The problem with nutritionism is that we look at it from a micro perspective rather than looking at the food as a whole. For example, if we just look at Omega 3 and boost the amount of Omega 3 a food contains, we don’t consider how it will react with other nutrients and how a combination and balance of nutrients affect the overall impact the food has on our body. For this reason, Pollan highly advises taking nutrition admonitions with a grain of salt. He also advises that we steer away from process foods that make nutritional claims that talk about including extra nutrients. Pollan refers to such foods as “edible food-like substances.”
He talks about comparing different undeveloped groups’ eating habits to those of the westerner. The undeveloped groups who rely on hunting and foraging their food are plagued by fewer diseases than the westerner. The only reason the westerner outlives the members of these groups is because of the advancements in medicine we have made.
The book also talks about how nutritionism has caused an outbreak in “false marketing.” I put false marketing in quotations, because it isn’t exactly false, but it only tells a partial truth. For example, I’m sure most people have heard that dark chocolates contain antioxidants which are supposed to be healthy. Now let us look at the whole truth. First off, what is an antioxidant and what does it do? Most people would not be able to answer this question. Also, all food that grows out of the ground contains antioxidants, and since the cacao bean grows out of the ground, it contains antioxidants. So what we have learned so far is that there are actually healthier alternatives to obtaining these antioxidants. So why market chocolate? Because it is a food that was once thought to be very unhealthy, and by marketing it as nutritious, consumers will think that they can eat something that tastes really good and is “healthy.” But you don’t see companies marketing the sugars and the fats in these chocolates. This is because doing so would be considered marketing suicide.
Overall, I found this book to be very interesting. It was very informative and made me look at what I eat from a whole new perspective.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the introduction, Pollan brings up a very good point about Americans and their views on dieting and eating “healthier”. Pollan explains the way that Americans went through a so-called “carbophobia” period in 2002, and how, unfortunately, this seems to remain true even today. The foods that American’s tend stay away from because of scientists and nutritionists devaluing…
- 324 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Michael Pollan, the author of “Escape from the Western Diet” has a very strong believes about…
- 894 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
He talks about how our culture of food has totally changed over the years. We went from having family home cooked meals to eating fast food every night. Now America’s eating traditions have changed to having a fast food dinner at McDonalds. He makes a good point in the chapter stating “we find ourselves as a species almost back where we started: anxious omnivores struggling once again to figure out what it is wise to eat”. I personally feel that this is true. America’s eating habits have completely changed over the years, and the amount of obesity increases every year. I think this is a very important part in the book and that America needs to slow down our eating habits and take time to enjoy a healthy…
- 617 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In Chapter 1 of “In Defense of Food” the author, Michael Pollan, refers to what we humans should eat in order to be maximally healthy. First, Liebig the father of modern nutritional sciencea German chemist that proposes a theory of metabolism, explained life strictly in terms of chemical nutrients such as vitalism. Consequently, Pollan concocted the first baby formula based in vitamins, essential fats and amino acids; as a result, in January 1977, the committee and the Senator George McGovern, established a set of dietary guidelines pretending to reduce all kind of diseases like, cancer, heart disease, obesity and diabetes, just cutting down the consumption of red meat and dairy products, but at the same time they was sending warnings to…
- 204 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Rude states that since the 1920s, low calorie “health food” has been favorable and has dominated the American food market. However, these terms would soon become a mere marketing tactic to get a specific product to stand out from someone else’s, as terms like “free-range” and “organic” could be thrown around with no restrictions placed upon the companies using these marketing tools. This system of industrial farming also hurt the American people, as a more industrial farming system created, and continues to make fewer jobs for low-income Americans. Hence, the industry can produce massive amounts of food very quickly, but at a steep…
- 779 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The author of this essay proved many useful points in regards to the Western Diet. In order for people to change their nutrition many things have to change as well, but is it too late? Almost every food we buy and put in our mouths is full extra additives and hormones. How whole is our food really? Comparing Americans diet to other countries proves that a healthy lifestyle with better nutrition is possible. Are the people that benefit from the consequences like doctors who treat patients with heart disease, high blood pressure or diabetes or pharmaceutical companies willing to give up everything that bring in revenue? I think we know what the…
- 287 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
How might we plot our escape from the nutritionist and, in turn, from the most harmful effects of the Western diet? To Denis Burkitt, the English doctor stationed in Africa during World War II who gave the Western diseases their name, the answer seemed straightforward, if daunting. “The only way we’re going to reduce disease,” he said, “is to go backwards on diet and lifestyle of our ancestors.”” (423) Which sums up fairly well that this point is that the problem is more about our current social structure when it comes to food. “For most people for most of history, gathering and preparing food has been an occupation at the very heart of daily life.”…
- 413 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
“In Defense of Food” is a book written by Michael Pollan which was released in 2008. Pollan writes about the “Western Diet” and the dangers associated with it. He proposes a new answer to what we should and should not eat. He states that it comes down to seven simple words: Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants. Those are the words that he opens the book with, this is his basic recommendation. He states that the rest of the book is just a detailed elaboration of those words. The first half of the book is all about criticizing and deconstructing the “health disaster”, as Pollan calls it, of the “western diet”, as well as the philosophy of nurtitionism that surrounds it. The second half of the book focuses on solutions to this disaster and Pollan’s thoughts on the matter.…
- 702 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
To begin, Pollan believes that people should have knowledge of foods from the ancient past. This valuable wisdom has been collected over thousands of years and can be used to improve present day diets. He states, “Modern Americans have lost the solution to the omnivore’s dilemma and today the problem is bigger than it has ever been. But it’s not an unsolvable problem. We need to recover the skills and knowledge people used to have” (104). Michael Pollan explains how learning about the history of food will result in food choices (such as eating locally-grown foods) which are safe and healthy.…
- 547 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Author, Wendell Berry, in this article "The Pleasures of Eating," Discusses how us as humans don't pay attention to the things we eat. He writes this article to try to explain his answer to many people's question, "what can city people do?" This question refers to the decline of American and farming. After he's answered that question he's felt that there were many more things he could have said to the people ,He does that by writing This article, he adopts a strong tone in order to get others to understand his ideal feelings about the food we eat.…
- 565 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
And while I agree that it is easier to be unhealthy in today’s world, it is also incredibly easier to be healthy. There are thousands of options for food in the world, and it is a person’s choice to be either healthy or unhealthy. It is a person’s choice to go to McDonald’s or to go to the grocery store or local market and buy their own food. In the article we read from Chris Otter , “Feast and Famine: The Global Food Crisis”, he mentions several times the affects that food has on America in particular. The malnutrition in our country comes from over eating. While both articles state that the world has a problem that involves rich countries overeating, and poor countries starving, that is still a choice of those countries, even the poor ones. They choose to export all of their goods and harvests to other countries in exchange for food. And while that statement can be argued and supported in a million different ways, that is not the point of this paper. The truth is that Diamond seems to be just throwing out one side of a given argument without even the slightest acknowledgement of the other. Malnutrition was around with the start of humans. There are bad foods in the world as they are. Fruits have tons of sugar in them, and a diet of just fruit and meat in ancient times could not have been great for them. Not to mention, most communities only really had one source of food, so they ended up eating a lot of the same thing. If you ask any doctor, nutritionist, or medical official, they will tell you that no matter what foods are being consumed; there is no health in eating the same thing over and over again. So if the ancient communities stayed relatively in the same areas for the majority of their lives, they would not have had as great of a diet as Diamond makes it out to be. Diamond even says that the modern “bushman” does not live the same way primitive beings did. To quote…
- 1556 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
In Michael Pollan’s essay “Escape from the Western Diet,” he informs Americans about the western diet and believes they need to escape from it. The reason Americans should escape the western diet is to avoid the harmful effects associated with it such as “western diseases” (Pollan, 434). To support his view on the issue, Pollan describes factors of the western diet that dictate what Americans believe they should eat. These factors include scientists with their theories of nutritionism, the food industry supporting the theories by making products, and the health industry making medication to support those same theories. Overall, Pollan feels that in order to escape this diet, people need to get the idea of it out of their heads. In turn he provides his own rules for escaping the western diet as well as the idea of nutritionism set forth by scientists.…
- 743 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
citizens still don’t have internet access to find the nutrition online, so he went in McDonald stores throughout Manhattan he found that only one in two McDonalds had nutrition information. McDonalds does not inform the negatives about eating their food. Morgan Spurlock stated “some of the McDonalds didn’t have any you can take home” and also stated “this nice manager brought me a nutrition chart- from the basement”. This goes to show you that McDonalds does not want you to find out about their nutritional information. It is hidden from the customers in remote places they won’t find about it. Thus our opinion about the food tasting good doesn’t change and they aren’t able to change our decision on whether we should continue to eat the food because we are not actually sure about if the food is actually bad for us. The idea of McDonalds not informing their customers is bothering because no one is doing anything about finding out and this will continue to get worse. To some people McDonalds is addicting to them, yet they are continuing to eat it because no one else has bothered to help find out why. So we’ll continue to keep going to McDonalds because they only inform the good things to…
- 755 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
To complicate the matter of meat consumption further, Professor Timothy Lang in a FAO article deduced that the challenge of defining sustainable diet is not just a matter of incorporating two scientific discourses i.e. public health and environment, due to the fact that food exhibits significant cultural and economic matter. Based on the article, Professor Lang asserted that, “part of the 20th century’s legacy is that it allowed us, in the name of progress, choice and individual rights, to develop an approach to food policy which saw no limits.” He claimed that long-established cultural orthodox, either religious or sometimes born from experience, have been imperceptibly overturned by consumerism coupled with substantially funded marketing. Therefore, the conflicts of human and environmental health is…
- 425 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
However, the unhealthy lifestyle should not be presented as something that is thoroughly impossible to tackle, before the food and diet industry have been brought to their knees. Each individual can change the society, since currently; everyone can gain a powerful voice through social media. This supposed helplessness that the people have grown accustomed to, this feeling of inferiority in the face of the big food companies is completely erroneous, and the way around it is not a ban on sugary sweets and a rise in sales, but plainly regulating your food and watching out for yourself. Boseley focuses on the wrong people throughout the article, when the real culprit in this story was in front of her the whole time. Georgia is not to blame for her obesity and neither is the company producing the fattening food, but her mother, who did not bother to give her daughter a balanced diet, but instead was irresponsible. She is far from the only parent or guardian in the western societies, who neglect their children in a subtle but harmful way, and it would not make Sarah Boseley’s other points any less true, if she simply admitted this…
- 1066 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays