Preview

Why Did the Liberals Lose the 1874 Elections?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1274 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Did the Liberals Lose the 1874 Elections?
Why did the Liberals lose the 1874 elections?

There are of course several main reasons why the liberals lost the elections. Opinions of historians vary on this topic. Some historians see the defeat as the result of unpopular domestic and foreign policies, like Alabama Arbitration, however they cannot agree on which policies contributed the most. Others see this defeat as the consequence of poor election campaign by Gladstone; his promise to cut income tax simply did not appeal to people. On the other hand the importance of Conservative party in this defeat should not be overshadowed. After 1868 elections the Conservative reorganised the party and managed to create more positive and popular image.

When Gladstone became the Prime Minister he emphasised that his mission was to pacify Ireland, however the reforms he carried out in Ireland not only had limited effect but also alienated landlords and Anglicans. The disestablishment of the Church of Ireland in 1869, although appeared to deal with obvious Irish grievance, had little effect on ordinary people and was viewed by Whigs with deep suspicion.

The Irish Land Act 1869 gave certain rights to tenants; however tenant continued to be evicted because there was nothing to prevent a landlord from raising rents so high that the tenant was unable to pay. This attack on landlords rights when against 19th centaury beliefs about the ‘rights of property owners '. This alienated upper classes. Even in Gladstone 's own cabinet Whigs like Clarendon and Argyll saw it as an outright attack on property which could spread to England. B Harrison claims that "fears for the security of property were more important than the licensing question in weakening the Liberal party".

The Irish University Bill 1873, which attempted to integrate university education in Ireland, was a complete disaster. The bill alienated Anglicans who wanted to keep control over education, whilst it was defeated by 3 votes, Gladstone resigned over it.



Bibliography:  "Gladstone and Liberalism" by Paul Adelman form "Britain 1867-1918", published by Institute of Contemporary British History, 1995  "Gladstone, Disraeli and later Victorian Politics" by Paul Adelman, 1990  "Gladstone and Disraeli" by A.H. Abbott, 1984

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    At the time Labour was a significantly divided party with the Gaitskillites and the Bevanites meaning some support of voters was lost through lack of assurance that the party would lead with strength and could make decisions that were right for the nation and not selfish. The Labour economy policies are also a reason why they lost. Gaitskell promised to increase public spending without increasing taxes. This put his credibility under question. Another reason is that although voters were happy with the nationalisation of electricity, gas, atomic energy and airline industries they thought public ownership of coal and the railways had been a failure when they were last in government and there was little enthusiasm for further nationalisation which Labour was committed to by Clause Four of the Labour Party Constitution.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Balfour's leadership along with other key factors, including chamberlain's influence, the Boer war and the liberal party's actions, overall led to the decline in popularity for the conservative party giving the liberals their first taste of power in the 1906 general election.…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The liberal’s victory in the 1906 was a very significant one due to how they won it with such an overwhelming majority; it was the biggest electoral victory since 1832. In the 1890’s the liberals were suffering from a crisis identity and they were lacking in money and morale. In the 1906 election the liberals won 49.4% of the vote and that amounted to 399 seats which was such a large margin compared to in 1900 where 45% of the vote was only 183 seats. There are four main reasons arguably why the Liberals won the1906 election and these are through Conservative faults such as the massacre in the Boer war. The education act in 1902 and Chamberlain’s tariff reform campaign also lost the conservatives a lot of support, which meant people turned to liberals just due to disliking the conservatives. The most important reason was Arthur Balfour getting involved and not making the right decisions for the conservatives and losing a lot of the voters they had before. The liberals also used a very negative campaign in order to get voters to realise the flaws in the conservative’s ideals and make them vote for the liberals just through dislike of the other parties.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is argued by some that Peel was greatly successful up to 1841 due to the fact that he brought the Tory Party from being a “beleaguered minority” (Adelman, 1989) to being a strong, relevant power once again. However, this ‘low point’ of 1832 is often greatly exaggerated by admirers of Peel. Arguably the high levels of support that the Whig’s received in the election of 1832 was predominantly down to the fact that they advocated the issue of Parliamentary Reform, meaning that it can be argued that the period of unpopularity that the Tory party suffered in 1832 could only ever have been temporary. Arguably even if Peel had not advocated the policies which many consider to be very ‘successful’, the fortunes of the Tory Party would have still recovered, as many of the newly enfranchised voters, far from punishing the Tories, enjoyed the exclusivity of Parliament and wanted to retain that exclusivity through conservative policies. Although the skills of Peel as an orator did contribute to the Tory revival to a certain extent, the Whig majority in Parliament was so fundamentally fragile that it hardly needed exploitation by Peel. Although Peel did contribute to disuniting the Whig majority by, for example, exploiting the Whig difficulties in the management of Anglican Church funds in Ireland, the opportunity to do so arose spontaneously, and merely needed to be…

    • 1317 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    - Gladstone converted to the policy of Home Rule in 1885, shortly after the November 1885 election. He remained committed to this policy for the rest of his political life, despite the fact it had a divisive effect on his Liberal Party, and the fact that introducing Home Rule to Ireland would be very difficult. Historians and contemporaries, have cited many different reasons as to why Gladstone converted to Home Rule, the three main reasons being that by 1885 there was no real alternative; several ways of settling the Irish question had already bee tried but had not solved the problem, secondly, it was the morally right thing to do, and lastly for Gladstone’s political ambition. Sources 1, 2 and 3 contain material, which both agrees and disagrees with the historical claim in the question; that Gladstone converted mainly for political ambition. For example sources 1 and 3 both suggest that they agree that Gladstone joined the Home Rule purely for his political ambition, whereas Source 2 completely disagrees with this statement. This essay will first consider the case that Gladstone’s conversion was driven primarily by his political ambition, before considering the case that other motivations for Gladstone’s conversion were more important. The conclusion will reach the judgement that Gladstone’s conversion to the policy of Home Rule for Ireland was not driven primarily by political ambition.…

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    This question focuses on the importance of the Second Reform Act in Disraeli’s rise to the top of the Conservative Party and his emergence as the leader. In order to decide on the relative importance of the Send Reform Act, I will also consider other factors, which impacted on Disraeli’s emergence, including the 1846 split of the Conservative party and the death of George Bentinck, Derby’s ineffective leadership, Palmerston’s death in 1865 and Disraeli’s determination and political skill.…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the1870s, the Conservative Party won three out of four elections and formed the government for 17 years out of a total of 20 years. It reflected the Conservative Party was the most powerful party in England at that time; they even had an overpowering majority of seats in the House of Lords. They had support from everywhere. However, the situation changed dramatically when the Liberal party won the general election in 1906 with an overwhelming majority of 400 seats as against 157 seats for the Conservatives party. This event was marked as the well-known ‘Liberal landslide’. There are several reasons why the Conservative lost such a large amount of seats; national efficiency, the imposition of Education Act and Licensing Act, tariff campaign and Neglect of social reform.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the Whigs electoral victory of 1832, how was it that the Tories were able to win the election in 1841, there were many factors that contributed to the enormous decline in Whig support during the reform years. The Whigs were running out of ideas by 1835. There was increasing economic depression, defections to the other side of the House occurred, the Whig ministries witnessed the rise of public pressure groups, the Whigs were viewed as being cynical and devious after the Litchfield House Compact. In comparison, the Conservative Party’s strength showed a huge increase after the passing of the Reform Act due to party organization under the Carlton Club and Registration Societies, the strength of Peel as a politician and the Conservatives' willingness not to use their power and influence in the House of Lords unconstitutionally.…

    • 1022 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both men, who served as Prime Ministers, reformed many institutions with many of them effecting the working class like education (bringing up the working class), trade union (helping the working class fight for work wrights), public health (living conditions affecting the working class) and licensing (the way many working class people passed the time), along with the electoral institution (workers being able to vote on the matters which the work upon, such as factory conditions and education). Many historians, such as William Kuhn, argue that William Gladstone, the Liberal Prime Minister, passed many other reforms as well to help the working class, including the Ballot Act of 1872. However, some historians, such as Monypenny and Buckle, say that Benjamin Disraeli, the Conservative Prime Minister, did more to help the working class, including passing the Second Great Reform Act of 1867.…

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the 1700s and 1800s the Irish decided to migrate to America for a variety of reason. Some of those being poverty, denied property, denied education, couldn’t be involved in politics, and weren’t able to practice their religion freely. They were constantly being harassed and stereotyped by the English. Therefore, the Irish decided to travel to America for a chance at a better life.…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Federalists did not build a sustaining party apparatus, and the party 's defeat in the election of 1800 led to its decline. It essentially ceased to be a national party after 1816.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There was Industrial unrest, which would effect many things. The government would need to deal this as a collapse of industry would have a huge impact on the country. Another problem the Liberal’s faced was a rebellious House of Lords as a result of a Conservative majority. The House of Lords could reject bills, until 1911, which would cause problems for the Liberals and the changes they wanted to make. Both of these events could be seen as a possible excuse, as to why the Liberal Government hadn’t…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Another factor was the oppression that the Irish people started experiences…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The 1964 election changed the British political landscape forever as a thirteen-year Conservative dominance crumbled at the hands of Harold Wilson and his youthful Labour Party. Historians, such as Rowe, postulate that there are a plethora of reasons to why Labour won the 1964 election, most prominently because of the Conservatives’ inability to economically modernise Britain. Contrastingly, other historians such as Lynch uphold the opinion that there are other factors responsible for Labour’s victory, including Labour’s prominence in areas of politics where the Conservatives lacked…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Daniel O’Connell’s success within the Catholic Association came from his individual skills and talents which he used at an early stage in the association. These came to prove key and essential to the cause as he used his ‘magnificent voice and clear conversation style of oratory that enabled him to build up a marvelous rapport with the catholic masses’2 to his advantage. Although it wasn’t just his oratory since it was also his 'superb instinct for distilling the essentials of a political situation, together with his knowledge of the legal constraints and the potential for constitutional agitation, that created the new movement' 3and pushed it to the front of Irish needs. Additionally, between the years 1823 and 1824, the Association had initially struggled to gain the momentum it needed for the campaign as it had been 'a tiny body which barely survived' and arguably one of the greatest successes of Daniel O’Connell was his innovative idea of the introduction of Catholic Rent in 1824, where a subscription fee was to be paid each month by the Irish peasantry to the Catholic Association.…

    • 1826 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays