Initially I thought that my student would be very strong in one or two areas but I actually found that she is mostly at the meaning maker stage on the writer continuum and that Word Choice was the only area that fell slightly below this. For me, reading the continuum pulls the traits into one umbrella of writing. The three-level writing guide did the same thing for me. L. is a 3/4 writer and reading through the ½ traits really helped me to see exactly how much writing progress and development she has made at this point in her writing experience.
I was surprised, in the Garfield survey, to see how much L. would not like to write for science or social studies. She also wouldn’t want to have a job for a newspaper or feel like she had to write to change someone’s opinion. From what I can assume, anything that seemed challenging was something that decidedly lowered her enthusiasm for writing. This makes me wonder if other kids would respond similarly or if she is unique in being discouraged by these