Preview

Rome: The Weaknesses Of Carthage And Rome

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
734 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Rome: The Weaknesses Of Carthage And Rome
Carthage and Rome were both very powerful nations for the time. Carthage started as a seaport town at the northern point of Africa, just below Sicily and south of Rome. Eventually their nation grew and expanded from Africa into the western side of Sicily in hopes of conquest, but the King of Syracuse there resisted them until Rome sided with some traitorous mercenaries that broke ranks from his military and decided to rebel[ CITATION Mor01 \l 1033 ]. Those mercenaries took over a city to the east and held it hostage in protest to the king. When the king began attacking them, they asked for the help of Rome. Rome reluctantly chose to help these mercenaries and this made the King mad. This king of Syracuse, Sicily resorted to siding with …show more content…
Both had an abundance of resources; Rome had a massive military, with better training and they had greater territory under their dominion, along with more allies. Carnage had vast wealth and was better at sea with its navy, at least before Rome started improving their own. Although both of their political systems were very similar, Rome’s was much more organized and advanced than Carthage, but Carthage had better leaders that were geniuses in strategy warfare, so they knew how to take a lesser grade of military to knock down better-trained troops. As far as people go, Rome’s citizens were more loyal and proud, and Carthage’s people were more success-driven as wealth and trade were everything to them; their leaders were always made up of wealthy aristocrats. Rome understood how to control their people and knew that in order to become powerful they would need to not just take over more territory, but to incorporate and reward their citizens, giving them a sense of ownership by being part of the Roman Empire[ CITATION Mor01 \l 1033 ]. This made it very tough for Carthage to take a strong foothold in Italy, when they finally attacked Rome later, only to find that much of Latium and other territories were completely loyal to the Roman Empire. Without that loyalty, Hannibal, one of the greatest Carthage generals to have lived, might have conquered Rome, but many of the territories resisted and would not turn[ CITATION Mor01 \l 1033 ]. In conclusion, Carnage, in the second Punic War, came very close to taking Italy, which leads many historians to believe them to have been as powerful as Rome, as it came very close to becoming a repeat of the catastrophe seen when the Gauls tore apart the Roman cities in a much earlier

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    What happens during the Krebs Cycle? (Key Concept): During Krebs Cycle, pyruvic acid is broken down into carbon dioxide in a series of energy-extracting reactions.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 500 years of no nation has everything stayed the same and Rome is no exception. While the economics of Rome managed to stay the same between 100 and 600 CE, and the laws of Rome with it, government and religion in 600 CE would not be recognizable to leaders and civilians from 100 CE.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hannibal resumed his siege of Saguntum and conquered it after a terrible and costly siege. Hannibal, although he held preeminence in Carthage, still had to rely on his allies to keep him in power. A delegate was sent to Rome to answer a question regarding whether Hannibal had acted on his own or had the approval of the Carthaginian senate. The delegate, according to Livy, was the best orator in Carthage. He quickly quashed the argument regarding the border of Hasdrubal because the Carthaginian council had not been part of the talks. Furthermore, he argued that the Romans had broken the treaty after the First War by invading Sardinia; finally, he stated that Hannibal broke no treaty because the Saguntines did not have an alliance with Rome when the treaty between Hasdrubal formed. However, the Romans did not care about that, they wanted peace or war. The Carthaginians declared the Romans needed to choose, and the Romans chose the later. At this critical juncture, Carthage still held with Hannibal and wanted to help him.…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    At that moment, an agreement with Carthage officially confirmed the rule of Rome among the other Latin nations (The Roman conquest, n.d.). In order to regard Rome as an equal, these city states generated an alliance known as the Latin League, which was supposed to ensure appropriate equal authority and unity of goals (The Roman conquest, n.d.). I pondered whether Rome feared the Latin League would grow stronger and desired to control it if, like Athens and Sparta, Rome and the League were equally powerful. Indeed, the members of the League challenged one another for hegemony after Etruscan authority over Rome and the other Latium states collapsed (The Roman conquest, n.d.). In this sense, Rome's goals against the Italian city-states and Carthage would have been quite similar to Sparta's goals during the Peloponnesian…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The stability of the law, the military, and financial standing of Rom kept it powerful. Rome successfully battled the Carthaginians, the Celtics(British), the Etruscans, and the…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Romans were great diplomats. They were firm when necessary and smart about granting citizenship. They also let citizens participate in domestic affairs. Their military was made up of strong, persistent soldiers. If a substantial amount of men were lost in battle they wouldn’t just surrender, but instead recruit new soldiers. They would build up new armies so that they could keep fighting. The Romans were also good strategists. By the year 264 BCE Rome had established colonies in strategic spots throughout Italy. By connecting these settlements with roads, they built a military and communication network that helped them rule more effectively. By getting military help from allies, they mobilized Italy’s military…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Lewis and Clark

    • 2091 Words
    • 9 Pages

    * Content Standards 1.2- Students access, synthesize, and evaluate information communicate and apply social studies knowledge to real world situations.…

    • 2091 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Roman Republic was the major stronghold for centuries. Encompassing the Mediterranean and much of Europe, and even having influence throughout Egypt and beyond, it was well understood that Rome was not to be messed with. No civilization could ever topple such a well-organized and technologically advanced society such as Rome. No civilization, that is, other than its own self. Pride, revenge, and greed influenced key decisions that pried at the few loose ends that Rome had. Generals, soldiers, and the Senate alike destroyed the foundations on which the Roman Republic was built on, and the nation collapsed from the inside out. In a perfect world, Rome had an…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Julius Caesar had impacted the country of Gaul by driving the German invaders out, making the bond stronger between Julius and Gaul. In turn, Julius Caesar had people in other counties that he knew would back him up if he got into any trouble in battle. In addition, Julius Caesar took advantage of his connections with other parts of the world to expand his empire and gain nobility on a global scale. Sadly, after Crassus’s death, Caesar to make the choice go into war with Pompey, which Caesar gained land from and used it as an advantage when they attacked other parts of the world. The death of one of Julius’ allies caused Caesar and his other ally, Pompey, to go into war. Later, Caesar won the battle, thus using Pompey’s land to add to his empire. “Caesar quickly took advantage of these connections and the shifting power position in Gaul to extend the sphere of Roman control”(Gaius Julius Caesar). To wrap it up, Julius Caesar had many connections with other people in the world, which he took advantage of to compete well in wars.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ancient Rome DBQ

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Because of the size, Rome had a lot of space to protect, but little protection. In Doc 5, “young men in military declined, the army faced a serious threat...the Roman government recruited foreigners...this ‘new breed’ of Roman soldiers had very little loyalty to the empire.” (Doc 5). After conquering civilization after civilization, Rome seemed powerful because of its large size, but also made them a serious target. Without any military support, Rome had no other choice, but to recruit from civilizations they had taken over. Because Rome had taken over their home, the new soldiers were not exactly sympathetic to Rome. Following this, in Doc 6 a chart shows all the invasions of the Roman Empire from 100-500 CE. Arrows and line and written on the chart to show the paths and entrances they came through. By showing all the invaders shows how Rome’s fall was enviable. Also to mention, there was six invaders that had tried to make their was into the civilization. If there had been one, Rome could have easily taken care of the enemy, but there was more than one to worry about. In addition, because this happened within the span of 500 years, these attacks must have weakened borders more before they were completely destroyed. As the big and strong Rome, became less big and strong, outsiders used this to their advantage to finally over rule…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Romans underestimated the “danger, and the number of their enemies” they were in battles with, especially the Germanic tribes or the barbarians. The Barbarians were a warrior people and “pressed on the Roman empire with accumulated weight”; however, it was not because they were at war but for sport. Since fighting in the barbarian culture was something they did for fun, they would get in a lot of battles with the Romans to keep them entertained. This contributed to the fall of Rome because all the extensive military pressure from the barbarian would…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Each of them has kind of the same purposes of concluding the trends in different crimes and suggesting the attention of issues. Even though, those types of crime measurement all have the similar focus, the result varies a great bit between them. While reading this, keep in mind each type of measurements are ran by different groups that hold their own ways of gathering information. It is often known that in the United States, the Uniform Crime Report (UCR) is the most relied upon. Many believe the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) gathers all their information from local law enforcement agencies around the world. Results come from recorded police reports which collect data on about 95% of the population (appendix table 2 in Criminal Victimization, 2012, NCJ 243389, October 2013). The UCR breaks down crimes into Part One and Part Two offenses. Part One offenses include eight crimes being either violent or property offenses (which are the more serious crimes). Meanwhile, Part Two offenses include all other minor crimes except for traffic…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Fall of Rome

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In Ancient Rome, the wealthy had lead pipes that carried water to their houses. Due to lead poisoning in water, the rate of death in wealthy homes was very high. The interaction of people at the Coliseum and the blood and death most likely spread disease. Those who lived on the streets went through an uninterrupted season of illness and disease. Alcohol use increased, furthering the intolerance of citizens. Poor families lived in crowded one room apartments. Because of overcrowding, poor sanitation, and poor nutrition, diseases were rampant among Rome’s poor, whose lives were very short. Crowded neighborhoods plagued with flies and dogs which carried and spread diseases. In Rome, bathing was highly respected, as for two Gods they worshipped. Despite health issues, the sick, and the healthy bathed together. The baths were cleaned out about every two weeks, so those viruses were spread throughout the baths, multiplying every moment of the day. Many of the diseases spread in Rome were deadly, such as malaria, tuberculosis, typhoid fever, and gastroentitis. The most deadly diseases in Rome were affected by temperature, which causes seasonal plagues.…

    • 284 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This war began as the Romans moved over to Sicily to acquire territory. Between 264 BC and 241 BC is when the first war happened. The first few battles were ashore. With the Battle of Agrigentum, the Carthage armed forces had to learn and adapt. Ultimately, they chose to utilize their naval forces. However, the Romans had manufactured many ships with advancements that aided them in combat and, in consequence, defeated the Carthaginian naval forces. The result of the First Punic War was a resonating victory by the Romans. The Second Punic War was a great deal shorter than the First one, it is most notable for Hannibal, the Carthage pioneer. Hannibal took a multitude of men through the mountains and startled the Romans in Northern Italy. As…

    • 281 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Roman Empire was one the largest and wealthiest empires of all time; and it was definitely the largest of its time (Wells 21). At its largest it contained about 20 percent of the worlds known population (Wells32). Historians have studied Rome for decades to learn as much as possible about their art, politics, military, and their economy. They study Rome to see how one small city turned into one of the most prominent empires in history. Rome rose from nothing into a strong republic and eventually grew into an even stronger empire, however there are many historians who believe that everything that made Rome strong and fascinating, such as its size and wealth and its leaders, is exactly what eventually lead to the down fall of this great empire. In this…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays