Preview

Punishmentments Needs To Be Punishment, By Robert Blecker

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1213 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Punishmentments Needs To Be Punishment, By Robert Blecker
The article Punishments Needs to Be Punishment by Robert Blecker says that the legal system in prosecuting criminals is not reflecting real justice if capital punishment is to be banned. Criminals are not morally prosecuted (Helling, 2014).
In this passage, for the author's argument, the author's overall stand is that he claims that capital punishment known as death punishment under the Eight Amendment should not be banned. This is due to two reasons listed below.
Firstly, the reason is because banning of capital punishment does not reflect the will of the people but the leaders. Serially supported to the reason why is because poll conducted to find out their opinion and results showed that people choose death punishment as the punishment for
…show more content…
It can be seen in the passage that the decision made only reflects the leaders rather than the people. Leaders are the one who are making the decisions using the opinion polls by the state legislations. People have the nature of rights for themselves but the leaders are not applying the popular sentiments to the decisions they are going to make. However, in my own objecting to the reason, leaders are the professional bodies making decisions helping the state and they are also the leaders that are elected by the citizens. Citizens should have a trust in them on why they resort to that. My second objection to the reason is because people do not know how expensive it is to have death punishment. It gives many problems when the verdict given to criminals are clearly wrong, as it can be seen in Kris Maharaj case where his death sentences was overturned and he is still serving life imprisonment for a crime he did not commit in Florida. Those who have an ineffective counsel will be affected by the "Procedural bar" concept where have future problems appealing sentence and convictions at early stages. Cutting corners can affect the criminal justice system dangerously that can lead to wrongful verdict, and executions in capital cases. It is said that the system for appealing, with the death punishment opposition and groups of very well trained …show more content…
My objecting to this reason is wrongful convictions such as corruption of people involved in solving the criminals' cases eyewitness identifies wrong person, false confessions, ineffective counsel, informants and human error will occur very easily that spoil real justice by killing innocent people. 2013 Global Corruption Barometer found out that more than one quarter of people around the world accept bribery and majority of the people surveyed and said that their governments fighting corruption ways are ineffective (Bidwell, 2013). Eyewitness mistakenly identification is the most common cause happening in the United States today. Defendants of accused may give wrong confession that may cause by the stress from the police and many more. Accused may have financial problem paying legal fees and higher chances to lose to prosecutor or plaintiff. Informants are people that cannot see light, thus they will have difficulties coming to court to defend for the accused or may even make up the evidences. Prosecuting attorneys also known as justices will make human error due to misjudgments in verdict and may killed an innocent people (Blankinship). This will violates human dignity of killing innocent people with wrong verdict with death punishment existing. Thus removing the death punishment is a better approach to even prevent this from happening. Furthermore, in life, everyone

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The reason being is because it would be very difficult to ask every individual in our whole country whether or not they have decided not to carry out a murder since there may be a chance of paying with death. However, deterrence may be used to its full potential if every state had Capital Punishment laws; "Capital Punishment: Give it a Chance," makes a great point of this. If consistency were established through our whole country, many would fear the punishment and not commit murder, but the inconsistency as it is right now, many commit a murder since there may be a chance of not getting the sentence, due to its inconsistency of the states. Also, the likelihood of deterrence could be boosted if the lengthy process were shortened, so that possible murderers of the time may witness how executions are a…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Caplan's Argument

    • 101 Words
    • 1 Page

    Caplan, the author of this article is the truman capote visiting lecturer in Law at Yale Law School. He is also the author of many books including The Tenth Justice: The Solicitor General and the Rule of Law. Caplan, is definitely a credible author with these accomplishments in his field. In his article he goes into detail on the argument to end the death penalty. The argument that is, “ the death penalty now fails to satisfy any legitimate penological purpose.” These points will be used in my paper by using the argument and explaining how the argument has a purpose.…

    • 101 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Topic: Capital Punishment General Purpose: To argue Specific Purpose: To argue that the United States should outlaw capital punishment in all fifty states. Thesis Statement: Capital Punishment should be outlawed in all fifty states because: (1) capital punishment once executed cannot be undone, and (2) the cost process of capital punishment isn’t worth the expense. Introduction I. [Attention Getter] Imagine being sentenced to die. A.…

    • 1696 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is a waste of money, time and space. The death penalty simply confuses the community and blurs the line between right and wrong, since you are hypocritically punishing someone for killing another human, by in return killing them also. The death penalty isn’t decreasing the murders so why re-instate it? Imagine the affect on young children when they find out what happens to hazardous criminals, it would ruin the child’s innocence. They death penalty bring nothing but suffering to the family of the criminal, and a negative atmosphere throughout the community. If it were your child on death row wouldn’t you want them to have a second chance? Once again, I state with utmost important, the death penalty should remain as a figure of the past and we should remain civilised and keep our-self and community away from this inhumane act as long as…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The death penalty or in other words capital punishment is a form of execution used for a long time. It is a form of punishment that was and still is used by several countries for various types of crimes for hundreds of years. However the death penalty has become a very debatable and confronting issue for last decades due to the fact of people having different opinions on this issue. In some countries it is considered to be a part of the judicial system, while in other countries it is considered to be an act violating human rights. During the first decade of 21st century, about two thirds of world vide countries have abolished the capital punishment due to the fact it is a violation of moral codex and human rights. There are always pros and cons to every action humans are able to do, so it is with the issue of death penalty. Countries such as China, USA, Japan or India have still retained to the execution of criminals by death penalty. However there are many intergovernmental and human rights organization such as the European Union that understands the death penalty to be one of the most pressing human rights issues of all time. (Babcock S., 2007) People are questioning the courts if death penalty really deters the crime, or if it is just a need to satisfy society’s desire for revenge. We can find many arguments against it; however the answer to question of abolishing the death penalty by the entire world is unclear and in far future. China is the country known for using many forms of inhuman punishment methods. There can be find an evidence showing the China to be the country with the highest execution case rate. I could not believe these statements, so I decide to search this issue and…

    • 1834 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every other day various methods of legally killing people by hanging or electrocuting, beheading or stoning is used hay Government to remove them or put them to death for different reasons It should be abolished as this capital punishment is brutal, cruel against humanity the one which degrades a person is not civilized, barbaric and is also a corrupt practice, at times even political interference. It is totally against the rights that are fundamentally given by the Constitution that is right to life which is universally accepted. Every human being has inherent right to protection of human life. There should be unconditional abolition of capital punishment. The death penalty has always the possibility of mistake or error; there are many instances of conviction where innocent people are put to death. Capital Punishment gives inspiration to the wrongdoers to become brutal leading to increase in such acts of violence instead of discouraging. Capital Punishment is full of corruption and…

    • 1506 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Whenever the word "death penalty" comes up, extremists from both sides of the spectrum begin to wildly express their opinions. One side says deterrence, the other side says there's a potential of executing an innocent man. One says justice, retribution, and punishment, the other side says execution is murder. However, all arguments aside, the best way and the only way to truly make a rational decision about capital punishment is to examine the purpose of our criminal justice system. Once the purpose of the criminal justice system is established, one must find out the purpose of capital punishment. This paper will show that the purpose of capital punishment is consistent with and embodies the purpose of the criminal justice system. Then, this paper will determine whether or not the present form of the death penalty is fulfilling its purpose, and what could be changed to make the death penalty more efficient and effective.…

    • 4332 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Death Penalty

    • 1667 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The death penalty is an interwoven controversy. The law is supposed to bring together the basic principles and purposes of society, including the recognition and protection of individual rights to life, liberty, and the security of people and property. The two separate groups of norms that are woven into the death penalty are desirable social principles and respectable moral principles. The death penalty has shown itself to be an ineffective punishment, due to the fact that, it is an immoral and anti-social practice in today’s society. It does not and will not uphold any of the basic principles that are the basis of the law in this country. This country desires revenge, and that is why we have the death penalty. Do not let people fool you with words such as justice and deterrence, because the death penalty serves neither of these purposes. The fact is, the death penalty is not a deterrent of crime, as the death penalty has been proven not to deter crime. The death penalty cannot be called moral, because taking another human life in such a fashion is not moral. Also, there is always the risk that an innocent man’s life may be taken.…

    • 1667 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are a number of assertions made against of the death penalty. Firstly, it is contrary to the moral principles to perform execution even if it follows the low. Furthermore, lethal injection, which is one of the method using for capital punishment, involves medical personnel in killing and puts them on one level with murders. Secondly, until now, researches do not found correlation between reduction of the number of crimes and the death penalty.…

    • 293 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In recent years more governments and states are abolishing the law of capital punishment. They believe that it is very inhuman to kill him/her just because he/she had committed a crime. Their view is of implementing tougher laws and their proper enforcement. Prior to giving capital punishment one has to think the reasons which has led the person to commit such a crime and for which he/she has been given capital punishment. For example, if a person kills another person just for food because he and his family were hungry from past several days. Here the state should be liable, which ultimately had to take care of that person and his family's basis necessity which of course was food. There should be strict transparent process of justification prior to awarding capital punishment, because it a matter of human life.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First and foremost, we can view the death penalty from the aspect of economic. Everyone is asking a question whether the death penalty should be abolished. If the death penalty abolished, it will replaced by life imprisonment and this will increase the burden of economic of a country. The government of that country needs to spend more budgets in this aspect. This will lead to the increasing of taxpayers and it is not fair for the citizens or taxpayers due to this replacement. However, we need to ask a question again whether the save of money is important than the life. As we know, we cannot compare everything with money in this world such as health, love, spirit and others. For example, we can buy the medicine but we cannot buy the…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    capital punishment

    • 978 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I do not support capital punishment because it is against humanity, human rights and forgiveness. It is the cause of family hardships and suffering. This paper explores why people should stop using capital punishment.…

    • 978 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    First and foremost the issue of the death penalty is a very immoral practise. It is a system which clearly believes two wrongs can make a right. In principle it is immoral, and it is unfair and discriminatory in practice. No one deserves to die and no one should give themselves or be given the power to choose whether another human being gets to live or die. When governments’ pass out vengeance disguised as justice, they stoop down to the killer’s level and devalue human life and human dignity just as the killers and other criminals do. Our society is civilized such that we reject the…

    • 1588 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The primary reason put forward to legalise the death penalty is that it is a strong deterrent. A person who has committed a crime like killing or raping another person should be given death penalty, which is as severe punishment as the act. It is said that when a criminal is given a death penalty, it dissuades others in the society from committing such serious crimes. They would refrain from such crimes due to fear of losing their lives. If a criminal is jailed, he may again commit the same crime after being released from prison. Giving him death penalty would make sure that the society is safe from being attacked by criminals. It seems to be an appropriate punishment for serial killers and for those who continue to commit crimes even after serving imprisonment.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    dealth penalty

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In conclusion, the capital punishment is a power that no man or woman deserves to have over another human being. There are too many flaws in the death penalty; therefore, the only reasonable solution is to abolish it. Punishment is supposed to be a…

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays