There were many reasons for the Tsar’s abdication and murder, the war being one of them however there were many other reasons such as the lack of political reform and the state of the country before the war itself.
However I agree that the First World War was a very big reason for the relinquishment of Tsardom in 1917. Russia had the largest army and gained some early successes against Austria-Hungary, but that was not to last. They suffered major defeats during the war such as the battles of Tannenburg and the Masurian lakes. This is because Russia was still a ‘Backward agrarian economy’ no match for the modernised superpowers in the war like Germany which was the reason for many of Russia’s defeats. Not only that, the Russian army was also very large and unorganised; lead by aristocrats who neither had the knowledge or skill to lead the massive army, many of the top officers had been appointed because of their loyalty to the Tsar. Furthermore the performance of the War Ministry was dire, compounded by the breakdown of the distribution system: there was a lack of supplies and equipment, especially rifles, ammunition and boots. Additionally, the Tsar was the leader of the army so all the military defeats were the Tsar’s fault in the view of the public. As a result the tsar became very unpopular for the defeats in the war and lost the support of the army because of the incompetence of their officers and the lack of regard for their welfare.
The First World War also affected the many people at home who were already suffering before the war itself. The strain of equipping and feeding millions of soldiers proved too much for the Russian economy and revealed its structural weaknesses. The military needs had the priority and so it was very difficult for Russia to keep food production up because of all the people leaving for the war and so agriculture collapsed because it was very labour intensive and peasant’s stopped selling as there was little incentive to do so. Inflation compounded these problems, Russia abandoned the gold standard and started printing money to pay wages and so government spending increased which lead to the price of food and fuel to quadruple. Hundreds of factories closed and thousands became unemployed. To conclude, the situation in Russia went from bad to extremely bad with unemployment, inflation and lack of supplies which lead to many extremist groups gaining support.
However the war wasn’t the only main reason for why the Tsar was overthrown. It was also the Tsar’s failure to make any political reforms after the revolution of 1905 which nearly lead to the deposition the Tsar. During the war the tsar had the chance to make some concessions to political that might have saved him. Russia could have slipped into a constitutional monarchy and the pressure would have been taken off him personally. However that did not occur and the Tsar continued to contradict the Duma’s purpose by upholding the Fundamental laws. Nicholas had shown that he was never really willing to work with or listen to the Duma. He looked for excuses to close down session; he was only concerned with preserving the autocracy largely because he believed it was a better way of running Russia. He did not understand that by passing some of his responsibilities to an elected assembly, he could avoid the criticism and hostility directed at him from various sections of Russian society which was exactly what happened between 1906 and 1917. A mention could also go to Tsar himself and his inability to rule which was also a reason for the Tsar’s relinquishment.
One of the main causes for the abdication of the tsar was the state of Russia even before the war which had put the Russian people in a lot of misery and suffering. The Russian peasants and urban workers, who were already suffering from terrible conditions because of the Legacy of Serfdom, had been forced to pay redemption taxes and live on terribly low wages because of Witte’s policies. The result of the poor living conditions and taxes forced people to live in rooms that more than 10 people. This gave the Russian workers a mass consciousness and it was much easier to organise themselves into different radical groups and such. Furthermore the economic slump after 1900 had led to high unemployment and social tensions in town which led to more uprisings and opposition to be formed Bolsheviks and Octoberists which contributed to the abdication of the tsar.
In conclusion, I believe that the First World War was a very important for the abdication of the tsar, if not the most important reason as it ruined the economy, sociality and welfare of the people. All the countries’ economies were left in tatters after the war but they were able to recover better because of their industrialisation unlike Russia whose economy broke down and collapsed. However the lack change and political reform and the social and economic problems even before the war were important reasons too.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
After the riots of 1917, the Tsarist regime collapsed, and many would argue that it was mainly as a result of the First World War beginning in 1914.…
- 1166 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In July 1918, the royal Romanov line was suddenly and brutally ended by the Bolsheviks. The Romanov family had ruled the Russian Empire for over three centuries. The Romanovs reign was one of strict tyranny. Tsar Nicholas II of Russia made one big step toward a more equal Russia by freeing the serfs but because the serfs owned no land they had little to no money still. After WWI when nicholas led Russia to a crushing defeat there was lots of unrest throughout Russia. I think that the main reason the Tsar was forced to abdicate the throne and then was slaughtered is that he made a more equal Russia but in doing so he made the serfs more impoverished than ever, that he had led Russia into multiple wars that had ended badly and that the technology…
- 151 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
World War 1 was a crucial and defining factor which led to the collapse of the Romanov Dynasty in February, 1917. Without it a revolution would not have happened at this point in time. This is not to say a revolution would not have eventually happened, as there were many other contributing factors that sparked the revolution. However, what World War 1 essentially did was to heighten discontent throughout society enough for it to revolt.…
- 875 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
5. How far was Nicholas II responsible for the fall of the Romanovs in 1917?…
- 313 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
How far do you agree that the most important cause of the February 1917 revolution was the Great War
How far do you agree that the most important cause of the February 1917 revolution was the Great War?…
- 1065 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In 1917 Tsar Nicholas II signed a deliration to abdicate from power; this was due to a number of long term and short term factors; some being of Nicolas II own problems and some being general problems that faced Nicholas II. When Tsar Nicholas II came to power many problems faced him, such as lack of industrial revolution, political problems, economical problems etc… Nicholas II was a very strong believer in autocracy and the belief that he had been made Tsar by God, however Nicholas was a very poor leader to the people of Russia, growing political problems and the war pushed Nicholas II to abdicate.…
- 1510 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
To what extent do you consider that the First World War was a key turning point in the development of modern Russia in the years 1856-1964?…
- 1981 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
The losses over the course of the war were staggering, making it very unpopular throughout Russia, all while oppression and corruption persisted throughout the government. With shortages of food and water along with mass rioting in 1917, soldiers abandoned its government to side with the citizens demanding change inside the government. The Duma commanded that the Czar resign and Nicholas II relinquished his power. Nicholas II were shortly thereafter exiled and later executed, ending the Russian…
- 685 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
How far do you agree that the use of repression was the main reason for the weakness of opposition to Tsarism in the years 1881 – 1914?…
- 648 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Nicholas II started a very unnecessary war with Japan which was a huge mistake that he made. The Tsar made plans to seize control of Constantinople and expanded into Manchuria and Korea. Japan did not like this. As he did this Japan felt threatened by his action and on February 8th, 1904 the Japanese navy surprised attacked on the Russian fleet at Port Arthur. As this point the Russian army was not in a very good place to be. Also, when World War 1 started the the Russian army was not properly supplied. By December 1914 the Russian army had 6,553,000 troops; however they only had 4,652,000 rifles. Untrained troops were forced into battle without rifles and ammunition. According to spartacus-educational.com, the army had about one surgeon every 10,000 men. Many soldiers would die from wounds that could be treated, but there was nobody to treat them. These men were sitting ducks waiting for a fellow soldier to fall just to pick up their gun to…
- 816 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
March 14 1917, Nicholas II fell from power, there was lots of reasons but my three main reasons are; The State of the Army and how they weren't ready for war, The Role of the Duma and how they wanted the Tsar out of power, and Rasputin how he had control over Nicholas's wife…
- 945 Words
- 4 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The war had an adverse effect on the Russian economy. The rising cost of food caused food shortages. Industrial workers went on strike to increase wages and by the end of the war and a new government emerged following Nicholas II abdication. The already delicate domestic political situation in Russia would be imperiled by Nicholas II’s personal affiliation with the military wealth of his country. Any other military commander could be blamed for a disaster and then dismissed, but by taking personal command the Emperor would now take personal as well as political responsibility for all military failures. The crumbling of the Russian position in the field after he assumed command made such an outcome inevitable regardless of innumerable…
- 1728 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In the Revolution of 1905, Russians gained new political freedom. However, Russia was still plagued with problems. The famine from previous years still raged on. In 1914, Russia joined World War I. To pay for the war, Russia raised taxes, secured foreign loans, and printed more money. This combined with many other factors, left the people of Russia wanting change. They needed the government to change, the famine to end, and economic stability.…
- 715 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Assess the view that the First World War was the main cause of the collapse of Romanov rule…
- 1023 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Millions of Russian soldiers and civilians died in the war. This completely discouraged the Russian soldiers that were fighting in the war, observing their comrades dying and couldn't do anything about it since they had no weapons. As strikes and demonstrations spread, the government called in troops, or the “Okhrana” to enforce peace. However, most of them were already against the Tsar and decided to join the protesters’ side. This created great civil conflict.…
- 1244 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays