappy, they are overstressed and students that learn a different way, even a little different, are left behind in the dust and fall behind. School reform…

    • 859 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    True Education Flaws

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Not all students are equally prepared for success. There are various reasons a student might be set a disadvantage. Some of these reasons may be discrimination, economical issues, language barriers, or location. On the issue of discrimination, James Baldwin said, “Now by this time the negro child has had almost all the doors of opportunity slammed in his face.” Students with bigger problems than school may not be motivated to achieve success in school. A student that struggles to keep food on the table probably won’t think about doing his math homework. I believe not that there are problems with our education, but rather in our education system. Right now, how we are taught by receiving information then being tested on it. Although people may not like this method, it is the best to keep student honest and on track. There is no other way to see where students are at efficiently. Without tests, the learning would be all genius and no drill. The system is meant for no student left behind. Of course, that is not possible due to the many problems. The most a school can do is to be supportive and provide engaging teachers. The rest falls into the hands of the student. The education system can’t control what a student does outside of school activities, but it can still have a hopefully positive influence at best. I believe that is why the problems haven’t been fixed. The system lacks…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Government plays a big role in dumbing down education by not really caring about how much our students are actually learning, instead they just pass them to try to compare with other countries education such as Japan, China as well as others that are above America and because our government doesn’t take our education seriously we are ranked really low compared to the other schools in different countries, also there is a conspiracy that not only is the government involved…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    .Being the world power it is today, United States is the land of freedom, and opportunity. But is it really? We have been lacking behind in the place that matters most: education. Finland currently has the best performing education system in the world; they are number one in literacy and number two in math proficiency. United States on the other hand, is number seven in literacy and number 27 in math proficiency. Education isn't the same as it was fifty years ago. Times have changed, and so has the economy. Getting a college degree is no longer a guarantee of a job, and getting an education has become more tedious with standardized tests around every corner. Reforming public education requires two steps: teaching skills that will be…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Despite nearly three decades of education reform that started with President Lyndon B. Johnson’s Great Society program in 1965 the United States still has substantial need for reform and change focusing on student achievement. Educational reform across the nation has been littered with dozens of educational reform strategies and goals. Federal, state, and local leaders have attempted educational changes using school vouchers, charters, merit pay, and school choice. However, as the government has continued to increase it’s spending in educational reform impoverished schools have continued to see decreases in student achievement. Fundamental improvements within educational reform has to focus on the large swaths of students who drop out of school.…

    • 215 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    American students fall so far behind in education than students in India, Asia and Europe especially in math and science. As educational researcher Harold Stevenson (1993) notes, although "the U.S. is among the countries expending the highest proportion of their gross national product on education, our elementary school and secondary school students never place above the median in comparative studies of academic achievement."…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    3 Things

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Education is a serious problem in some parts of the world, and making it possible for anyone,…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Education Reform

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages

    America is faced with a challenge harmful to the future of the nation: education reform. This issue was brought about by the idea that America's public school system is failing. Many have opinions as to why the system is not working, why students are failing, and why we are ranked as the twenty-ninth in our education system (anaphora). However, Finland is the fifth most successful education system in the world (Reporters, 2015). Unlike many countries, Finland emphasizes on equality and well-being. Not only that but they have also eliminated standardized testing and hire teachers that meet the top requirements for the job. The future of America is dependent on the success of the younger generation and education is one of the principal keys…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays