Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Compare and Contrast Political and Economic Effects of the Mongols on China and Russia During Postclassical Era

Good Essays
503 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast Political and Economic Effects of the Mongols on China and Russia During Postclassical Era
A compare and contrast essay on the political and economic effects of the Mongols on China and Russia during the Postclassical era.
The Mongols are a large nomadic group of people, in which throughout the course of world history have invaded, conquered, and dominated multiple civilizations. Two of these dominated civilizations include China, conquered in the early 13th century and Russia, conquered around the same time as China. These two dominations of different regions brought about numerous political and economic changes, however the styles of influence differed greatly from each other. On the contrary, there were similar political and economic influences caused by the Mongols on each Postclassical civilization.
In China, political impact from the Mongols came off much more strict and centralized than what politically occurred in Russia, and will have a more significant effect. When Kublai Khan established the Yuan dynasty, he practically conquered China, however he applied a “split effect” in which he would separate the Mongols from the Chinese. Kublai put this into place because he was afraid of intermarriage, and as a result, banned it. He also ruled the fact that Chinese scholars were not permitted to learn Mongolian script, and that the Chinese military will remain separated from the Mongolian military. The power for rule came mostly from Kublai’s dynasty. The same nomadic group also conquered Russia, a region where political impact is greatly diverse. Most of the rule in Russia came from the Khan of the Golden Horde. The status of people in Russia was demoted in a way, from a higher position to a lower one. The Russian princes had become vassals and the peasants had become serfs to the princes for their own protections. Because of the peasantry converting to serfs, serfdom is later introduced as well as the princes to begin collecting taxes and tribute.
Economically, the impacts of the Mongols on Russia and China are clearly expressed in different styles but will contribute to the development of future civilization. The Mongolian-Chinese economy consisted of a couple of key factors that the Mongolian-Russian economy lacked. Firstly, during the Yuan dynasty was the high point of respect for merchants. This implies that the merchants in China in this period were highly regarded as necessary people for a prospering civilization. Secondly, the Chinese, during the rule of the Yuan dynasty, had also implemented the use of paper money and was rapidly expanding. Lastly, the call for foreign people for various occupations may have led to a temporary boom in the economy, but will not last forever. The Mongols of China had supplied numerous jobs, such as, Muslim engineers, scholars, and doctors, and Persian astronomers. In Russia, the economic impacts were not as heavy of those of China. However, there was some sort of benefit brought upon Russia. Moscow was a city that benefitted immensely from an economic standpoint, due to the city being a tribute collector for the khans, in which Moscow will soon become the head of the Russian Orthodox Church.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The nomads of central Asia during the thirteenth century returned to center stage in world history. The Mongols ended or interrupted the great postclassical empires while extending the world network of that era. Led by Chinggis Khan and his successors, they brought central Asia, China, Persia, Tibet, Iraq, Asia Minor, and southern Russia under their control. The states formed dominated most of Asia for one and a half centuries. The Mongol success was the most formidable nomadic challenge to the global dominance of the sedentary, civilized core civilizations since the first century C.E. The Mongols often are portrayed as barbarian, destructive…

    • 4257 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    19 Mongol Study Guide

    • 668 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “In addition to (the Mongols) importance to Moscow and the Orthodox Church, Mongol contacts led to changes in Russian military organization and tactics and in the political style of Russian rulers. Also Mongol example may have influenced the desire of Russian princes to centralize their control and reduce the limitations placed on their power by the landed nobility, clergy, and wealthy merchants.” While the Mongols had some positive influence on other countries, in the case of the Mongol dominance over the Muslim world, they had a far more negative influence. “It is understandable that Muslim historians treated the coming of the Mongols as one of the great catastrophes in the history of Islam. The…

    • 668 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unlike China, Russia was not under direct rule and the Mongols had Russian princes rule over…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mongols conquered and controlled most of Asia during the early civilizations. Unfortunately, the manner in which they acquired this land was ruthless and barbaric. The Mongols started out as simple nomads grazing the pastures. They lived in steppes and had to learn to survive the harsh temperatures there. The different tribes often got into disputes over land for their animals and fought very often. This made the Mongols tough mentally and physically.…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Mongolian rule fell long ago, its influence can still be seen today. In Russia and China, the Mongol era brought a change in political power. The Khans, or “Great Leaders”, ruled both places, although not equally. China was directly ruled by the Mongols, seeing that China hosted them in the Yuan province, while Russia was given a sense of self rule. The Mongols still claimed taxes and sought goods from Russia, but did not actually occupy it as they did in China. The lack of occupancy in Russia eventually led to the downfall of the Mongol rule there seeing that there was no opposing force to govern them, thus putting power back to the Russians, and creating what we know Russia as today.…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    During 13th century, the Mongols ruled both China, and Russia. The Mongols had similar and different political and economic effects on these regions. For example, the Khans chose a Russian ruler to take the position as Grand Prince and gave them the authority over other rulers. In contrast, the Mongols gave native Chinese no power within their government, but in fact they brought in Arabs, Europeans, and Persians to help them rule. In addition, during the Yuan Dynasty circa 1279, Kublai Khan insinuated himself into Chinese society by establishing an economic and political system that was familiar to the Chinese such as Confucianism. While in Russia entirely new governmental and economic systems were put into place and Russia became a feudal state. The Mongols also had similar effects, for example, in both regions the Mongols made a positive impact on their economies. They secured important trade routes within the region and contributed their effective trade techniques. Safer Russian trade routes and the Silk Road brought prosperity to these regions.…

    • 833 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    When the Mongolian armies of the Golden Horde started to move west, by the 13th century, Kiev was in a period of decline and Russia was divided into small kingdoms. These Russian kingdoms were unable to unite and create a large army before the Mongols came to attack and conquer their land. Batu, Chinggis Khan’s grandson, invaded in 1236 and defeated Russian armies (after being taken over, the Russians became vassals of the Khan of the Golden Horde). Also the Mongols were mostly negative, Mongol occupation was important to Russia. This is shown through the influence of military and political organization. But most importantly, the Mongols isolated Russia from developments in western European civilization; like the Renaissance and the…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the years between 1100 and 1400 the Mongol empire stretched the farthest of any empire throughout history. Within the massive land under Mongol rule laid the lands of China and Russia. The Mongols knew how to maintain their empire but had different ways of doing it in each part. This lead to the separate, divergent ways of governing the two lands. In China and Russia, the Mongol era brought an immense change in political and economical power.…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The only society that gained the most out of this period was China. In order to stop the first invasion of the Mongols, they built the Great Wall of China. The society that gained the least was probably Russia because by cutting of Russia from the rest of the land, the Mongols caused problems between Russia and the Greek Orthodox churches. In conclusion, the Mongols conquered many societies.…

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mongols were a nomadic people until 1206, when they acknowledged Temujin as the supreme leader, Genghis Khan. A huge empire was created under his rule, linking Eastern and Western Eurasia. An analysis of these documents will discuss the topic of how the Mongols expanded their empire so far in such a short time through their power of violence. This analysis will also show the admiration and respect of the Mongols by others in surrounding regions. Ultimately, this analysis will discuss how the fear from other people gave the Mongols their biggest advantage in conquering other regions to expand their enormous empire.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mongol conquests impacted places differently, however, in China and Russia, the Mongols had a large influence on both their political and their economic systems. Both China and Russia had good governing systems and a strong economy. The Mongols attacked China, slaughtered many people, deported laborers and skilled workers, and were able to make use of Chinese administrative practices, techniques of taxation, and their postal system which was able to allow the Mongols to…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In spite of the fact that the Mongols are only perceived for their “barbaric” behaviors, they impacted the development of China. Because of their structured laws and leadership, citizens were obedient and united under Mongol rule. Economy during the Mongol Empire was thriving and they even spread that wealth to other cities and regions. Under the Mongols, 4,860,000 square miles of land was conquered, the largest conquest in the world. The Mongols may not have been liked by the Chinese, but their is no denial that their rule did not lead to many beneficial…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mongol Empire Dbq Essay

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The effects of Mongol expansion include increased violence and the increase in security in trading and industry. As an example of increased violence, “the Mongols now descended from the walls and began to slay and plunder.. They then drove all the survivors, men and women, out onto the plain; (Document 1)” This evidence describes how violent the Mongols were when they entered a city in Persia known as Nishapur. The acts of violence being described in this event shows that other societies are apprehensive about the Mongols, for this instance on their strictness. The strictness of the Mongols is what causes them to be a fierce, violent empire. Another effect of Mongol expansion comes from the increase in trade security. As it is described, “were it not…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mongols- Virtual v.s. Real History By: Sarah Hornbarger The Mongols, a group who conquered a huge part of Asia, existed from 1000-1500 CE (All Empires). This empire was known for its brutality and swift military conquerings, and played a huge role in shaping Asian and European history and culture.…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays