Preview

Punishment Fails to Teach Socially Appropriate Behaviors

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1102 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Punishment Fails to Teach Socially Appropriate Behaviors
Punishment Fails to Teach Socially Appropriate Behaviors

Have you ever wondered why after you punish a child, he will most likely commit the offense again when you are not looking? The reason punishment is so ineffective in stopping an undesirable behavior is simple. Punishment is only effective for a certain period of time. Punishment does not teach students to act appropriately. Instead, it can increase undesirable behaviors. The best way to get desired behaviors is through reinforcement, either positive or negative. Positive reinforcement should replace punishment (Holub and Harrington). Punishments may have a physical, psychological, and emotional consequence. Punishment is both ineffective and harmful. Teachers may punish students for reasons unrelated to their bad behaviors, either unconsciously or for reasons they deny. According to Is Punishment an Effective Technique to Control Behavior?, "John Maag bemoans the fact that most teacher discipline for student disruption involves various forms of punishment such as removal from the classroom, fines, restitution payback, and in-school and out-school suspensions and expulsions. He believes that teachers "overlook the long-term benefits of positive reinforcement."
The first thing that we need to get straight is that negative reinforcement is different from punishment. A punishment is something negative or bad added as a consequence to an action in an attempt to stop a behavior. Negative reinforcement, on the other hand, is something bad taken away as a reinforcement or reward to strengthen a desired behavior. Positive reinforcement is adding something favorable as a reward to get a certain result. John Maag argues that teachers are ignoring data, which he believes is relatively important in our part of the world:
Researchers have typically relied on empirical data to convince people of the effectiveness of a particular technique, model, or approach. If this tactic worked, application of positive

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    I tend to agree that if a person knows that they are getting rewarded they will more than likely to continue to have good behavior. Nothing about punishment was mentioned in this article about children who are defiant when doing this study. It did not mention what would happen if the student refused to cooperation in doing the study. Of course, in Skinner’s behavior modification on punishment in Organizational Management and Leadership he states that if punished you should as taking something away then the problem will more than likely not occur again. I tend to think this way in children if you punished them in the right way of course they will tend to repeat it again. When I was a children our punishment was getting a spanking, out parents did not worry about taking something away but the spanking was enough to remind me not to do it again. In today’s society being spanked is no longer acceptable. I do believe in discipline a child that does not mean to abuse…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Unit 8 P1 M2

    • 3137 Words
    • 10 Pages

    With negative reinforcement the occurrence of a behavior is increased by removing an unpleasant stimulus. “For example, your dog can avoid being spanked when it sits in response to your command. If the dog has been getting spanked, not getting spanked is rewarding (removal of unpleasant stimulus) so the frequency of the behavior will increase.” People confuse negative reinforcement with punishment--just remember that with reinforcement you increase the occurrence of the behavior but…

    • 3137 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    While in some instances, positive reinforcement works well, but as this article has shown that may not always be the case. In most instances, it may cause lower self-esteem, lower grades, and an inability to cope with failure. Reading through the article the author shows that positive reinforcement can be more harmful than positive. Studies show that children who are told they are smart are usually less…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Research consistently shows that teachers typically reprimand students far more than they praise them. Why do you suppose this is so? I believe teachers focus more on reprimanding students and not praising them, due to the belief that punishment will provide quick results. I also think when a student is being disruptive it draws more attention versus if the student was not.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Sanctions and rewards are a very useful way to manage positive behaviour as a child learns that if they are well behaved he/she will receive a reward such as a sticker, certificate or award etc. They also know that if a rule is broken there will be a consequence no matter how big or how small, such as time out- time off rewards, staying in with staff and time off the playground. It is the ‘certainty’ of the sanction not the ‘severity’ that makes it so effective.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    5.09 Parenting Skills

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I do believe that using consequences and following the ABC process will help shape a child’s behavior. As long as the consequence is related to the offense it will make a difference. The child will realize that you are serious and will want the consequences to stop; thus molding the behavior.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Negative reinforcement is also a very common behavior, but it can sometimes be confused with punishments. Negative reinforcement often prevents or ends a bad outcome. People often use negative…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    By rewarding positive behaviour it encourages the child to carry on seeking rewards and also shows other children what they would receive if they emulate this behaviour. This in turn will make the classroom experience much more pleasant for all children and staff and, therefore, enable the teacher’s and teaching assistants to teach a lesson without any disruption from inappropriate behaviour. Children may try to gain attention by displaying bad behaviour, it is important not to give the child the attention they are looking for and give the attention to the children who are behaving properly.…

    • 237 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Assertive Classroom Model

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Alberto and Troutman’s (as cited in Lyons, Ford, & Slee, 2014) Applied Behaviour Analysis (ABA) model has its roots situated in Skinner’s early work on behaviour modification. Consequently, the principles of behaviourism provide the foundation for the ABA model. In the classroom the teacher maintains absolute control of students by altering the environment in order to encourage desired behaviour and discourage undesirable behaviour, while providing consequences in the form of rewards and punishment (Lyons et al., 2014). This is based on the notion that behaviours are enacted willingly and can be changed by controlling the environment and “reinforcing consequences” (Lyons et al., 2014, p. 29). Accordingly, students quickly comprehend there are immediate rewards for ideal behaviours and…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Coercipator Generalization

    • 1323 Words
    • 6 Pages

    To build on the example above, there were children working quietly and diligently on their artwork. It was much easier and more enjoyable for me to praise these students for their hard work than to constantly correct the student I was in the coercive cycle with. Teachers may face the same sort of competing contingencies in the classroom. Perhaps there are other bright, well-behaved students with which the teacher would prefer to interact. Perhaps grading papers is more reinforcing than classroom management. Interventions themselves are not always inherently rewarding. It can be aversive to implement corrective feedback, response cost, and time out as part of an intervention. It may be more reinforcing in the short term to do nothing than to engage in the potentially aversive intervention. However, interventions are reinforcing when they improve student behavior. Consultants can help make the reinforcing properties of an intervention more salient by offering praise, supportive statements, and empathy in consultative meetings (Allen & Warzack, 2000). This may make the consultation process more enjoyable for the consultee as well as create an environment where the teacher feels comfortable asking questions to improve treatment integrity. Secondly, the consultant may enlist the support of others who can provide reinforcement for implementing the…

    • 1323 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Spanking Research Paper

    • 1370 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Some also try rewarding their kids for good behavior. “When a child is verbally corrected, apart from the use of any other form of punishment, the result is almost always a disaster. The child quickly learns that you are all talk and no action. A child then learns that the tongue lashing is that, just a voice. Therefore they learn how to tune you out.” (usingspakingdiscipline.com). Rewarding children for good behavior teaches them that they should only be good to get something out of it. They need to learn that they can do good deeds for the purpose of being a good person, not to get a reward. Children may also learn to behave badly to get a reward. Grounding your kids usually never work. Most parents ground their kids and forget that they have an electronic world inside their bedrooms. Sure they’d love to sit in their room all week and play their video games and play on the computer. Grounding will not work unless parents take away all…

    • 1370 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    But in a study, mothers who combined reasoning with negative consequences had the most success in changing negative behavior. Den A. Trumbull, M.D.; president of the American College of Pediatricians believes spanking is a proven way to reinforce milder disciplinary tactics. The researchers came to a conclusion that spanking disobedient 2- to 6- year-olds worked just as well at reforming their behaviors as 13 alternative disciplinary approaches like giving a time-out, reasoning with a child, and taking away privileges. As long as the parents explains the reason for their action it should not be considered corporal punishment. "Some kids are difficult to parent. At times, they simply won't stay in a time-out and they can't be reasoned with," says Robert Larzelere, Ph.D., author of the Clinical Child review…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    One program many schools are taking into consideration is the Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) model. PBIS encourages a positive environment in school and promotes peaceful mediation and opportunities to learn from one’s mistakes rather than being treated like a criminal for small ordeals (Ward 2). In fact, schools tested with this model experience a much lower rate of disciplinary actions than other schools (Kang-Brown et al. 7). Another beneficial alternative to zero-tolerance is Response to Intervention, which is a model that assists troubled kids who are not necessarily special-needs, but do need additional support in a classroom environment, accomplish similar goals as PBIS (Kang-Brown et al. 7). Whatever the case, there are several much more effective and beneficial programs for schools across the country to put in place of the unnecessary and unstable school discipline policy that is…

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Punishment is a response-dependent environmental change that reduces the future probability of a response (Azrin & Holz, 1966). Punishment contingencies are frequent in the natural environment (Skinner, 1953); however, our understanding of punishment contains substantial gaps, and basic research on punishment has declined rapidly over the past 40 years (Baron, 1991; Lerman & Vorndran, 2002). Furthering the understanding punishment as a process would have not only basic and theoretical implications, but applied implications as well, as common treatments (e.g., response blocking, guided compliance) may reduce problematic behavior through the mechanism of punishment (Lerman & Vorndran, 2002).…

    • 1747 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There are many alternatives to corporal punishment in schools, such as in school suspension, detention, and other such punishments. Also teachers are urged to use behavior contracts, use positive reinforcement or appropriate behavior, and encourage disciplinary consequences, which are meaningful to students. But the school should be able to provide the students with social skills training and individualized and group counseling.…

    • 1972 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays