Preview

Jared Diamond Worst Mistake In The History Of The Human Race

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1556 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Jared Diamond Worst Mistake In The History Of The Human Race
Jared Diamond is… interesting.
The argument that Jared Diamond makes in his article, “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race”, is completely refutable. There is very little evidence in the article that makes sense, and most of it appears to be that Diamond just has a grudge against the laziness of the modern world. This is where Diamond and I agree. The modern world is incredibly lazy. We now live in a world where fast food is a food group, and technology is being used incorrectly, resulting in the overall decrease of brain capacity. But, technology has also created amazing advances in medicine, education, and increased the ability to learn. There is no reason to say that agriculture is the worst mistake and even if somebody wants
…show more content…
And while I agree that it is easier to be unhealthy in today’s world, it is also incredibly easier to be healthy. There are thousands of options for food in the world, and it is a person’s choice to be either healthy or unhealthy. It is a person’s choice to go to McDonald’s or to go to the grocery store or local market and buy their own food. In the article we read from Chris Otter , “Feast and Famine: The Global Food Crisis”, he mentions several times the affects that food has on America in particular. The malnutrition in our country comes from over eating. While both articles state that the world has a problem that involves rich countries overeating, and poor countries starving, that is still a choice of those countries, even the poor ones. They choose to export all of their goods and harvests to other countries in exchange for food. And while that statement can be argued and supported in a million different ways, that is not the point of this paper. The truth is that Diamond seems to be just throwing out one side of a given argument without even the slightest acknowledgement of the other. Malnutrition was around with the start of humans. There are bad foods in the world as they are. Fruits have tons of sugar in them, and a diet of just fruit and meat in ancient times could not have been great for them. Not to mention, most communities only really had one source of food, so they ended up eating a lot of the same thing. If you ask any doctor, nutritionist, or medical official, they will tell you that no matter what foods are being consumed; there is no health in eating the same thing over and over again. So if the ancient communities stayed relatively in the same areas for the majority of their lives, they would not have had as great of a diet as Diamond makes it out to be. Diamond even says that the modern “bushman” does not live the same way primitive beings did. To quote

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Not only this, but “the farmers profit margin dropped from 35% in the 1950 's to about 9% today.” (Mckibben, 54) This means that “to generate the same income as it did in 1950, a farm today would need to be roughly four times as large.” (Mckibben, 55) As a result of this perpetual growth and centralization, problems like “huge sewage lagoons, miserable animals, vulnerability to sabotage and food-born illness”(mckibben, 61) have become commonplace. Not only this, but “we are running out of the two basic ingredients we need to grow food on an industrial scale: oil and water.” (Mckibben, 62) The situation has become so dire that “we are now facing a near simultaneous depletion of the underground aquifers which have been responsible for the unsustainable, artificial inflation of food production.” At this point of realization, Mckibben begins indulging the reader in a large number of facts that promote a more localized form of farming as the solution to a seemingly endless number of issues. Initially the point is raised that “sustainable agriculture leads to a 93% increase in per-hectare food production.” (Mckibben, 68) The next idea raised is that, “since World War 1, it has been cheaper to use…

    • 3032 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jared Diamond is a scientist and is the author of “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race.” The article isn’t the clearest on what could be better. Would the human race have been better off living with the need to hunt and gather for their life, or would agriculture be the key to the survival for the human race? Jared believes moving back to a hunting/gathering lifestyle would be beneficiary to us. I believe Jared Diamond makes some great points, but that agriculture was a necessity for what we’ve accomplished.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jared Diamond makes a compelling case for why “the adoption of agriculture was in many ways a catastrophe” in his 1987 Discover Magazine article “The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race,” however I am not convinced. An Agricultural Revolution is a “significant change in agriculture that occurs when there are discoveries, inventions, or new technologies that change production” (The Editors of Encyclopedia Britannica, 2015) and the development of agriculture has been a fundamental part of the march of civilization. The Agricultural Revolution was not a catastrophe from which we have never recovered, it was the groundwork for the rise of civilization. Cynthia Stokes Brown, author of Big History- From The Big Bang To The Present states…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He talks about how our culture of food has totally changed over the years. We went from having family home cooked meals to eating fast food every night. Now America’s eating traditions have changed to having a fast food dinner at McDonalds. He makes a good point in the chapter stating “we find ourselves as a species almost back where we started: anxious omnivores struggling once again to figure out what it is wise to eat”. I personally feel that this is true. America’s eating habits have completely changed over the years, and the amount of obesity increases every year. I think this is a very important part in the book and that America needs to slow down our eating habits and take time to enjoy a healthy…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Chapter 1 of “In Defense of Food” the author, Michael Pollan, refers to what we humans should eat in order to be maximally healthy. First, Liebig the father of modern nutritional sciencea German chemist that proposes a theory of metabolism, explained life strictly in terms of chemical nutrients such as vitalism. Consequently, Pollan concocted the first baby formula based in vitamins, essential fats and amino acids; as a result, in January 1977, the committee and the Senator George McGovern, established a set of dietary guidelines pretending to reduce all kind of diseases like, cancer, heart disease, obesity and diabetes, just cutting down the consumption of red meat and dairy products, but at the same time they was sending warnings to…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The author of this essay proved many useful points in regards to the Western Diet. In order for people to change their nutrition many things have to change as well, but is it too late? Almost every food we buy and put in our mouths is full extra additives and hormones. How whole is our food really? Comparing Americans diet to other countries proves that a healthy lifestyle with better nutrition is possible. Are the people that benefit from the consequences like doctors who treat patients with heart disease, high blood pressure or diabetes or pharmaceutical companies willing to give up everything that bring in revenue? I think we know what the…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    I reexamined the foods i've been consuming and became astounded. Looking at something as classic as bread, a food that used to contain only a few ingredients, now contains dozens. The effects of the industrialization are all around us, especially in our food. I was unaware that products that make health claims aren't exactly healthy and was surprised to find all of the tricks and loopholes the FDA allows. The rules regarding wording are ambiguous, thus making the health claims on foods almost frivolous. This book examined the diet fads of the past in America such as when margarine was considered to be healthier than butter. I’ve learned that we come up with a new diet plan and find “stunning” data that will better our health all the time, but our health has yet to make a drastic improvement. While we continue to consume the Western Diet, we look for ways to outsmart it rather than do the obvious thing and move away from it. Ultimately, I came away from the book with far more knowledge then when I entered. The book offered great incite into the food industry and how it all works. I am glad I read this book and will definitely implement some lessons into my life.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How might we plot our escape from the nutritionist and, in turn, from the most harmful effects of the Western diet? To Denis Burkitt, the English doctor stationed in Africa during World War II who gave the Western diseases their name, the answer seemed straightforward, if daunting. “The only way we’re going to reduce disease,” he said, “is to go backwards on diet and lifestyle of our ancestors.”” (423) Which sums up fairly well that this point is that the problem is more about our current social structure when it comes to food. “For most people for most of history, gathering and preparing food has been an occupation at the very heart of daily life.”…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is clearly demonstrated in the scene where the China study took place by Dr. Campbell. It took part in 367 diet and health related variables making it one of the most ambitious nutritional studies ever undertaken. Sixty five counties across china were carefully surveyed their diet and lifestyle of 6500 people. Urine and blood samples were also taken. After nearly a decade of intense study, the study identified no less than 94,000 correlations between diet and diseases. One of Dr. Campbell’s colleague’s clearly states that, “the main message we got from thee correlations analysis is one of the message: the plant-based diet mainly cereal, vegetables and fruit was always associated with lower mortality rate and that whole-foods are beneficial to human health while animal foods were not.” The purpose of this study was to show the relationship between diet and risk or developing…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pollan states that the western diet is the root cause of health problems in countries that subscribe to it. He examines these countries, and the health consequences that they suffer due to their diet. He also provides examples of the alternative countries which focus on the traditional and cultural diet instead, resulting in comparatively better health. Pollan argues that the western civilization’s transition from whole foods to refined foods, from quality foods to quantity foods, from complex foods to simple foods and from culture food to science food is the main reason for the health problems that we have today.…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Globalization in the 70s played a huge role in making things tough on Americans. In an effort to create a cheaper more abundant food supply America looked to the Japanese who had figured out how to produce a new sweetener, high-fructose corn syrup, which was less expensive and had a longer shelf life that sugar. Food manufacturers also began to replace sugar with Palm oil which is a stable yet highly saturated, commercial fat, which in turn led to an increase in the production of inexpensive, and energy packed snack foods. This combined with the fact that portion sizes were getting larger seemed to be the perfect storm for consumers to be able to eat on the go or buy cheaper foods that were much more easy to store and handle that meals that families had to slave in the kitchen over a hot stove for. Cristler describes the fact that economically it only made sense for companies to keep producing these goods, I mean why not? The companies were turning over huge margins of profit and the consumers couldn’t leave these delicious items on the shelves. Why would Americans, who are driven by capitalism spend more time cooking at home, when they could easily stop by a fast food restaurant and pick up a cheap fast meal to eat? It was at this time when I came to realize that in today’s society a lot of the reasoning for this problem that we are facing in this country would be because of…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Jared Diamond's article "The Worst Mistake in Human History," he describes the adoption of agriculture as a catastrophy. At first mention, this sounds rediculous. How could one of our greatest advancements possibly be regaurded as the worst mistake in human history? It encouarged civilization and made food easier to come back. Surely this porgession was not catastrophic.…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pollan explains that scientific theories of nutritionism focus on individual nutrients rather than foods as a whole (Pollan, 434). He further goes on to refute this claim mentioning that these scientific theories contradict with one another. Pollan explains “the scientists who blame our health problems on deficiencies of [micronutrients] are not the same scientists who see a sugar soaked diet leading to metabolic syndrome and from there to diabetes, heart disease…”(Pollan, 435). On one hand there are scientists who blame health problems on a lack of nutrients, and on the other hand there are scientists who blame those health problems on a sugar soaked diet. By stating these theories, Pollan tries to get his point across that they all have the same thing in common; these theories are mere explanations to western diseases. In Pollan’s view, “scientists can argue all they want about the mechanisms behind this phenomenon, but whichever it is, the solution would appear to remain very much the same: Stop eating a Western diet” (Pollan, 435). In other words, no matter what reason scientists have for the causes of western…

    • 743 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    When it comes to keeping the human body, nutrition is the most essential part of everyone’s life. If people do not have full control, it will affect the way they will be in the future. Any change to someone's diet will change their body in the long run, whether it be positive or negative. It is quite apparent, especially in America, that the common person’s nutrition has gone down hill. Since the 1980s, the rate of obesity has inflated double the amount for adults and triple for children (“Obesity” p. 1). Shockingly, America spends more on fast food than on college education, computers, software and cars combined. In fact, in 2005, Americans spent one hundred thirty four billion dollars on fast food alone. In the ‘70s, America only spent six billion (Schlosser p. 10). I am not one to blame McDonalds for the drastic rise of poor nutrition. There are obviously other reasons why. I mainly blame the misinformation and myths that the general public has been told. The reason why that people are more unhealthy now than in the past is…

    • 1532 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hunger In Haiti

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages

    It is just totally wrong that a large group of people are unhealthy due to eating too much, when there are those without any food (Coates). We do not have too little food to feed everyone , we have a seriously messed up and unfair food system(Coates). Food prices are slowly rising which does not quite impact us, but when you are living off of $2.00 a day it is a catastrophe(Coates). Going to bed hungry could be a very avoidable thing if we could just make our food system fair (Coates).…

    • 470 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays